Casa Nostra Restaurant in Sutton - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Everyone enjoyed their food and it's good that on some of the dishes a smaller option is available for those with a smaller appetite. Friendly atmosphere. Do wish they had home made desserts ( which they used to years ago) rather than the ready made ones.

Love this place. Staff are friendly, food is always great and big portion sizes.

the best Italian I’ve ever had, make sure you book as there always full, so many things on the menu to try and then there’s the specials board, spoilt for choice and the flavour of everything is done supremely, puddings out of this world

Great restaurant! Awesome atmosphere! Service was so attentive, extremely quick, and very personable. This place is a must visit when in Sutton! We may make this our regular spot.

Horrible food! Definitely not Italian! We ordered some pizzas and the dough was definitely shop bought not properly cooked! I lived in Italy for 6 years and traveled extensively I know what a good pizza is! Also, service was horrible everyone was trying to do some bad taste jokes. My toddler was with us and watching some cartoons one of the waiter came and turned it of! I mean… why would you ever touch my phone in first place. Anyway it is not Italian food everything about this place was horrible

I don't know how I didn't know about this gem of a restaurant before! I can't remember the last time I had such an amazing time when out to eat. The staff are amazing, they made us feel welcome and even had some jokes "on the menu"! The food was delicious and I wanted to try so many but I could only eat one thing because the portions are really generous. We had a birthday in our group and they made a really big fuss and the whole restaurant sang for her - we loved every second! If you are looking for a place with great food and amazing atmosphere then I totally recommend Casa Nostra in Sutton! I'm definitely going back!!

What a fantastic restaurant all staff are amazing friendly treat you like you've known them for ever food was excellent great portion size atmosphere was incredible all staff join in dancing singing with customer s it's amazing would highly recommend booking a table here you will not be disappointed wish other restaurant establishment s were as great can't wait to return

Brilliant restaurant. Great food and friendly staff. They always make you feel so comfortable and nothing is too much trouble for them

This spot was recommended by our friends and needless to say, it did NOT disappoint. Firstly, make sure to get a reservation for dinner service, otherwise you will be disappointed with the wait time. Right from the moment they showed us to our table, the staff were very friendly, welcoming and their antics were hilarious. Pity I do not remember the names of the three gentlemen who serves us but even if you don’t like real delicious Italian, you should visit just for the service. We ordered the “Pasta of the Day”, Salmon, Lasagna and Mango & Avocado Crab. So so so good. Words cannot express how amazing it was. A must visit if you are in the area or even if you are willing to travel a bit for the food. You will not be disappointed.

The best Italian restaurant in Sutton. Staff is friendly, you can feel like at home. Food is delicious 😋

Food was absolutely delicious. The staff are hilarious, spot on Italian vibe. Loved the busy atmosphere and food. Would go again and again

Very friendly, helpful staff. They make you feel at home. We had a lovely meal and would definitely go back again.

Wow, the food service was outstanding. I had the special was so so so good. It was busy so would recommend booking but the staff are so wonderful I'm sure they would welcome you regardless. Well done Casa Nostra wonderful team beautiful food.

The staff are friendly and warm. One shared with me how to take care of his cuddly teddy when he saw my rabbit. Please remember to see if any daily special. We are so lucky to have mango, avocado with crab and prawns. The fresh sweet mangoes are from their garden! Also, don’t miss their desserts! Thank you for the lovely lunch today xx

Nice place , nice food with excellent service

Superb little place. Great food, very friendly and a great atmosphere

I absolutely love this cozy restaurant, the food is top notch, the service fabulous and the atmosphere so fun. I highly recommend.

Warm welcome for a weekday dinner. Fast and impeccable service. Excellent wines and good dishes (pizza + and pasta carbonara a little less) Very good time, a place that I recommend.

Must try the "espetada". A deliciously seasoned beef skewer.

