Bonnie & Wild's Scottish Marketplace in Edinburgh, City of

The fish and chips from Creel Caught was grossly overpriced for a piece of fish you would expect to pick up at Farmfoods and low quality frozen chips. Even the mushy peas were awful. To say I was disappointed is an under statement when I saw the quality of the other dishes that my family had. Will be back at Bonnie and Wild but you can be sure I will be giving Creel Caught a wide berth.

Encontramos be&W bastante por accidente cuando se mira alrededor de un lugar para tomar un bocado rápido de almuerzo. Habíamos estado cerca un par de veces antes y asumimos que era un restaurante. No puedo creer que me haya perdido este lugar todo este tiempo. Hay una gran variedad de opciones de comida internacional y escocesa. Fuimos a Leith Wok y tuvimos deliciosos platos de pollo y arroz de cerdo - humeante caliente y muy sabroso. La gente con la que he hablado desde entonces tampoco sabía que Bonnie & Wild es un comedor (¡con una diferencia!). Casi me discutía entre callarme egoístamente y contarle a la gente sobre este lugar, pero para ser justos con los negocios allí, creo que su perfil debería ser elevado (tal vez be&W debería tener una idea sobre la publicidad y capitalizar el paso) ya que creo que mucha gente todavía no es consciente de lo que realmente se ofrece. Esperamos con interés mi próxima visita. Consejo: tome sus bebidas del bar antes de pedir comida.

Este es un gran lugar para visitar si todos quieren comer algo diferente! La comida está lista cuando está lista, así que no esperes comer al mismo tiempo que tu fiesta. En general, la comida era buena, el servicio en el bar no era exactamente amable más funcional.

Preciosa comida. Teníamos una pasta de pescado, sal y pollo frío y una botella de vino por menos de £ 40 y era todo encantador. Tuvimos que hacerlo, pero valió la pena

En Leith Wok, último restaurante dentro de los muchos mini restaurantes, entrada de rollo de primavera de pato, pollo Chow Mein, recién cocinado y absolutamente delicioso. 💯

Great idea if family would like to eat various different types of food - good way to keep everyone happy There wad a long queue when we arrived but it moved quickly and there were six of us Pointed to a table in the distance the its basically a bit of a dash everyone going n different directions some piled high with food !! My husband and I decided on the Seafood Platter - Staff not really interested butt gave us buzzer and we waited. On arrival food was presented reasonably well - though Prawns poor quality and swimming in watery sauce. Smoked salmon probably was the best on the plate -sure they could do better as one very small langoustine just looked lost. Pate was ok and skinny fries were fine

We stopped for lunch at the Creel & Caught ,had fish and chips and tacos We have been regular customers for some time however have notice on our last visit that the service /presentation and portion size has changed and not for the better I’m afraid to say ,girl at the till could barely look at me on taking the order .The fish was small and placed on a very small amount of chips with no peas as apparently this is an extra now ,definitely not worth £14.95 the tacos came with absolutely nothing on the plate ,presentation very poor .will not return to what was always our favourite place to stop for lunch .

A wonderful experience everytime I come. This is not my first time, but it's about time I actually write up a review of the place! When you go in, you are greeted with a wide range of various food stalls, from chicken to Chinese and more. Once seated, you can order your drinks to your table. Unfortunately though when me and my bestie visited, this option was unavailable. But you can easily walk up to the lovely bar and be served. (And to the Irish guy who served us, you were wonderful, sorry for the confusion haha). My choice everytime for coming here is from Salt & Chili, and is the Katsu Chicken Curry. So insanely good, with delicious spices. My friend got chicken tenders and waffle fries from Chooks, which were amazing. Ended the evening with ice cream from Jo's Gelato, not a first during my trip this time, but they have probably the best ice cream around. If you don't go in for a meal, I recommend walking in just for an ice cream to take out! Plenty of choices to choose from. Perfect for those who like to have a variety of choice when it comes to food!

Popped in for a quick coffee as I was early for a meeting. When the coffee arrived it had over spilled into the saucer. When I went and asked for a napkin to clean I was told they didn’t have any and would have to go and get from another outlet. I politely asked the server to get for me and when they arrived they were thrown down in front of me. Will never return.

