Gyros in Exeter

We used 58 Main BBQ for our 10/11 wedding. Everyone raved about how good the food was, which was what was most important to us as far as food went, we wanted people to like the food and it definitely was a huge hit. The only downside was that not very many people ate the salad due the dressing being from dollar general. This was not discussed at our meetings as we thought the ranch and italian dressing would be made in house.

BBQ all the way! We had a party or 9 and were sat in the front part, which was very quiet and we were pretty much by ourselves. Although they keep the front door unlocked and a couple of time some questionable people came in and left within minutes, as of just using the restroom. There was no hostess or anyone in that area. Some what clean place. Bathroom not nice. Also our food arrived in four separate intervals. By the time everyone got their food the first person's food to arrive was cold. Food was decent, my pulled pork was on the dry side and also my brisket that they reheated was mainly burnt and inedible. Don't think I will revisit this establishment for a while of I do give them another shot.

I have tried this place multiple times and I keep hoping that u will walk away with a better impression, but I don’t. Yesterday, we went with 3 adults and 2 kids for early dinner. It wasn’t very busy being around 4pm on a Saturday but the service was just not good. We were seated at a table that had chunks of crusty food on it, but it was a table for 6 so I just didn’t sit at that part of the table. I had to ask for 4 different things 3+ times before each actually appeared at the table (I.e silverware, to go boxes, etc). When the food arrived, not one part of any of our meals was any warmer than lukewarm and some was downright cold. I am guessing that others have had better experiences but this was my last thought me giving them any of my money. I really wanted to have even one good experience here, but this place is not for me.

Definitely not as good as usual. Very long wait for food. Service as nothing special. Have had much better servers. Some of th food was over cooked

Food is decent service always seems slow unless your in the bar area.

One of my go-to spots in Brockport. Wide variety so easy to find something for my palate. And so close by. A friendly place with a full bar too.

We were there for the first time on Saturday night 14th . OMG we were very impressed with the service/ and what we had off of the menu / appetizers and our entrees . There is a very strong possibility that we will be “ repeat offenders “ 👍🏽👍🏽😊😊

Service was awsome but food was cold.

I was traveling for business, and always like to support local. The food was incredible, and the atmosphere is fun. I’ll definitely it’s come here again if I’m ever in Brockport in the future!

Awesome food. Great value. Friendly staff

HORRIBLE…. I called this morning asking for their hours and they said they were open until 9. I show up with a few friends at 8:25 and this lady comes out saying they close at 9, to which I look at my phone and say hey well it’s 8:25, to which she says “yeah it’s closed”…WHAT This is ridiculous and I’m only going back because I have a coupon here. I’ll update yall…

Nice, cute place. College town so a little loud but enjoyable! Food was great. Fresh, clean atmosphere

Food was great fast and friendly atmosphere plenty of tvs to watch private booths or tables in the bar area

Our server, Joe, is amazing!! We have been going to 58 Main for a long time and always request Joe. The service, food and atmosphere is wonderful!! Highly recommend anyone looking for a place to eat, go to 58 Main!!

Quaint little place in Brockport! Delicious BBQ, great portions! Good atmosphere.

The waitress is not the best one for this job. She just wanted us to leave. Never offered to refill the drinks or to get more beer. She was a big let down. The food is outstanding. The staff not so good, at least the host and the waitress we had.

Stopped by 8/10, and boy could they use a visit from John Tapper. Ordered the Memphis style Mac n Cheese, and the Buffalo chicken rolls for an appetizer. Appetizer and entrée came out together. The Memphis Mac n Cheese was a plate with 1/2" of congealed cheese on top of a hand full of ziti with a lot of Bar B Q sauce. I couldn't eat more than a few bites. Not sure if there was any Brisket in it. Looked like maybe some chipped beef buried deep down in there. My wife ordered the pulled pork sandwich, and it was just ok. If I were a waitress and saw the kitchen not time the appetizer and entrée I would have them make a new entrée and throw out the one he fired to early. Granted this was one bad entrée but you only get one chance to make a first impression.