Food, service and atmosphere great

We booked a table for our wedding guests . The staff were absolutely amazing with the children. Really did feel very special eating here . The food was nice . The staff really friendly and made a huge effort . My daughter keeps asking if she can go back to the cafd with the sweet shop . Win win if kids are happy to .thank you to all the staff at Casanostra for helping make our day special . Serena and Dwayne (and guests )

Staff very enthusiastic and friendly. Food amazing. Must try it. Absolute 10 out of 10.

The food was delicious, but it can be better in some areas. The service was top notch, and the wait staff were hilarious and very friendly. I recommend this restaurant to anyone who likes Italian food and we all enjoyed it very much. Wouldn't mind going there again.

Great evening with the girls celebrating my birthday, the food and service were great.

I thoroughly enjoyed visiting Casa Nostra for an Italian meal. I had a starter and main from the specials board and then an affogato coffee. The waiters were personable and that is part of the charm of this place.

Wonderful experience from start to finish. I ate there solo, but saw how happy groups were enjoying their Easter dinner. I had Fried Whitebait, Salad, appetizer portion of Spaghetti Puttanesca, and Veal Milanese. The Whitebait was an experiment for me, never had before, but it was crispy and good to me, although honestly have no frame of reference to judge it. The things I can judge are the tasty Puttanesca sauce, delicious. And the veal, pounded thin, fried perfectly. Excellent.

Love the goodbut can get very noisy if you are on a date. But very nice.

Outstanding delicious proper Italian staff are ever so friendly food is decent priced well worth the money the salad is also beautiful definitely reccomend garlic bread 🤤

Absolutely fantastic. We booked for 20 for my Mums 84th Birthday. The staff were fantastic as was the food. The restaurant really gave my Mum a birthday to remember. Would highly recommend

An absolutely brilliant Italian restaurant. Excellent service with a hint of comedic banter. The food was delicious and filling. Great value for money.

Nice people, scallops, and prawns were fantastic. The potatoes were good, too. The bread was amazing.

This place is like going back in time and I love it Waiters sing at your table if it's your birthday - make cheesy, fantastic jokes. The food is exactly what you expect and that is perfect for this establishment.

Absolutely fabulous Valentine's evening. Food was delicious, staff very friendly, all in all wonderful.

Great Italian restaurant,super food and very friendly staff. Would highly recommend 👍

Such an amazing restaurant from the food, the staff, the atmosphere all the way to the vibe!! I had such an amazing time here with such lovely staff to make me feel so welcome Highly recommend here for any event, or even just an evening out

Never disappoints. Well done Silvio and the team 💯 👌

We were very impressed by the exceptional food quality from their kitchen. Staff were super friendly and passionate to serve and customers are immersed in its vibrant atmosphere. Food all came in much bigger portion than expected, for instance there were 3 scallops and prawns respectively in the appetizer, and seafood risotto contained generous mussels, prawns and risotto rice. Pepperoni Pizza was hugely stuffed and cheese-loaded very delicious! All in all a very reasonable priced restaurant in its best quality. Will re-visit if ever in the community again!

Excellent food as always. Efficient, helpful & friendly staff helped add to the cheery atmosphere. Thoroughly enjoyed it & would of course recommend.

Lovely service from these two gentlemen and great food! Thank you so much. We will be returning 😋

Fantastic place. Had a great 70th birthday there

They were closed on Tuesday as few days before Xmas

Good food, good service and good entertainment

A brilliant afternoon spent with wonderful friends in this excellent restaurant, food was to die for, staff make a fantastic atmosphere and you are made to feel part of the family. Happy Birthday Casa Nostra from Marika and her party of four.

Food was great.steak on a skewer was the highlight for me

Very good food and reasonable prices.

Excellent! Great place! Food was stunning! Highly recommended

Our group of 7 had a lovely experience at Casa Nostra. The food was excellent and the staff are so warm and welcoming.