We saw a queue whilst in the shopping centre and looking for food so not familiar with the place. After a Google search queued to try it out, the wait was short though once in wasn't sure what we were supposed to do next. We were directed (not shown) by pointing to a higher seat based up the back and we sat down to what we assumed was the correct seat even though there were empty, lower seats around us. We looked at the menu that directs you to QR codes one for food menus and one for drinks however message stated unable to take online orders to the bar. Okay so after locating the table number headed to the bar for £3.75 for a small bottle of juice and was instructed to go to my food venue of choice to order food. We decided on fish tacos for £10.50 and cod in a bag for £14.95 with a side of fries. You are given a buzzer to collect your own food, which was nerve-wracking going through crowds with a tray of food. It's expensive for what you get. Food tasted good though portions sizes small and tacos were served cold, cod was served with nice veg but swimming in a greasy sauce. Still hungry we decided on a gelato cone, again nice enough but pricey at £3.95 a cone. All in all it was a new experience, similar to ordering from Wetherspoons with expectation of better food die to higher price tag but it wasn't an overall brilliant experience

Great place to visit with young kids (8and 9) the wide choice of food can please most palate’s, the only reason I’m marking it down is the pricey bar prices. The food is very reasonably priced. I noticed some knowledgeable locals taking advantage of the free water station. The shopping centre itself is eye opening for country bumpkins like us.

If you are happy running around to collect your own food & drink then OK, but not for me. Bar is pricey as they only serve schooner measures (which is 75% of a pint) but at pint prices. But main concern is that the food outlet leaves your order on a shelf for you to collect, whilst at the same time people are placing their orders over yours. Not hygenic as the order can lay there some time before you can collect it whilst people are talking, shouting, coughing etc. over it! They should leave the order under the shelf, not on it.

We really liked this place and went twice on our short visit to Edinburgh the food was excellent and dining area was spotless

Amazing! Me and my daughter got the Chicken Katsu from Salt & Chilli and it was full of flavour and I would def order that again. My daughter then had a biscoff pancake which was beyond tasty and surprisingly large. We ended up sharing it due to the size, which I’m not complaining about ha ha. We are looking forward to visiting the next time we are in Edinburgh!

Excellent food all with a variety of restaurants and cuisines there is something for every tastebud in here. Would visit again.

I don't understand why they decided to build a new shopping mall but make the main food court so small. The Q to go in then the wait to find a table. Just really bad planning. The food was ok but expensive and it's a shame as I like the concept. Thinking the planning team will be regretting the small size in years to come and they will have to find a way to expand the space as not fit for purpose.

Wanted a bite to eat before the theatre, but didn't want a sit-down restaurant meal. First time here, no queue at 1130am on a Saturday. Wandered round looking at all the menus. My mum and I decided to share a burger & chips from El Perro Negro, and the banana/ oreo pancakes from Stack & Still. Given buzzers, and within 5 minutes both had buzzed. Enjoyed the burger and chips. The pancakes were delicious. Bar is quite pricey, so we just had a soft drink. Left at 1230ish, large queue had formed at the entrance....it was good, but I wouldn't queue to come

Had lunch in soup and caboodle. Excellent choice of soups with a large sourdough roll. We all enjoyed our lunches. Very accessible for all major city attractions. Can't wait to return.

Nice concept. We choose from Salt and Chilli Oriental menu sorry but was disappointing tasteless and nothing original or remotely HK dining. Try different vendor if l return

Amazing food quality, me and my partner came here for dinner tonight. The staff had been incredibly kind to me and my partner, who is pregnant. Food quality had been delicious at this venue. High quality

Went to the Fish Restaurant Cheel Caught and ordered some crispy calamares.They came soft.Got another portion and the same.Can not believe that this restaurant is recommended for there food.