"I recently had the pleasure of experiencing the catering services of Fifty Eight Main Street, and I must say, I was thoroughly impressed. The quality of the food was exceptional - fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Not only was the food delicious, but the portions were incredibly generous, ensuring that everyone left satisfied and content. What truly stood out to me was the impeccable service provided by Fifty Eight Main Street. From the initial inquiry to the actual event, the staff was professional, attentive, and went above and beyond to ensure that everything ran smoothly. Their dedication to customer satisfaction was truly commendable. Overall, I highly recommend Fifty Eight Main Street for any catering needs. Their combination of quality food, great service, and generous portions make them a standout choice for any event. Thank you, Fifty Eight Main Street, for making our company picnic a memorable and delicious experience!"

Their BbQ is delicious! And, the service was on point. Prices seemed a little high, till I saw what you get! Great place!

Our server was awesome. We had a party of 10 that received great service. Thank you.

Great BBQ, great Scotch Ale and great service!

Grilled wings with dry rub, were soggy on the outside and dry on the inside. I've been going here for 7+ years, and it's just getting worse everytime. Taste and feels like they're just precooking in the morning or night before and reheating it at this point; in my opinion.

Nice place to grab some Q. The garlic festival fries are amazing!!!

Very good hospitality but food was horrible and bland the greens was glory greens and Mac and cheese was horrible

We already decided to go back within the first few bits. Best BBQ

My favorite place to go for BBQ. This is a must go to stop for Mac and cheese.

From pa.come once a year to fish always come for BBQ! Great place.

58 Main catered a birthday party for us in Albion. The process was easy and smooth, the food was hot and delicious, and the customer service was A+. I had an issue with my card (this was my issue, not theirs) and Chris handled it it with grace and understanding. The solution was expeditious and very much appreciated.

We visited this restaurant for the first time today. It definitely won't be the last. We ordered the grilled chicken sandwich with fries, grilled chicken with garlic mashed potatoes and sides of salt potatoes, Caesar salad and coleslaw. Every single thing was delicious. The portions were bigger than expected. The service was great. (Our check said Everett helped us.) He checked on us often but not too much to be bothersome or intrusive. He brought over refills and to go containers without us asking. The atmosphere was cool and the music being played was great too. A hidden gem in Brockport and one I'm glad we found. Can't wait to go back.

I'm obsessed with the buffalo chicken wing dip! I add extra cheese on top, and they heat it up to make it a crispy cheese on top. It's scorching hot (exactly how I like my food to be). Definitely recommend giving it a try.

The BBQ joint to go to in Brockport. Service and food was good.

Brisketwech!!! With beef broth dip! Best ever!

Excellent food, service and a wide variety of local brews on tap and definitely check out the summer menu specials! Surf and Turf kebobs are wonderful!

Excellent food, service and atmosphere. Bar was hopping,food was excellent and our server was wonderful!

Would not recommend trying to cook seafood if you can’t do it. You serve wings.. stick to what you can handle.

Good barbecue. The choice of sides was amazing. Had 2 meals just from our leftovers.

You gotta get there wings. Get the smoked, fried, charbroiled. Get them either with the house sauce or the dry rub both are excellent. I have eaten here twice in 3 days. They are open late till midnight and the kitchen till around 10:30 or later. Go see the bartender Stephen he will make you all the delicious drinks you want. Excellent place will definitely be eating there on a regular.

I very rarely post negative reviews. I am very disappointed with my experience ordering take out from 58 main. We were in the area and decided to give it a try on our way home. We were told it would be 30 minutes for our order. We ended up waiting an hour and when we got home, half of our order was missing. We both ordered chicken wing dishes and on the menu it says they come with blue cheese and celery and I even asked on the phone call ordering to make sure. Neither of our orders came with celery or blue cheese. We were also missing sides that were requested and paid for. We called and addressed our concerns and they offered $20 off next time we’re there but quite frankly I would not go back there. The food was mediocre. I would not recommend this restaurant.

Food is always delicious. So far every order has been made correctly.

Great food and drinks every time.

This is a super friendly, casual restaurant with great food. I loved the atmosphere and since it’s within walking distance of where I just moved I think I just found my new hang out! Highly recommend the skewers!

