2nd Girlfriend in Sheffield - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

One of the best meals I've ever had! Lovely atmosphere in restaurant, great service too. The meal was simply amazing. I had the mushrooms and pancetta starter and it was so very tasty. Then my fillet steak was ullnof flavour and was cooked to absolute perfection, along with it's sauce. We shared a lovely bottle of house white, while others in my party enjoyed garlic bread, mozarella, pasta and a beautiful seabass dish. I really couldn't be happier about the food I ate.

Our 5th visit. After the 4th visit we said that we wouldn’t return due to the poor service. We went as it was for a friends birthday meal. It was absolutely abysmal service, shocking! I wish that I could say the food was awful but it was good. Just one of many things……We were told “if you don’t want a dessert, can you finish your drinks at the bar?” We had literally just swallowed our mains (plates still on the table) and just received our bottle of wine that we’d ordered before the meal. There were 13 of us and had arrived on time and been sat for 1 hour 28 mins when we were told this. We asked for a dessert menu and it was shouted back across the table what desserts were on offer. We weren’t allowed to even peruse the menu. We won’t be returning. What a shame. Shocking way to treat customers.

We was booked in for table of 10 at 7pm. we arrived to be told we was not booked in- They did manage to seat us. we waited 50 minutes to order our drinks- The starters arrived, not the best value for money, just chucked onto a plate-no dressing -salad or nice bread rolls. The main meal arrived - £26.00 for peppered steak and chips!! no garnish no presentation and no drinks offered- we had to ask again three times for more drinks. Three people had lasagne- they all left it. Half way through our meal one of our guest was asked to move to allow them to seat another party-how rude! Never again-this was to be a special night out for a birthday-disappointed.

The food is lovely been a few times and will be back. Staff are friendly and helpful very nice place

Staff very friendly and helpful, the place isn't very big but it was clean and had a nice atmosphere . The menu had plenty of choice and they have a specials board. Food was served piping hot and was very tasty, could have done with a bit more veg to a portion. Alcohol is available with bottled beers and spirits. We would recommend a visit if you haven't been yet and we will be returning some time soon.

Extremely friendly service, food was fantastic and full of flavour! Great price. Will definitely be back!!

Visited early Friday before a football match. Outside looked a bit dubious with grafting on the wall but it was really good. Excellent service, good choice & very reasonably priced. Everything we had was tasty & hot plates! The monkfish linguine was lovely and the house wine at £18 a bottle was perfect & when we asked about it didn’t get talked into ordering a more expensive one. Complimentary limoncellos always a plus! If we are ever back in Hillsborough would definitely revisit.

Staff were really friendly,food was just average...nothing really to complain about but nothing would make me recommend to anyone and wouldn't go back myself ,husband said the same .

What a hidden Gem this place is, beautiful place, excellent food and very welcoming staff and owner. We will be back for more. Amazing Italian food!

Wpw, what a place. Absolutely beautiful food. Would definitely recommend and I'll be going again. Very pleasant owner and waiting staff.

Went for my son’s 40th birthday, what a fantastic experience. The food was amazing and the host was absolutely lovely. The chef came out to make sure we all enjoyed our meal. I can’t recommend this place highly enough. Beautiful food, beautiful decor and lovely staff. If you haven’t been, please give it a try.

Wanted to try this place for a while & I’m pleased to say, it didn’t disappoint. A little gem on my doorstep. Very welcoming despite being busy, friendly, efficient staff serving delicious food! The steaks were succulent & their accompanying sauces were full of flavour. The starters & pastas were equally as good. We also had a variety of cocktails, which were all spot on & reasonably priced. All in all, a great night out with the family and one we will definitely repeat soon.

Absolutely delicious, freshly prepared authentic food. Cannot recommend this place highly enough. Portion sizes are also huge, value for money.