Rubbish Portugueses restaurant, it is not Italian restaurant and the food is rubbish and frozen sea food is no fresh. I am not recommend this place, and it is similar to others around there

Works Xmas party, food really really nice and plentiful. Service was good too.

We had a lovely night out here, the food was lovely and the staff were very friendly and entertaining.

Great night out and lovely food I had the brushette, lasagne and mint chocolate bomb all delicious and great value for money

Best restaurant so far! Love the food, the service, the atmosphere.

Larmende, overfriske tjenere og kedelig mad.

Excellent service and delicious food

The food just tastes average, only the pizza is more authentic. I ordered aglio olio, but the pasta was very soft and didn't feel authentic. I'm a bit disappointed, if you can't eat authentic pasta in an Italian restaurant.

Great atmosphere, went there to celebrate a 40th birthday. Everyone enjoyed their food and GF options were available

Absolutely amazing. My friends Hannah and Dan got married, Bit salty that Hannah stole Dan off me but is what it is. Food was incredible and staff were very friendly. Would definitely recommend to anyone who would like to indulge in exquisite Italian cuisine

We had nice family dinner plus my daughter's birthday celebration 🎉

Really good food and friendly service. I think if there would have been some music in the background, the overall atmosphere would have been much nicer and warmer :)

Service & food was outstanding as ALWAYS!!!

Always good food and great service.

Perfect Italian restaurant friendly service with amazing quality food

Always great food and an amazing atmosphere

My daughter (Kim) and I had two great meals. The staff are great and fun, wonderful atmosphere. Will definitely go if in the area again, can highly recommend this restaurant.

I've never been to Italy, but I imagine it would be just like this! Fabulous food, and the staff feel like family by the end of your meal. Everyone is amazing. Well worth a visit.

We have been going to this restaurant over 10 years now and they never been disappointed. Food is always great and delicious always too fun for desert!! My son always goes for the steak I go for linguine with tiger prawns and sun dried tomatoes flavours are alway consistent!

Visited Casa Nostra last Friday evening for my hysbabds birthday The food was amazing, the staff were fantastic we are a family if five nothing was too much trouble. And the cake and candle for my husband with the whole restaurant singing happy birthday was a lovely touch. Thank you so much to all staff, we will definitely be visiting again.

Great restaurant with very good food been going for a few years now and it's still our go to favourite for value and quality

A lovely restaurant that you'll definitely need to book in advance as it's very popular! The food is amazing and the staff are very charming, love it here.

Great friendly atmosphere and good food, will definitely go back

5* probably the best Italian I have ever eaten at. Great menu at reasonable prices plus voluminous specials . Food was amazing, service was warm friendly and welcoming. Can't say enough good things.

Went with my husband for dinner as we had heard good things about this restaurant and we were not disappointed. Would recommend you try it

A lovely, welcoming establishment. The food is fresh, delicious and authentic. The staff are friendly, funny and extremely helpful and family friendly. It is now out new local. Cannot rate it enough.

Lovely food, friendly staff and they weren’t kidding when they said best Irish coffee!!

I can't decide if I like the food or the staff better! So let's start with the staff, because they make up for 99% of the atmosphere and they are doing a damn good job: they are fast, they are brilliant, they joke around with the customers in a very friendly and witty way. They are just amazing! And the food... part of the menu changes but it never disappoints! They have some amazing dished which are just addictive, and fish dishes are to die for! Overall, as someone who has been to Casa Nostra a few times, I do highly recommend it, its a gem!

The food is good, but its the service and the atmosphere that we go here for

Another lovely family meal for my son’s birthday. The staff are friendly , helpful and engaging and the food is always delicious. You would be hard pushed to find a better Italian . Great place for a celebration.

Really disappointed with the behaviour of the staff. They thought it was funny to frequently drop several metal trays in the restaurant to make a loud clattering sound, which made the customers jump!! I must have jump 3 to 4 times during my visit. I suffer from Tinnitus and this behaviour has caused a flare up 😭 It's such a shame they behave like this because the food was nice and the restaurant was packed. It is a VERY NOISY restaurant. It was very hard to hear what our group were saying over the noise.

