Slice Of New York in Birmingham

The pizzas arrived completely ruined—squashed, toppings everywhere, and sauces spilled inside the box. I called the restaurant directly, but they were unhelpful and kept insisting it was “impossible” and told me to contact Uber Eats instead. No apology or resolution was offered.

Delivered within the timeframe stated when ordered. The biscotti calzone was delicious.

Best takeaway we have had in a long time, everything was spot on! we will definitely be ordering again

Brilliant pizzas, very tasty and nice and hot

BBQ chicken wings were dry and drizzled with bottled sauce. Clearly cooked the day before or morning. Pizza was mediocre. Fries were dry and old. Food came late and was cold

When I went on to order it said 60 - 75mins delivery time so ordered it at 17:40. The delivery time then said 18:35 - 18:45 and there was no further info from the restaurant and they delivered it at 18:00 which wasn’t great as the person coming was 20mins away. If I’d known it was going to be earlier I would have chosen a delivery time.

Great as usual!! fresh, hot , tasty👍🏻

I ordered shrimp pasta, got chicken was still lovely & chicken wings for my 2 fur babys

Tried this for the first time Highly recommend Different to a lot of the others Pizza:fresh ingredients Buffalo wings:addictive flavour you eat one and want more Fries: great not greasy Philly: yummy would order again but without the jalapenos and add a touch of sauce Thanks for the free Biscoff calzonetta: something different maybe do it with a Nutella filling and cream on side 🙌

The order was made at 19:05 and didn’t arrive until 20:30. It dosent take an hour to cook a pizza let alone longer.

Superb and flavoursome pizza and pasta dishes. Tasted freshly cooked and very generous portions. Biscoff Calzone was delicious. Definitely excellent value for money.

Delicious food, so flavourful! Extremely filling, so will last us a couple of days! Biscoff Calzonetta spectacular. We'll be back!

Bay bridge pizza always hits the spot

Excellent 👌🏼 as always thanks 👍🏼

Best pizza iv tasted my new food place

The Cheese and Tomato Pizza with Sweet Butter Crust is probably one of the best in Brum. Just like the ones I used to have in NY

friendly service...food was great😊

When you’re jonesing for a dirty pizza this is the place

Really used to like this place but the pizza dough is now so thin that the toppings don’t even stay on, the cheese isn’t melted properly, and it’s never hot. Was really disappointed with tonight’s meal.

When we ordered the app showed 45-60 minutes, then received a text after 60 minutes to apologise it would be late, waited a further 25 minutes and no update, called the store was met with hostility when questioned how much longer our order would be ,was very harsh and quite rude telling me no it was a minimum of 90 minutes and when I queried that the app showed 45-60 minutes when we ordered again was told no in quite a harsh tone, food ended up arriving 2 hours after we originally ordered

Absolutely delicious , the pasta was delicious and portions were massive.

Always top quality and great tasting food

First time ordering from here, and it was great! it's freezing outside and the food was hot and really fresh. I had a pizza and the Mrs had a chicken quesadila. We also shared some curly fries and were given a free dessert too! Will definitely be ordering from here again.

I ordered 2 calzones and buffalo wings. The food was delicious, but there should be an option to choose the dips that come with the order. Both calzones came with NY sauce, which I didn’t like, and the wings came with blue cheese, which I also don’t enjoy. I requested tzatziki instead, but this was ignored. Offering dip choices would reduce waste and improve the experience. Not sure why delivery took particularly long today but overall amazing food but dips choice would make it 10/10

Upper east pizza is so nice and so is the biscoff calzonetta. Food is always so fresh

Squid Game - Korean Fried Chicken. Worst shop ever. Staff threatening customers, food is crap and clearly running a tax evasion scheme.

Best burgers and best service…by far.

Really delicious food! Many thanks.

Real nice flavour and really enjoyed it!

Pizzas are consistently amazing

Good pizza, good price, usually on time

Ordered pizza & fries for 10 plus a few toddlers! Everyone agreed it was the best pizza they'd ever had! Thank you guys ... food was amazing!

Food was unreal! We ordered 10 mins before closing & came within 15-20 mins! The dough for the calzones was soo fresh😍 Biscoff calzone was absolutely amazinn. Not to forget the Philly steak 😮‍💨 First and definitely not the last time I will order.

Definitely one of the best pizza places around. Forgot to review these guys years ago. The classic Alfredo pizza is just perfection with added spicy beef on top it gets even better. Fries were really nice, sauce was nice. Can’t go wrong with this place at all. So tasty and fresh.

Tasty food and delivered hot! Thank you!

I am regular customer order here every week nearly but today this evening my food came cold and not the service I get normally maybe it was weather but usually my food comes piping hot and burger normally comes in a box wrapped up but today came in foil but hopefully it won’t happen next time

Pizza wasn’t the best, all stuck together and cold, I’m not certain that mozzarella was even used. Otherwise it was good, loved the calzonetta.

we read the positive reviews but weren't expecting much. Definitely worth the hype, though! very pleasantly surprised. the pizza was gorgeous, nice soft base, not too greasy, generous toppings. thank you so much for the free dessert, too! it's lovely, and so big! just all around 10/10 experience, thank you!

local to me, not the 1st time I've ordered from here,really nice & tasty food good portion. lovely family business, always gives me x2 chicken for my fur babies, Thanks guys doing brilliant 👏

me and my partner order here all the time. the food is perfect every time with quick delivery and never any issues at all. our favourite local spot.