This rating would be a one if the manager hadn’t been so very sorry and actioned our complaint as best he could. My brother is diabetic and I overheard 3 staff members talking about him and his injection feet from our table. The staff continued to stare at us while passing by, sniggering and smirking to each other. I had no idea what the issue was and honestly thought that no way this was about us because they were discussing the ‘problem’ so close to our table. I went to a manager who told me I was correct, they were talking about my brother and that they thought he was going to the bathroom with a vape. The manager really done his best in the moment to turn this around but I still feel upset about the whole situation. Food is great but the attitude and respect of the staff is not.

This was a new experience for me. The food hall has a variety of restaurants and street food kitchens to choose from and you and your friends choose any table then can select food from any venue. I chose the Creel Caught platter from Creel Caught - smoked salmon, prawn Marie Rise, smoked mackerel pâté, hot smoked salmon, langoustine, olives, cornicing, celeriac Arran mustard slaw and brown bread (£14.95). My friend chose the Katsu Chicken Bao and Salt Chilli Fries from Salt & Chilli Oriental (£9.90) and a pancake from Stack and Still (£2.75 for a single with toppings at extra cost). Wine from the main bar The Hauf & Howff is quite expensive but the Sauvingon Blanc was tasty. I will definitely be back.

There are quite a few different eating places in this one building. Would please most people I would expect. We only wanted a light lunch so had some pancakes from Stack and Still. Both savoury and sweet are available and cooked fresh. Would like to try some of the street food places that were there next time we go.

We had southern fried calamari which was like rubber and was tasteless. We complained to the staff and told them it was overcooked and was like rubber. They were great and cooked us another one. Unfortunately it was exactly the same and they replaced the with a piece of fish which was very nice. Obviously a very poor product, which was suprising from a restaurant called Creel Caught owned or endorsed by Gary Maclean! We won't be back but commend the staff on their handling of the problem.

I was impressed when I first entered the market place - it looks fab (sparkley) and lots of delicious food options to choose from.. I felt less impressed after paying £7.95 for a small glass of wine! After purusing the menus online, I eventually decided on Creel Caught as it sounded high end, fresh and tasty. I was wrong! Received what was basically a fish burger and chips in a plastic basket and paid £14 for the privilege. Chips were just chips nothing special, fish in the burger was okish but ruined by the plastic basket lined with paper that got ripped and mixed in with the food. Burger bread was average at best and there was no sign of the dark crab mayonnaise? Left feeling bloated and extremely disappointed. High end prices and distinctly average food. Its unlikely I will return.

This was our family day to Edinburgh from Newcastle so we went here recommended What can I say this is just awful. The mocktails were 90% ice and as we went to try all the food, this was just awful.We left without eating there and without finishing our drinks.

Love the food here especially the fish and Chinese offerings both great quality and always super fresh. The drinks aren’t great though. Choice of beer isn’t good enough and you can’t get a pint!

We (my younger son and I) came here for a late lunch. It's a food court so it was convenient in terms of variety. Very average and you could probably get better food in the mall.

Just had possibly the worst bacon roll ever from Soup and Caboodle. An absolute disgrace. Bacon I could sole my shoe with on a dry roll with no butter - and they didn't even have ketchup!

We were excited to come to this place as it looked more Scottish than the other food court we came across online. It’s in a shopping centre which none of our group had realised upon deciding to go there, and despite not needing to book,...

When we got there, there was a queue going through one door and there was another door which was open with no queue. I assumed the queue was for a particular restaurant and so we made our way in. We got a table and ordered...

Terrible burger as El Perro Negro. Full of gristle which was inedible. This was the same in my burger and my partners. When I approached the staff they were nonchalant and did not seem to care. Better burger down the street at fat hippo. Don’t...

The manager directed her staff member to interrupt our table and falsely accuse us of smoking in their toilets. He patronisingly explained to us why we shouldn’t smoke in the toilets despite us telling him that we had not in fact done this. When I...

Went for lunch at creel and caught, disusting attitude of the guy at the counter who told me at 11.45 food is ordered at 12pm with attitude then at 12pm as I walked up to order he checked his watch !! We then called him...

Had lunch at El Perro Negro. Worst burgers we have ever had. Full of hard lumps of fat and gristle. How they won an award is hard to understand.