Went for dinner 2nd of May, shared a lovely starter of Prawns, then I had a chicken Corriacchio ( I think that’s what it was called) , my husband had the special, Penne with fillet steak , both very tasty, the chef came out to ask if we were enjoying our meal, will definitely visit again

Amazing food and fantastic staff. We went for my 40th birthday and I loved every moment of it. the meals were amazing, I had mussels for starter and I don’t think I’ve ever had any that nice in a long time. The chilli and tomato sauce they were in was perfect with just a hit of spice. Fillet steak in Rossini sauce for my main done medium/rare and it melted like butter in my mouth. To top of the evening the host, Mimo, brought his guitar out to sing me happy birthday! Real authentic Sicilian food that we will be going back for again. Top marks.

I went there for my birthday party with my friends today and it was an absolute great experience! The staff were very friendly and considerate (in helping my friend preparing my birthday cake surprise!). They played live music to celebrate my birthday which was very nice of them. The food was also very authentic and at reasonable prices. I would absolutely recommend it to anyone who is planning to visit Sheffield! Thanks again for this amazing evening with us. Best, Yao

Service was friendly and efficient and the fillet steak was one of the best I've eaten in Sheffield. Would highly recommend.

Booked this restaurant as a result of reading other reviews. What an absolute delight. As soon as we entered, the atmosphere was pleasant and relaxed. Staff couldn't have been more friendly and approachable. Quality of the food was excellent. My wife and I both had...

The food was faultless and I'm very hard to please. The service was wonderful. I'll definitely be back.

A perfect experience. The meals were delicious and prepared in a matter of minutes, the service was impeccable from both waiting staff and management, and the whole experience was a very welcoming one. I’ll be coming back weekly! Worth travelling to if you’re in any...

We went for my son's birthday and it was our first visit but will certainly not be our last. The food and service were excellent and the young waitress was very attentive and we weren't rushed it was a very pleasant experience.

We have visited on numerous occasions. Staff really friendly. Food excellent.Really convenient location. Would recommend.

Had a lovely mid week meal at 2nd Girlfriend in Hillsborough, Sheffield Lovely food, excellent tentative service. Mussels starter and mains from the specials board. Can’t fault this local find. Will definitely visit again.

Can’t fault it in any way. Food fabulous, generous portions. Meat & fish great quality. Service spot on . Owner attentive & personable . Restaurant itself was spotless & intimate . Great for friends & couples . Would highly recommend

4th visit here and just as brilliant. Food hot, fresh and delicious. And plenty of it. I had lamb meatballs to start and they were gorgeous. Just the right amount of seasoning and great texture. O/H had steak which was cooked perfectly. It was full...

We visited the restaurant this evening, with my in laws. Right from entering the restaurant, the staff were friendly, attentive, very polite and helpful. It was only the second night for one of the waitresses, but she was faultless and really lovely. Even though it...

Terrible doesn't even begin to cover it. Starting with trying to talk to the place before our booking - no-one answers the telephone. A prompt taking of our wine order was the only decent service we got all night. Our starters - with one wrong...

Had a lovely evening at the 2nd girlfriend. The Seabass was so tasty and we had a great welcome. We’d definitely return 👌 x

Impromptu first visit with my parents. Outstanding food and customer service. They went out of their way to provide amazing food and service especially on a cold snowy night. Can't wait to come back again with all my friends and family. Thankyou guys !

First visit on a cold and snowy Wednesday evening, but the food was excellent - tasty and fresh. Proprietor was friendly welcoming and attentive, but not over the top. Limited choice of deserts, but it was a Wednesday after all! We will certainly be coming...

Lovely food, great ambience and really friendly staff. We will definitely go here again. We had a lovely evening.

Have visited 2nd Girlfriend twice, most recently as a party of 6 on a busy Saturday night. On this occasion the restaurant was full and they had a large party in, which meant that service to our group was slow. This was recognised and addressed...

It's not the 1st time for my husband & I. 2nd Girlfriend is local for us so we've been a few times. It's a comfortable atmosphere with a good selection of food, nice wine & great friendly service . If its a special occasion you'll...