The loveliest Italian food outside Italy. Taste, presentation, and service is fantastic.

Had a lovely lunch here. Pasta of the day was very tasty and spaghetti vongole as well. Bruscetta nice and garlicky. They have nice doors what open all the way,it is so nice to sit during nice weather.The best part was the service, could not fault it. Although all the other customers seemed to be regulars, we were greeted and treated the same! So nice, thank u, recommend!

You can't go wrong here -from the welcome to the goodbye ! The staff are superb -all of them- the food is superb in fact its close to amazing! The prices are realy good for food and wine -considering your near to London! Atmosphere is superb,they do a free cake for birthdays-plus a song by everyone . It was so good the first night -we headed back the next night and managed to get in . It's busy -so booking is defo an option -to avoid disappointment. Can heartily recommend either the veal or the fillet rossini-you won't get better. Recommend easily !

A little gem. Very good food and friendly entertaining staff. If I lived closer I would be a regular! Highly recommended.

The shape of the eating place is appropriate

Great staff, Friendly and attentive. I found three of our meals mediocre to be honest which was a shame.

Very noisy and as they were so busy, the waiting staff struggled a bit with the orders.

We've tried several Italian restaurants in UK. The best of the best one is Casa Nostra Restaurant (Sutton) undoubtedly.😍🥰🤩🥰😍 My beloved Mum and Wife have both celebrated their happy birthday here. All Casa Nostra staffs are passionate guys and served us with great pleasure. My relatives and friends all are satisfied with the birthday dinner.😋🎉🎂🎊😋 The Italian style foods and chef recommendations items are delicious. We'll most likely to come back here again when we've gathering next time. Cheers.🍽🍻🍺🍻🍽

Great food, great staff and great atmosphere

Food a little salty but apart from that, very good and good prices for the portions.

Great atmosphere. Great owners. Great service.

I’ve seen this place on my last visit to the area, I had to try it this time and my oh my was I extremely surprised. The food was almost like home cooking and the Waiters all had there own personality which made you feel so welcome. I couldn’t decide on pasta and the chef let me have half of each! I can’t wait to come back and try more dishes

I have lived in London for over 11 years. and visited many restaurants. But my favorite is Cosa Nostra. Today we celebrated a birthday and, as always, everything was at the highest level. Many thanks to the Silvio and Luis team. You are the best. I recommend for everyone.

Had a wonderful evening at this wholesome Italian cuisine restaurant!! Shared the feast with 13 friends to celebrate a 50th birthday! What a treat and what delicious food!! I had the sirloin steak on a hanging skewer and I'm glad I did. The food envy from all at the table was palpable!! The starter....prawn and scallops was also to die for....the best seafood sauce I've ever had....so rich, creamy and packed with umami flavour!! Deffo recommend this delightful restaurant!!

Waiters were funny and charming. Homely atmosphere...just right for a chatty evening with a dear friend!

Delicious food - love their calzone, polpette and desserts. Staff are friendly and humorous. Atmosphere always appears to be vibrant.

Fabulous authentic Italian, food was perfect and the portions were big. The mussels were beautiful, my main of veal was one of the best I've had in a long time. The staff were excellent, fantastic atmosphere. Great for a special occasion. Definitely returning soon

Love coming here. Excellent quality food and generous portions. Highly recommend any of their fish dishes or the sardines starter. The staff are super fun and add to the whole experience (pictures for proof!). Thanks for another great meal Casa Nostra!

Best restaurant locally without a doubt. Fantastic food and staff, lovely atmosphere. A must visit!

Friendly staff and delicious food

This place is incredible. Great food. The waiters are absolutely hilarious and will crack jokes and mess with you in a fun and playful way. Amazing experience.

Cosy little restaurant. Quality food and very friendly staff :)