We went for lunch here when the Christmas Markets were so busy and we tried Chooks. The food was lovely the chicken was fantastic and the little waffles fries were very tasty.

Disappointed that the only beer served is in a schooner. Since when was this Scottish? We were more than disappointed with this. We thought that this experience would be Scottish but couldn’t be more far from Scottish. Poor poor poor

Second visit, El Perro Negro DID disappoint, can only describe burger as salty rare beef . I’m Scottish and the person on the till couldn’t understand me

Advertised as “the best burger in the UK” Well this is not the case at their restaurant located inside Bonnie And Wild Edinburgh. The burger wasn’t even cooked properly. . After cutting the burger in half, blood oozed out all over the plate. How hard...

Stopped off at Bonnie&Wild for an early evening meal , first impressions were very good, I like the concept of different food vendors all in one place as my wife is a vegetarian and I’m not so hopefully something for both of us . I...

We had food from salt and chilli and it was beautiful. The food was fresh to order and was very tasty. Staff were also friendly. We ordered the salt and chilli chicken and the salt and honey chilli chicken which was to die for. The...

Interesting food court with a diversity of cafes offering different cuisines, several bars, and some chic retail outlets including a wine shop. Service throughout is cheerful and swift.

I feel like this place needs more sign posting. Me and a friend visited. No line no staff so walked in to find a table. Unfortunately it was busy and whenever we found a table someone else took it. We were contemplating buying food and...

I decided to try Creel Caught today and had the scampi basket. The food was excellent however what impressed me most was the social skills of the gentleman taking the orders. I’d been to two clothing shops with sullen, disinterested staff so to be greeted...

Had a lovely dinner with our son plenty of choice on the menu. Staff were very attentive and friendly

Came here after my son recommended it. After reading the reviews I was a bit cynical and didn't expect much. Between us we had Sri Lankan kotthu, Italian pizza, Chinese honey chilli chicken, and American fried chicken & chips. Everyone loved their food, and the...

Went on 13th October and took grandkids for a day out. We dropped in here after shopping in the Centre. However, when trying to find something kids would eat there wasn't a very big choice. When decided on what to eat at one outlet you...

Went to chooks, had the hot honey chicken sandwich and was bang average. Took way too long to cook and was devoid of flavour. Can’t speak of the other places but avoid chooks. Better getting a zinger tower from KFC.

Brilliant Location!! I reccomend this place for the tourists! Very Scottish based and staff are lovely! Guy on the door was fab, there was a long queue but he got us all in pretty quickly! The lady who put my order through for east pizzas...

We went to Creel Caught and I enquired whether there were any gluten free items and was given a choice. I chose the fresh fish platter and was most impressed. They even added gluten free bread for me. The platter included prawns, smoked salmon, hot...

This is a brilliant, up market food court. Lots of good options and the food we had was really tasty. It’s new and modern. Very convenient and comfortable

Several things made our dining experience here a complete waste of a rare night out. Firstly, the online drinks ordering system is unnecessarily over-technical, convoluted and seemed to struggle with sun iPhone, so we ended up giving up with it and going to the bar...

We opted for Soup and Caboodle as the sandwich and salad options looked good. We had the roasted meditteranean veg sandwich and the quinoa salad. I have to mention the girl who was taking our order. She barely spoke, and when she did it was...

My friend and I had dinner at Leith Woks.The fine dining Chinese restaurant within Bonnie and Wild.It was absolutely delicious!By far the best Chinese food we've ever had!!

Scan QR code to order drinks from table ....I want to go somewhere, sit down, order drinks and food then pay without inconvenience of having to create an account,password and provide contact details so I can be bombarded with junk emails and texts in the...

Came into Cairngorms for a coffe and the man behind the till was stood watching a video on him phone and didn’t notice me waiting to order for a while until I said something for him to look up. Price for a flat white was...

Plenty of different places to eat and caters for most. I really like eats Pizzas - freshly made and good size. Great dough which fluffs up. No complaints here. It can get very busy though with queues often just to get in, so try and...

Went today for a spot of lunch at El Perro Negro in the Marketplace and was so disappointed with the customer service i received by the young man on the front taking orders. Very dismissive and uninterested in serving me, then when i asked if...