The perfect dining experience for Valentines Day and indeed for any other day of the year! Its stylish and welcoming with personal service from the owner who presented the ladies with a red rose!! Our food, as always was superb. After starters of mixed olives...

Superb from start to finish, freshest high quality ingredients used. The staff are amazing and possibly the best pasta iv ever eaten. Thank you for such a fantastic night.

There was a great variety to the menu, we both had calamari to start and then I went with the Pizza Carne and my mum had the Salmone Penne pasta and these dishes didn’t disappoint. The staff were lovely and even brought a guitar out...

We were greeted with a big smile and warm welcome and shown to our table. Drinks arrived quickly, all staff friendly. Food was faultless. I rarely order steak when eating out but went for it and so glad I did. Home made tiramisu to complete...

Omg such beautiful food. I wanted seconds, thirds and more. Got the homemade meatballs and the gravy was so 🤌🏾🤌🏾🤌🏾 and the salmon pasta which was beautiful. The tomato sauce - exquisite and the pasta and prawns were gorgeeeouuus! The salmon added a lovely saltiness...

Best place to eat in Sheffield - the food was delicious and the staff are lovely. Great atmosphere too. 10/10 🌟

What a delight to finally find a restaurant that ticks all the boxes, great ambiance, friendly and courteous staff, excellent food and exceptional value for money. I would highly recommend and will definitely be returning to be spoilt some more . 10 out of 10.

The restaurant is nice rustic and cosy the owner and staff are very friendly and made us feel very welcome, the food was unreal amazing flavours and good portions everything fresh will be coming back!

Fantastic welcome and Food ., the special boards had a fab selection and large portions ., We didn’t have room for dessert

Just had a meal with family at 2nd girlfriend couldn't fault it the food it beautiful best meal in a long time would definitely reccomend visiting you will not be disappointed staff are very welcoming

Good service. We loved the vibe!! The staff was very friendly and we had a great time. The pizza and chocolate fudge cake were amazing!! Definitely coming again.

Really warm and welcoming. Lovely service from start to finish. The food was really good,very tasty and plenty of. We also got to see the waiter's talent at singing and playing guitar. We really recommend this restaurant .

I've been here twice now and been so impressed with the food. Great pasta with really tasty sauce, big meaty king prawns, melt in the mouth steak cooked perfectly - everything I've tried has been delicious. And generous portions! Nice ambience. Lovely service too, really...

We ate here as a family group of three couples. The restaurant is a nicely appointed Italian/Mediterranean eatery with a well balanced menu. There are also a few specials starters and mains on the blackboards. All of our food, both from the menu and blackboards...

2nd visit to the restaurant & was just as fantastic as the 1st time. Gorgeous, tasty food Attentive , friendly staff Overall a excellent night , can’t wait to return

This was possibly one of the best restaurants that we have eaten at in a very long time. The welcome was friendly, the decor superb with Mediterranean art work enhancing the walls. The menu is extensive especially the amazing selection of 'specials' on various boards....

Really nice atmosphere right in the middle of hillsborough really clean great authentic Italian food and staff are polite friendly and attentive owner goes out of his way to make you feel welcome my first visit but will definitely not be my last…

We recently ate here on Saturday 26th November a party of four that booked a late table 9pm when we arrived we were shown straight to our table. Our order was taken ten minutes later and we all had two courses (too full for three)...

We were a party of four on a busy Saturday evening, and it was about 25 minutes after being seated that our food order was taken. The service was then prompt and our starters were good, the mains came and all was good until one...

All I will say is absolutely excellent 👌, Food superb, service excellent would definitely recommend this restaurant

We had a lovely evening meal here on Saturday 15 th October Exceptional quality dishes , service first class along with a lovely glass of house merlot . Will certainly book again and also will recommend to friends family etc .