Food was very good, travelled from Rochester here for my work anniversary with my co workers. I got the Ribs and Brisket with fries and Cajun corn. We got the wings for an appetizer, were very good. I had a minor slight issue with my ribs but it was remedied. Was even given wings to take home to grill which I’m cooking for my wife now. I would recommend this place 💪🏽

We live very close to 58 main and it's so good. I'm never disappointed with anything. They have great bar an pub food. My favorite thing to get there is the Ruben. It's so good.

Awesome BBQ joint here in Upstate, NY!! You won't be disappointed!

Multiple menu items & summer menu also. The service & food was good but, the draft taps were out of service - all good Modelo to the rescue

Great place to watch the game. We ordered smoked meats, ribs needed more time, and chicken needed more time. The pulled pork was ok, but it was more like ground pork than pulled. Portion size was good a lot of food. Staff was great.

Went for the Mother's Day buffet. To say that everyone was impressed would be an understatement. The food was amazing. So many options and the buffet was kept full the entire time (we were part of the last seating of the day, still plenty of everything). Thank you to the staff that obviously worked super hard to put on such a great buffet.

An absolutely great local barbecue joint. The menu is extensive. The brisket was very good and the portion size for the platter was very generous. I left with that oh I ate too much feeling, and there was food left on my plate. I just could not finish all they have me. The dessert menu was hidden in plain sight on the napkin holder. This place was hopping the whole time we were there. I would definitely go here again.

Amazing food, along with amazing service. A+ place to grab some delicious bbq

Manager took care of us and made sure we had a great experience even after she was berated by a self entitled wasp that had way too much to drink at the countryclub before dining.

One of our "Go To" places. They have specials and a good menu selection.

Amazing bbq and mac n cheese. The pulled pork will melt in your mouth. They sell their bbq sauce by the jar which is excellent. Highly recommend as the staff and food is excellent

Just bland food, it was hot but nothing gave me the sense of smoked anything

Cook certainly knows what he's doing. Ambitious menu. Service was lacking when busy. I wish I had time to really go through the desserts. they sound great.

The food was very ...not good. The pulled pork was somehow crumbly and not pulled at all. Disappointing flavors and textures with the meats and sides. (The Caesar salad came with maybe Italian dressing? I wasn't sure?)

The wings and Ribs !!!! Soooo good !!!

On our way back from Rochester we thought we'd grab a bite to eat uptown Brockport, but forgot the bridge was out. GLADLY SO! We looked at Pizza Hut and saw 58 Main BBQ across the street. Hey!? We never saw this place and thought it would be a perfect choice. SO GLAD WE DID! We entered through the front door and were quickly directed to the Hostess in the back of the restaurant. The front was possibly family dining at dinning room table style. Through the side door (which seems to be the proper entry door) you will be greeted by the Hostess and sat in the bar/dining area. Ample tall tables and stools. Nice atmosphere and set up well for watching sports via several televisions along the walls. Loved the unique neon beer signs, as well. I saw outside tall tables for dining in good weather. Our waitress, Michelle, was an absolute sweet heart. Our orders were taken, drinks brought, and we were checked with for further needs . . just enough. Our orders brought to the table on the small aluminum baker pans. The food was fresh, hot, and delicious. I enjoyed "The 58" a Grilled smoked ham & turkey breast, hickory smoked bacon, melted provolone cheese & sweet honey mustard sauce on a pressed grilled sub roll. The meats were hand cut, not sliced. They were tender and delicious! My husband enjoyed the ¼ RACK COMBO with home fries, beans, baked apples, and corn bread. The ribs were super tender and there was ample sauce. We've already recommended the restaurant to friends and we definitely plan on returning.

The food was amazing. It got very crowded as we were leaving with people everywhere, but other than that, 5 stars all the way. Very impressed!

