The Jolly Judge Pub in Edinburgh, City of

90% of pubs in Edinburgh are tourist scams. 95% of them have friendly staff. This one falls into the category where it is not a scam and the staff is very very worthwhile listening to... if you want a whiskey adventure! Time for a haika. I wrote this while drunk Went there to drink a scotch Here i found my favourite scotch!!

Very busy, didn't eat. Fairly cheap for High Street

The Jolly Judge provides a truly authentic Edinburgh pub experience in a charming, tucked-away basement location. The cosy, low-ceilinged interior, complete with a welcoming log fire, creates an inviting atmosphere perfect for relaxation. With its range of real ales, well-kept ciders, and an impressive selection of whiskies, the Jolly Judge caters to both locals and visitors seeking a genuine taste of Scottish hospitality. The knowledgeable and friendly staff add a personal touch, making each visit feel special. Conveniently located just off the Royal Mile, it is an ideal spot to unwind after exploring the city. The unique ambience and quality offerings make it a must-visit for anyone looking to enjoy Edinburgh’s pub culture. Five stars well-deserved for this hidden gem.

Great bar with an impressive selection of cider and beer!

Super nice bar! Very nice waiter who advised us on whiskey, we exchanged a few words Good atmosphere!

Didn't have food but this a lovely place to have a drink. Very welcoming lovely friendly staff

Probably the best bar in Edinburgh tucked away in a former bakery xxx

Cool little pub tucked away in an alley. Beers were very good and reasonably priced. All the seats inside were taken so we sat outside on the benches and had a lovely conversation with some locals.

A small but cozy bar. The ceiling is made of old painted beams. Supply of whiskey and lager beer is sufficient. If you want to sit at the tables with five people, it is a bit cramped and it is better to stand at the bar. Good atmosphere and cozy.

Cozy little pub just off the royal mile. Felt like I was in a local pub miles from any tourist. Staff was friendly and the drinks were great!

Great little pub in the heart of the Royal Mile 💜💜💜💜💜

Really good service in here. They don’t have Guinness on tap, which is normally a disaster for me. However they recommended a local stout and went into a lot of detail about what else they had on that day. Their recommendation didn’t disappoint. It’s quite small inside and has more of a restaurant vibe compared to a “boozer”.

Excellent town centre bar hidden down a close but worth seeking out. The staff are very efficient serving a good choice of real ale well.

Stopped in here on recommendation from a local. Space inside is small but cozy and if the weather is nice they have a nice patio. Tucked away down the side from Royal Mile, this offers a cozy respite from the tourist crowds. Bartenders were friendly and prompt.

No food served here. Service was wonderful. It was a quiet Wednesday night. The cider was AMAZING the guys behind the bar really know how to recommend.

Authentic pub in the beautiful courtyard that houses the writers' museum. It does not offer meals, but only beers and some snacks (such as chips and peanuts to accompany, always for a fee) Smiling and kind staff. I recommend it for a good beer

Small local pub. Nice, there was also a quiz in the evening.

Stellar vibes—loved the carpet, the low ceilings, the cozy vibes! Even had a good sour on tap!

We always stop in for a pint at the Jolly Judge. Small but charming Pub. Excellent beer selection.

Nice athmospheric place with good craft cider. Unfortunately it's located in a very crowded touristic area and it's almost impossible to sit inside.

The Jolly Judge Pub in Edinburgh is a charming spot that perfectly combines warmth and traditional Scottish character with a modern flair. Located in the city center, this hidden gem embodies the essence of a classic Scottish pub. As you step inside, you'll find a cozy atmosphere with low wooden beams, unique decor, and comfortable seating, making it ideal for both a quiet drink after a day of sightseeing and a lively evening out with friends. The drinks menu features a fantastic selection of local and international craft beers, fine wines, and an impressive range of whiskies. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, ready to offer great recommendations based on what you like. The food at the Jolly Judge is equally impressive, highlighting classic pub dishes made with fresh, local ingredients. Be sure to try the haggis, and don’t miss out on the perfectly crispy and flavorful fish and chips. There are also vegetarian options available, so there’s something for everyone. What truly makes the Jolly Judge special is its rich history and welcoming atmosphere. Both regulars and tourists feel right at home, creating a sense of community that’s hard to find elsewhere. Plus, with live music events and quiz nights, there’s always something fun happening at the pub.

Really great pub. The staff are incredibly knowledgeable, they have a great selection of beers and an even better selection of whiskey. Would recommend if visiting Edinburgh

Cozy hole in the wall pub with fairy lights. The girl passionately offered whiskey to taste to help pick the Scotch most suited to our palate. Highly recommended!

Was prepared to be disappointed, as this was just off the royal mile and in festival season. But it’s a lovely cozy subterranean place and with some great cask ales - enjoyed sampling some Cromarty ones.