Ate at this lovely restaurant last night and was very impressed! Generous portions of delicious food ! 3 of us had the monkfish and prawn linguine and it is possibly the best pasta dish I’ve ever had ! Lovely and plentiful pieces of monkfish with...

We came to 2nd girlfriend a few days ago and absolutely loved our visit. They originally gave me the wrong calzone but quickly rectified this and made me a new one free of charge, which I got to take home. They also gave us a...

We visited the 2nd Girlfriend last night after reading all the good reviews. I must say we wasn’t disappointed, the food was lovely,wonderful staff very friendly and welcoming. I loved the look of the decor inside very fresh it made me feel like I was...

Absolutely amazing quality food. It's difficult to find the superlatives necessary. Two starters - king prawns and arancini both came with very different sauces, both full of different flavours. Mains - seafood risotto and calzone. Both full of meaty chunks and flavour. The only real...

It was the best place that I have been in Sheffield the staff the food everything was amazing ✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨☕️

Once again, food & service were excellent. Went on a quiet Sunday evening,so we got undevided attention. Both my husband and I chose scallops,served on a bed of creamy risotto,off the specials board. The scallops were cooked to perfection. For desert,my hubby chose Tiramasu,which was...

There were four of us and we each chose something different from prawns, mussels, fillet steak to swordfish. we all enjoyed our food and house wine and the service was good too. The only let down was it was so cold in the restaurant ,...

Excellent food, great atmosphere. Really recommend this restaurant. I had prawns for starter, lamb chops for main and chocolate cake for dessert.

Have heard very good things about this place and the food didn't let us down can not fault the food . The service wasn't great and a lot of attention was placed on the drunken birthday table. They even played a song for them which...

Amazing everything food, service hospitality even singing. Group of 12 went for a birthday and we was treated like royalty. Nothing is too much trouble the service was efficient, the staff really friendly and the food was gorgeous definitely going back and would recommend it...

Oh my days what an absolute gem of a find. This little restaurant is tucked at the side of Wetherspoons on Langsett Road where the tram stops . It was clean and bright, gentle music playing which did not interrupt our conversation. The waiter (Santino)...

Absolutely gorgeous food, service was top quality too. Couldn’t recommend it any more, such a lovely welcoming place!

Very nice, Okay, Bad Starter was very nice. We Ordered 2 fillet steak... 1, With Chips & Greek salad. Which she thought was okay. 2, With Chips & Pepper sauce. The worst steak i have ever had, regardless of whether it was Fillet or any...

My brother and I took my mum here for her birthday. What a delightful evening we had. Lovely atmosphere, great service and most important wonderful food. We all had different starters / main meals and everyone said it was the best meal we had had...

Amazing food amazing service and friendly. Well looked after. Definitely go again. First review ever wrote 👌👍👊

What can I say about this, it has a strange name but it’s definitely a fantastic place to eat. We had the best time for a special occasion. The food was lovely and the service was brilliant.

Amazing food very helpful staff definitely will be bk value for money atmosphere was lovley very good choice off food

We were really looking forward to our visit here after reading the reviews. Very disappointed basic Italian food and overpriced calamari slightly under cooked, fillet steak was served as 2 serlion steaks on top of each other NOT FILLET, wine was well over the top...

Absolutely recommend the 2nd girlfriend, beautiful food, great atmosphere and very attentive staff nothing is too much trouble we had a fabulous night and will definitely be going again, L & O

as a resident of Sheffield 6 I have seen this particular building trade as an Indian restaurant and as a chinese. It appears to be one of those venues that never quite seems to 'take off', & bearing in mind its location next to Wetherespoons...

Absolutely first class service. The owner was very attentive and nothing was too much trouble. The steak was cooked to perfection and if the scallops were any fresher, they’d have still been swimming! The home-made tiramisu rounded off a perfect night. Very nice atmosphere and...