Came in last Sunday for coffee and food. Was a girl and a guy working at the coffee stand. A girl working at the pancakes stand. Pancakes were ok. Good topping selection. Was busy so it was a long wait time. Came up to ask...

Soup and Caboodle are a must-stop. Excellent choice for Non-Vegie and Vegies alike great choice of food for all don't miss it

We had to spend an unplanned night in Edinburgh due to the train strike. Luckily a local told us about this place. After lots of walking around Edinburgh we popped in to see what it was like. A simple idea, like a food court, but...

Visited early on a Saturday evening so no need to queue and plenty of space. Honey chicken dishes were great and plentiful, if a little on the spicy side. £6 kids pancakes were great value and range of toppings amazing. Lovely atmosphere, good range of...

What a great good market. I love that it’s so organized and not a free for all for a table. Don’t give up if the line is long. It moves fast. My son and I had salt and chilli oriental And it was so so...

We have been here a number of times. My husband loves fish and chips so he had this from Creel Caught. Unlike our previous visit the fish was tiny and, despite staff's comments to contrary, it looked like a small half fillet. Staff advised problems...

A selection of food outlets under one roof with communal dining areas. A nice idea and we certainly didnt sample all outlets. I looked at most menus and many had popular cusine.I thought there was a lack of freshly prepaired food and perhaps a salad...

Unusually we didn’t have to queue to get in which was great news - the downside was ‘salt & chilli’ where it seems the staff don’t really care about their customers and the food tasted cheap (the curry sauce tasted like the low quality powdered...

Great choice of foods all under one roof. Everyone can eat from different kitchens . Had to queue for abt half an hour to get in but enjoyed the experience. Will return.

Soup was fine, bread nice. I think the concept of Bonnie and Wild is good. It is a foodhall above a shopping centre and, if you remember this, you won't be disappointed. If you are expecting quality dining, I feel, you need to go elsewhere.

Saw this via social media and so thought we would try a meal whilst visiting Edinburgh. Called at 9pm to find several outlets had already stopped serving food. It was messy, untidy and just full of young teenagers, no ambience and certainly nowhere nearvthe standard...

Didnt get the concept of the whole place. I take it it is takaway food in a food court. I didnt get thecreason for queuing as people were walking straight in? We were directed to a table at the Creel place - table was covered...

I had a mini break in Edinburgh staying at Hotel Indigo York Place. Bonnie and Wild is just a 5 minute walk away and I ate there each night. The choice of food is very good and it’s a comfortable and relaxing place to eat....

Ordered my daughter salt and chilli chicken from salt & chilli oriental. Half way through eating it she bit one of the bits of chicken in half only to see it was still raw on the inside. Staff members were not concerned at all and...

Go and try the Sri Lankan food stall. Lots of great choice but this meal was amazing. So tasty. No regrets. Lots of variety. People moaning that it’s expensive are probably more used to Wetherspoons. You get what you pay for. This is quality produce.

Loved the place. Don't believe the sour reviews and Karens. You can find plenty fun places here and you'll be able to have a great time paired with the food you love.

I went there in my day off to have something nice at the bonnie &wild and I bought some fried calamari off creel caught ...do not bother try their food the calamari were over cooked, grease and the oil were the calamari were cooked smelled...

In general this place is just overrated compared to other great eateries in the city. I think it is just a hype. If I had to go again then I would only eat the chicken at Chooks as it is pretty decent.

First visit here thought we'd try the delicious looking burgers as seen on the web Site from el perro negro but what we received after being served by the sullen uninterested young woman I would not even say it was a burger more a ball...

There is a good selection of food choices here most of which I have tired. My favourite so far would be Leith Woks which was really delicious. The new Soup & Caboodle was also really good and something a bit different than the other eateries....

Excellent spot to cater for all needs - Lunch, dinner, coffee, ice creams, cocktails, etc. Lovely seating areas, staff were all cheerful and happy to help, and the staff did a great job of cleaning the tables regularly and keeping it tidy. Plenty of choices...