The Jolly Judge: A Hidden Gem Off the Royal Mile Nestled just off the bustling Royal Mile, The Jolly Judge is a charming little pub tucked away in a historic building. Despite its small size, the pub has a welcoming and inviting atmosphere. A Quaint Retreat: Historic Charm: The Jolly Judge's quaint setting, with its exposed stone walls and traditional decor, provides a delightful escape from the hustle and bustle of the city center. Friendly Service: The staff at The Jolly Judge are friendly and attentive, ensuring a pleasant experience for all patrons. A Great Drinking Hole: Relaxing Atmosphere: Whether you're looking for a quiet pint or a lively conversation, The Jolly Judge offers a relaxed and enjoyable atmosphere. Off the Beaten Path: If you're seeking a break from the crowds on the Royal Mile, The Jolly Judge is the perfect spot to unwind and enjoy a drink. Overall: The Jolly Judge is a hidden gem that offers a charming and welcoming atmosphere. If you're looking for a great drinking hole off the beaten path, be sure to check it out!

Great for a pint but food not available.

Great non-touristy proper pub on Royal Mile. Highly recommended

Very cozy pub, good beer, normal prices. Significantly nicer inside than outside and much quieter than on the nearby Royal Mile.

Great little find. Lovely outside courtyard as well as small restaurant area. Food fairly typical of a touristy place - basic but decent. All the servers were great. If you're doing anything at The Hub or Edinburgh Castle nip into the Jolly Judge first.

A great little pub in central Edinburgh

Lovely little pub, with a nice range of beers. Only the benches are for this pub. The tables for the restaurant.

Small hidden gem near the castle... I love the outdoor seating and having a drink under the table umbrella in the rain. Inside seating is a bit limited and can get crowded. No matter how busy the inside is, you can get your drinks within few minutes of wait.

Worst glass of lager we've had in Edinburgh!

One of the best pubs I’ve ever been in… hands down. Must visit if you’re in Edinburgh.

Best picture of a judge I've ever seen

Very nice, good beer selection and a nice Scotch of the day.

Love this hidden gem in Edinburgh, just off the royal mile. Cosy wee spot, nice for a quick pit stop whilst visiting the city

Very nice staff and cute little pub!

Lovely little pub with good selection of beer/whisky/cider. Can be v busy.

I went here hoping to find traditional English beer such as a pint of cask conditioned bitter or pale ale. They had nothing like this. All of their draft beers were modern typical types that look like what would be found in a USA bar. Even the cask taps were American style IPA or stout. Also had a cider that did not turn out to be typical English style. I think the bar manager does not intend to keep the drink selection aligned with what this place is and should be, an ancient English pub.

Nice little pub for a refreshing drink and well located in the heart of Edinburgh.

Great little find just off the crowds, of people. Good choice of local craft beer. Really nice and cosy bar. Male wcs could do with a scrub. Altho my wife said the ladies were spotless Would go again Cheers guys

Great for ciders, but quite small!

Great little pub with a greater beer and cider selection and friendly staff. Always my choice if in need of refreshment near the top of the old town. Just wish it was a little bigger, or if the weather was slightly consistently better. A welcome haven from the tourist madness at all times of year.

Lovely little pub with great atmosphere. Thoroughly enjoyed the pub quiz! Abbie behind the bar is great and very knowledgeable about all the different drinks. So many cider options!!

Just a great pub with a that's cozy and fun. Good food and drink and the staff is super. A great place to hang out on a wet afternoon to warm up with a strong drink!

Award winning Ciders. Good selection of beers too.

Stumbled into this pub to grab a pint and it was so cool. Great selection of whiskey and great beers. I had the Lochlea whiskey twice and it was so smooth. If you're looking to get off your feet for a minute go here to get your pint .

Fantastic pub, best in the old town, quick and easy to get served too

I love this little pub, right smack dab on the Royal Mile which is bustling with tourist traffic. Somehow, this place feels like somewhere locals frequent, and while it's small, it doesn't feel affected by the tourist traffic. The bar staff are friendly and helpful - willing to talk to you about whisky and cider. It's a great respite after a day of sightseeing in Edinburgh.

Brilliant pub hidden away from the main road .a nice little gem

Lovely location in the basement of an old building. Don't ask me what year because the bartender who's worked there for 3 months favorite answer to all questions is I don't know 😕 This fairly new hidden place has huge potential, but I suggest the owners set the level of their bartenders hospitality a couple stars higher

It's a lovely wee pub. With it being sunny we stood outside. Shame they don't have tables to sit on outside. Not very disabled friendly as narrow stairs into the pub, and narrow stairs up to the toilets. We all enjoyed it all the same though

Nice place with great beers! Warm and jolly atmosphere!

A cozy pub, in a side street. A nice small selection of whiskeys and a selection of ciders and beers!

Hidden corner to escape from the madding crowd and enjoy a good pint

Very nice pub. Friendly service!

Well hidden but very valid, it wins the award for best whiskey bar in the city every year! Super recommended visit

If you like an old time Scottish pub, with a great, cozy atmosphere and fantastic beer, you found the right place. Be prepared to wait, as there is not a lot of space!