We went there on March 23 2024 and the food was not good at all. Not sure what the issues are because we've always had a good meal in the past. The mashed potatoes tasted like some one dump pure vinegar into it. The ribs were very thin, dry and cold. The wings seemed like they were reheated because they had an odd texture to them.My daughter got the pulled pork nachos and the waitress asked her if she wanted just regular nachos without the pork and she said sure. Well the pulled pork nachos are 17 dollars so they charged us 17 dollars for just a hand full of chips with barley any cheese on the chips. Overall the meals were cold, dried out and for some reason everything tasted like vinegar. Except for what ever that hot wet mess they have for pulled pork. Unfortunately my family and I will not be going back

Food was absolutely horrible.. The BBQ meat was old, especially the ribs. Waitress was great and the atmosphere was a typical sports bar. Was very disappointed in food being first time there.

Food was great and the staff was exceptional A++ folks.

We have group of 8-20 people once a week for lunch. 58 Main BBQ works for us.

One of my favorite places to eat when in Brockport! Great BBQ food, good service, relaxed casual atmosphere.

Food was great, servers were very friendly 🙂

Service was lousy and unfriendly most of the food was ok, ribs were tough to chew. I like to support the small town places but this was really lacking

We enjoyed the drinks and atmosphere here, service was friendly and on point and was very busy when we came for dinner. Chicken wings were really good, but we didn't enjoy the pulled pork or brisket could have been an off night but service made up for it

Outstanding! The food is great, prices are good. Service is always above and beyond. We love when Cheryl takes care of us, but all of the staff is very friendly and accomodating.

Touring Brockport college and stopped here for lunch. It was an amazing find and we'll certainly be going back. The burger was so good, I wish I could give it more stars! Food, service and atmosphere were great, highly recommend.

Very nice bbq joint. Choice of bar area or quieter family dining room. Mix and match bbq menu with something for everyone. Kids menu. Clean bathrooms.

Food is always great as are the people who work there!!! Thanks for the good service Joe ;)

Great food, amazing staff. The smoked wings are some of the best wings I've ever had. Love this place.

Food was subpar when it comes to barbecue. Had several problems there wait staff is horrible management is not existent. Heaven forbid you suggest some advice in regards to service and food you will be sorely let down

Amazing food, service and worth the trip!!

Great food, great service and a lively mood. One of the best, if not the best, places to eat in Brockport

I keep coming back for the wings (smoked, grilled, and fried). They're addicting.

We ate here tonight and my brisket burger was a “bubba burger” I’m not sure why they had to ask how I wanted my burger cooked because it was a frozen patty that could never be cooked medium. The cheese was sprinkled on top not melted. The meat hot sauce was also weird. We usually love the food but it has been off recently. Our server was excellent.

Should be one star because of the food. A beer is a beer but when it comes to food they just don't have what it takes to be a legit BBQ joint. The past 5 times we gave them a chance the Food was usually room temperature. It seems like the food can be better but they just dont know how to.

Last time we went here was 2 years ago. Brisket tastes old and reheated no pink smoke ring vowed never to go again but we thought we'd try it again. Same thing brisket all gray tasted old and reheated and they just poured bbq all over the meat. Not cooked on. This time we won't go again! Award winning bbq must be only when they compete cause it's sure not in the dinners

An extremely untrustworthy establishment. I cannot deny, 58 Main has very good food. I'm not a big BBQ fan but their food is very delicious. However, I do not expect to give this place my business ever again and I must advise others weigh the risks. 58 Main is not a trustworthy establishment because of two instances. 58 Main charges an exorbitant gratuity charge and still requests a tip from their customers. The gratuity charge was at least 20% and we were a party of only 3 people, operating on only 2 different checks. None of us were pleased by this. If you dine at 58 Main, be aware your bill will likely be higher than expected. However, the true instance that has ruined my trust in 58 Main occurred outside its walls, but concerned a employee/representative of 58 Main. 58 Main sponsors a local wrestling promotion who in turn sponsors them. From what I understand they work together and are in close contact with one another. At their most recent wrestling event, a man wearing a 58 Main work shirt attended the wrestling event and was extremely indecent. The wrestling event offers people such as myself to to purchase table space and sell wares. This man was caught stealing from me, groping several of the women wrestlers and was caught lurking in the women's bathroom before ultimately being removed from the premises by event security. I was personally robbed by this representative, my father and friend witnessed the groping of the women wrestlers and the lurking in the women's bathroom situation and his removal was personally confirmed to me by one of the event organizers' fianceé. The same fianceé also helped me address the issues at hand and she strongly, strongly inferred to me when we discussed this person's menace to the event, that this person was indeed a representative of 58 Main. To what end this was futher addressed is beyond me. Now I am more than willing to discuss this matter further privately with 58 Main in the event I am mistaken in any of the finer details regarding this person, but with what I witnessed and the information provided to me by event staff, I am confident that this person was a representative of 58 Main. I simply cannot in good conscience support a business that employs people who actively steal and harass women at an event that they themselves mutually sponsor. There is simply no trust and I must warn other potential customers of this untrustworthy nature.