We had a fantastic night. It was obvious early on that they were short staffed, and the main waitress was rushed off her feet. They all (including kitchen staff) asked if we were OK and checked for allergies before they presented the menus. They made...

Visited christmas eve not knowing what to expect from a new restaurant was definitely not disappointed . Awesome food , very welcoming and a great atmosphere will be coming back for sure.

We went to 2nd girlfriend on a Tuesday night and the food was fantastic I had prawns to start which were delightful and lamb chops main which were delicious too my wife had aranchini balls to start and chicken for main which she says were...

What a wonderful place this is and deffo will return. Excellent food choices on both the main menu and specials board. We ordered from both, the food is amazing, the setting is just lovely and the service excellent. Christina served our table and was so...

Weekend visit to Sheffield and booked for Saturday evening, 4th December. The restaurant is small but beautifully decorated. We received a warm, sincere welcome from Christina and Chris (owner, chef and all round nice guy). The bruscetto starter was so fresh and light, best we...

A very warm welcome awaited the 3 of us when we arrived at this beautiful restaurant. There were 2 specials boards together with a fantastic menu and we were spoilt for choice. There were 7 starters which I wanted! Final picks were bruschetta, calamari and...

Was told it was good but it was superb. The good quality and choice spot on. The staff and service were warm, helpful and very professional. The decor bright and spotless.

Excellent food and service. Attentive, friendly owner. What a great find nothing too much trouble. Would definitely recommend this restaurant.

Visited on a Wednesday evening after spotting the usual restaurant name . What a great choice . The food and service was excellent. We ordered bruschetta and mussels to start and sea bass and calzone for our mains . Both courses were lovely and reasonably...

We would definitely recommend this little restaurant The food was fantastic and the service great. Generous and well priced. We will certainly go back again.

We received one of the warmest welcomes ever at 2nd girlfriend. No sooner had we arrived at the front door when the owner greeted us. We were shown to our table straight away and we were immediately impressed with the room lay out and decor....

New restaurant in the heart of Hillsborough in the building next to the Rawson Spring pub serving Mediterranean and Italian dishes From the outside it looks ok although blinds obscure views into the restaurant from outside but don’t let that put you off. Just head...

Absolutely stunning food, great service 👌 In my opinion the best Italian/Mediterranean restaurant in Sheffield. Well worth a visit.. you won't be disappointed.

We had a lovely meal at 2nd girlfriend! The food was lush and the staff really friendly. I would definitely recommend

This place shouldn’t have empty tables whatever night of the week! Excellent food, service and ambience! Highly recommend and this is the start of many visits for myself! Felt extremely comfortable being a person eating alone!

Fantastic restaurant. Food to die for and service second to none. Starters were huge; prawn cocktail from the specials board and Mare Monte from the main menu. I had the Pollo Diane and the chicken was cooked to perfection, not dry and the sauce was...

A great addition to restaurants in Hillsborough. Excellent food, very good value for money and Chris is a very pleasant host. We had a great evening with friends and looking forward to our next visit.

Sheffield is not short of nice Italian restaurants, but this one is a cut above the Hillsborough/Walkley/Crookes norm. Definitely worth making the trip down the hill - and back up again.

Absolutely delicious. Staff were really lovely, place was perfectly clean, nice toilets. Food was sensational! Highly recommend

From start to finish our visit was lovely. The food was amazing and such good value. Husband had the steak which was lovely and the pasta dishes were so tasty. The staff were really friendly and helpful, we will definitely be back.

This venue has been many things, the last place was a great Indian restaurant. It’s now Italian.........very attentive staff, fantastic food (I always say that if you don’t get a steak knife when ordering a steak, they know they have great steaks...........they do!!) and right...

This restaurant only opened on May 17th,but well worth the wait.Extremely friendly welcome,EXCELLENT service throughout and a varied menu. For starters,we shared a bruschetta, which was the nicest I,ve tasted ANYWHERE. For mains,we both chose the sea bass,and once again,the fish and accompanying vegetables were...