I think I may have chosen the wrong food on the menu. Fried chicken, chips with chilli powder. I felt it was greasy and quite uninspiring and boring. I regularly visit the foodhall and had always wanted to try Salt and Chilli and heard positive...

We had been keen to visit but once will probably be enough unless standards markedly improve. I love the concept but couldn't have imagined the execution being so poor! We had to clear our own table which isn't surprising considering the clearly insufficient amount of...

Regular visitor to B&W. No issues any visit, I would highly recommend you turn up early or you will be queuing for some time. Ordering drinks to the table is fantastic and the food on offer will never disappoint. I would like to see a...

We ate here this Friday afternoon. The queue to get in was long and finding a table was troublesome, although the chap at the front seemed to be doing his best. However, we were told to sit at a 'seat at the bench' by the...

Great concept. Drinks took a very long time time to arrive. Ordered calamari from Creel Caught, a very disappointing plate of overcooked batter with very little calamari. Pizza from East Pizzas was better. Wouldn’t come back.

First time here kind of fish shop Approach Order at bar get a timer Timer rings go get it also cutlery short Had to wait didn’t understand chef Attitude ask why not real Scampi Reply monk fish is real Scampi

I sited here for the first time with my husband and 3 week old daughter. There was plenty room for us to park out pram next to our table, but it was a Thursday lunchtime - could be much different at the weekend or in...

Ate at the Creel caught today. Ordered fish tacos, minimal fish, 3 small pieces, with bones! Lukewarm and the salsa was watery. Ordered wine and lager, took an age to arrive, wine not chilled and tasted like the bottle had been open for days! Won’t...

Took our granddaughters for lunch. We had burgers, service was lovely but burgers were awful, very dry, grisly and tasteless. Fries were fine. The drinks ‘bar’ was terrible. Served by a sullen, disinterested young woman. No kids options drnks-wise. Wouldn’t go back.

Stand we went to had neither of first two options my friend wanted and staff unfriendly. Went to another and was informed it was just closing ( at 4pm) Once we eventually got something seating was comfortable though Had coffee after and staff at this...

We spotted Bonnie and Wild whilst shopping in St James Quarter. I wish we hadn’t bothered. We ordered two breakfast stacks from Stack & Still. The quality of the meat was very poor. Cheap supermarket type black pudding which was really dry. The Lorne Sausage...

We had fried chicken with a couple of cocktails at Bonnie & Wild. The chicken was tasty but I am not sure how it was fried, as some parts of the pieces were like stones and impossible to chew. The cocktails as well as the...

Ate at Kochchi. Expensive for what you got. The straight hopper was a cold dish ( not told this) and it was fridge cold. Chicken hopper was disappointing with chicken only at room temperature.

Came to salt & chilli for the 2nd time. When ordering at the til, I forgot that they have a buzzer system and proceeded to give the woman my table number, she rolled her eyes, muttered something in her native language and pointed to the...

Third visit to bonnie and wild, went with friend before heading to the theatre. Can’t booked so was expecting to wait but pretty much walked right in. Told there was table at the far and left to find it. Ordered drinks on the app and...

We have been here several times but the queue to get in is becoming monotonous as well as very frustrating There was one young greeter today holding up the queue for no reason at all. I counted 15 empty tables inside yet we waited 40...

We went to Creel Caught on 22nd December 2022 after a delightful day of Christmas shopping with my wife and young daughter. I opted for Creel Caughts Goan Seafood Curry and fish tacos which initially werent bad if a bit on the small portion size...

We came at the beginning of December, with the sole purpose of having a coffee, with a name like cairngorm roasters, we was hopeful, but what a letdown, my coffee was cold, my kids hot chocolate was also cold, the pepito I had was dry...

I liked the canteen-style layout of the foodhall. It's easy to use. You order at each food station, pay and are given a buzzer that rings when the food is ready. El Perro Negro serves mainly burgers. Although I don't normally like chips, I really...

Wanted to try this place for a while & wasn’t disappointed. Four of us went & each of us had something different. It was all good! The lad that served me was very informative and friendly. We had drinks as well. A really nice experience....