The food was delicious. We had the smoked wings and the pulled pork nachos. Both were huge portions. The restaurant has seating at the bar, in the open at tables, and in semi-private booths. The prices were reasonable. There were 10-12 craft beers available on the menu. The server was pleasant and offered menu recommendations.

This place was amazing. I had a BBQ combo with pork, brisket and ribs. All amazing. Mac and cheese was so good!

Went here with my mother when she cane to visit me in college and ordered a burger. The food was great tasting but had a hair in it and the beer was flat. I asked for a new beer and that one was flat as well. I figured hey i might have just come on a bad day and as i have eaten here before a few years ago and it was amazing. However when i went back with my brother i ordered a different sandwich and it had a hair in it AGAIN and the beer was still flat and lifeless. Sadly i will not be going back as i originally had a great experience but having hair in your food on multiple visits calls into question their food safety standards

You have to get the smoked, fried, grilled wings with the house sauce 🤌🏻

Got the wrong flavored wings served to us but they were still good. The smoked fried and grilled wings are the best wing you'll ever eat.

Picked up dinners to go and they were actually pretty disappointing. Won't be revisiting any time soon.

Great food,great service,great place overall

Wings were average. Your typical wing, i did not try the smoked wings. Blue cheese was different but good. BBQ Ribs and pulled pork were not good. My wife did not like them either. Flavor was bad, could not eat had to throw away. This was take out. Everyone was nice, food was ready for me, no other complaints.

I always get a 3/4 rack of ribs. The bbq sauce is sooooo good. Yum yum

Great place! Nice atmosphere and the staff is nice and accommodating! I’ve been a few times when I go visit my Brockport student.

Food was fine, atmosphere was fun and the staff was amazingly efficient and friendly. We came for parents weekend and we will absolutely be back.

The food was great! The waitress was kind and efficient. The drinks were yummy. We had coco Loco frozen coffee type Pina colada YUM...and bloody Mary's 😋 the bill was around $120 for 4 people which is about avg especially with multiple drinks. We would and plan to go again!

Great service, spicy wings and good margaritas!

Everything was good. We will be returning

It was great. Very nice menu with many choices for all tastes. Our server was excellent.

I didn’t know what to expect since I’m not from brockport but nyc. I have to say hands down the food was amazing !!!!! I ordered the three cheese chicken sandwich with a side of Mac and cheese with a side of hot sauce. Had the wings too and they were amazing. Perfectly crispy! The only complaint would be the Shirley temple that was mid but yes great spot !

my first time here and i can definitely say, come here if you're a meat person and a sauce person! i really liked how friendly everyone looked and was. the food was very good. i normally like my fries salty but these fries don't need salt, 10/10 on there own. the food is very filling. our waiter was super honest and nice! it's 4 stars because it look long to get us out food but that's cause we ordered 2 sample plates and kettle chips.

Always delicious. Fast service and friendly atmosphere

I've food was fantastic,I had the smoked wings with Cajun fries,a side salad corn bread and scalloped apples.the flavors were fantastic.

Service tends to change based on the day and time, as does quality, but it's still a solid pick me up for lunch or dinner. The portions are quite large. ***Updated 3/11/22*** Service was amazing, the food was on point and the prices were great. Some of us from the office went for lunch and we intend to go back again soon! Our server was absolutely great.

I was hoping for some good BBQ. Ribs were precooked and barely luke warm, garlic potatoes were also left over crumbly and dry. The smothered pulled pork beans were pork and beans with BBQ stopped on top. Definitely not at all what was expected. Nothing was hot if barely luke warm.