Great selection of vintage Lambic at great prices. Good location.

Super nice place to have a drink with friends. Highly recommended

Lovely small pub with a pretty good selection of beer.

Great little hide away pub for a few drinks.

Been here a lot over the last 5 years, staff and choice of drinks are brilliant. One of my favourite places in Edinburgh.

This place is truly unique and special. It shouldn't be this great because it's in the middle of some of the heaviest tourist traffic in town. But it's through a little "close" and only for the adventurous. Not necessarily divey but it's a bit of a hole in the wall. You walk down the stairs into a tiny little pub full of life and good vibes. Friendly barkeepers and good conversation and on a busy day the crowd flows out into the courtyard. One of the best pubs in this part of town.

A small place hidden away from the main drag. What I loved was the vast variety of ciders and beers. Loved trying the different ciders especially, and the guy helping me choose let me try some to make sure I was ordering what I wanted. Really enjoyed. Normal (expensive) pricing for the area. But the ciders are actually a bit cheaper if you stick to some of the semis and the drys.

Cute little Scottish pub with good beers. We didn't try any food, but the beer and ginger beer were good.

Nice pub. Proper pub. Interesting beer. Not a real ale drinker by any stretch but something for everyone. If there's a fault service is sometimes slow and some bar staff could be cheerier.

Good selection of beers and a cozy atmosphere

Wow! Fantastic pub. Great range of beers, whiskies and ciders. Intimate atmosphere, knowledgeable and friendly staff, decent prices- and right in the heart of tourist-trap Edinburgh. I found it by chance- not wanting to join my family at the nearby Obscura- and only afterwards discovered other favourable reviews. CAMRA seem to love it too (although that’s not always a good indication of a decent pub, sadly). Not child-friendly (although they are accepted in the outside courtyard) - also no food (in April 2024), contrary to what some listings state. A must-visit just off the royal mile. :-)

Good place to sip a beer in a calm and relaxing atmosphere! Important hydration step during a day’s walk

Small place. Not friendly. Beers mainly. No sightseeing, no view, just a small pub inside. Strange door.

Great little bar with very reasonable prices

Nice little pub, hidden near the royal mile.

Proper old fashioned pub hidden within a historical alley. It is quite tiny but that is kind of its charm. Cozy carpet interior with a great cask and whisky selection. Nice and gentle staff. And prices are great for central Edinburgh. A hidden gem

Great little pub, although such a shame that the young barman chose to use foul language on many occasions whilst serving. Not very professional 😢

I could really recommend this place 👌😁 It has a nice atmosphere, good selection off drinks and a nice service.

Great little pub hidden away off the Royal Mile. Cosy quiet very walming atmosphere. Outside seating in Small court.

Good selection of well kept cask ales

Could not drink a coca-cola as an almost 27 year old.

Tiny nice place. Depending on the time of day you get there, it's going to be packed.

Nice place and people in the old town. Only downside was the noise from extraction fan.

What a find have never been before but will definitely be back

Lot of space, perfect service, and great beers

Great hidden little pub. We had a couple of beers, quite cheap.

Last visited February 2024 Lovely cosy little bar tucked away. It's worth a visit just for a cheeky one.

The food is excellent. The service is very good too. Due to the restaurant being upstairs, it may not be ideal for some. If you take your time though, it's worth the effort.

Hidden down an alley off of The Royal Mile

A good pub which is a short stroll from Edinburgh Castle - the perfect place to have a beer and something to eat, especially after a walk around the historic district

Really enjoyed our trip to the Jolly Judge. When we walked it in was very crowded but the bartenders still walked us through our drink selections. We found some seating with a lovely couple in the back who allowed us to keep them company. Within about 20 minutes it cleared out immensely but we stayed on for another round. I really enjoyed the neighborhood feel of the place, despite it being right off of a main tourist street. They have a lovely outdoor seating area but it was too cold and rainy to take advantage. I bet in warmer weather it's wonderful.

Beautiful atmosphere and friendly staff. Will come again.

Quiet and cozy. Really nice ambience.

Cozy place with friendly staff and very good drinks! Highlight the warm wine! Absolutely amazing! 😊

Lovely little gem of a pub just off the Royal Mile. Planned on just stopping in for a little while but stayed for a few hours reading my book as the place was so cosy. Great atmosphere and lovely staff.

Very small basement bar with good selection of whisky and beer. Great atmosphere. Good service and friendly fellow drinkers

Lovely, so quaint and cozy. Feels like a movie set.

Located off the Royal Mile, lovely cosy pub. Enjoyed a pint of Tennents with my Husband one afternoon in January 2024, during a short break to Edinburgh. Service was warm and welcoming and the atmosphere was relaxed and friendly.

Hidden nice pub near de castle. Best beers and ciders! Highly recommended!

Nice pub but if love if they played some music

A perfect place on an important tourist route to the city. It seems to be a bar specialized in cider. The ones I actually drank were very good. It also seems to be a place frequented by local people, which makes everything more natural and interesting.