Burgers are unreal never had bad food from here

Delicious hot and fresh pizza! Couldn’t be better

This place is unreal been eating here for a few years and the quality and range of food is top notch. Beef burgers 10/10 chicken burgers 10/10 hot dogs 10/10 pizza 10/10 prawns 10/10 fries 10/10 calzonetta 10/10 fat tony burger 10/10. I’ve never had food from here and not enjoyed this place its defo the best around and my top place to order from. 1 thing I recommend from this place is to give an option on any pizza to have hot dog crust i feel that’s the next step for you guys to change the game

Great food but delivered slightly late, also don't think parmesan crust on pizza as per order

Just Eat removed my address so Slice of New York didn't have my details after ordering. They resolved this issue perfectly with great customer service and aftercare! It's great to know that any issues, they will always take care of customers!

Absolutely delicious. The perfect food to watch the fight on Netflix. Thank you so much as always. <3

Delicious cheesy pizza and tasty fries. Would definitely order from here again.

love this place, sad they stopped selling a gyro but the calzone is beautiful as are the halloumi fries. Pleasw have special offers more often, I would eat here every night if I could and get fat off calzone and cheese

Guys you're amazing. I love y'all.

fab pizza as usual. THE best pizza, not greasy at all just full of flavour.

Delicious food, delivered on time by a friendly and polite delivery driver.

great food, great service every time!

Says stuffed crust but i'm not lying when i say, 3 tiny cubes of hotdog in the crust. I would expect the entire crust to have hotdog when i'm paying over 20 pound for a pizza. Also the calzonetta didn't even have a slice of cake in!

my kids really enjoyed their food 😋

defo changed the cheese not my fav only issue

pre ordered my for at 6 for 7.30 food didn't come till 8.15 and was cold joke

Used to be really nice but not sure if new management or chef but unable to follow instruction and cheese is always very stringy and undercooked, although note always added to have cheese well done and not burnt

amazing delicious food, everything was so tasty even the chips!

Amazing as always. Best around! Highly recommend.

First time ordering from here. I really enjoyed the pizzas and fries were really nice too. I would recommend 👍

very nice welcome on collection

Hate to complain but when you have waited over the already extended delivery time only to find it’s not what you’ve order is frustrating. So having said that my order was sent straight out. So customer services was spot on.

fab as usual, can't fault this restaurant, top quality food 👌🏻

I ordered 2 x9inch pizzas . Both with extra mozzarella and garlic butter crust . One was perfect,the other was sweet butter crust instead of garlic butter. only one pizza was eaten . Very very disappointed.

This is my regular pizza restaurant always good quality

Great food, closest thing to a new york pizza.!

What to say about this place it is fantastic food always has been always will be I don’t write reviews normally but this place deserves recognition our favourite take away spot keep up the great work!

Really lovely food and was delivered hot.

Delicious as always. Hot liked it had hust come out the oven. Tastes reslly fresh and has lots of flavour.

perfect pizza, not greasy at all. Best pizza we've had!

really disappointing. the burger tasted chewy and fatty. the chicken wings were chewy. couldn't eat them. have you changed suppliers, it never used to taste that bad?

My drink was missing as well as the incorrect dips being delivered, have got credit back for the dips but its not allowing me to choose the drink as the item missing its only showing the food

Best pizza in brum imo. It's come my default location for pizza's

food get better and better value for money

Great people, even greater food. Pizza time every time...

Excellent pizza and the freebie was delicious, even though we could only manage a few bites each! Thank you!

drink was missed but simple error...driver came back with and food was very nice so overall 👍👍👍

Delicious, fresh, full of flavour, well cooked pizzas. My husband and I enjoyed them very much. Thank you.

Genuinely the best pizza I’ve ever had from a takeaway! We order regularly, think I’m addicted 🤣 the Jackson Heights pizza is sooo good! Highly recommend this place if you want amazing pizzas 😍

The Jackson Heights pizza is so good, flavoured crusts are a nice extra touch too

Had a delivery .which was on time nice hot and fresh when it arrived we had x1 buffalo pizza and one custom one made with spinach and feta. Both were amazing and very tasty the garlic butter crust could taste the garlic with every bite. Would very much recommend and will be ordering from here again soon. Keep up the great work.

Great food as always, value for money and a free dessert!!!

Great food as usual, the best pizza hands down. always fresh and hot. well packaged and great delivery driver.

Absolutely bang on burgers 👍🏻👍🏻

Great food although if going to deliver early would appreciate it if tracking was updated, food delivered before status was flagged as out for delivery

Amazing food highly recommend Thank you so much

Absolutely delicious pizza. Not sure I'd call it american but it was excellent. Food nice and hot and note to restaurant taken into account. Would recommend.

The worse spaghetti bolognese I’ve ever eaten, should have made it at home myself. Buffalo wings and Caesar salad were good though. Overall 3/5

easily the best pizza I've had, everything is very high quality and good to perfection

Food arrived well within its time allocation....pizza was fantastic ..aint had anything like this before . The only downside was that it was a bit tooo salty....apart from that thumbs up from me!

Delivered bang on time - the popcorn was delicious and the pizza was nice

Staff keeps on unnecessarily cancelling orders even with more then enough time to make and deliver the order, not a good sustainable business model to have.

Really enjoyed the food great service 😀

Not what it used to be. Burger covered in that much mayonnaise it wasn't edible.. Waste of money! For the time it took to arrive, I expected better. Very unhappy, used to order from here alot, won't be ordering in future.

was a bit late tonight but it isn't usually, usually it's early, and it's good food, was still hot. idk if they use their own drivers so idk if this is relevant but i'm a difficult address to find but the driver was great.

The new smash burgers are amazing 🤩 🤤

Thanks for the food it was delicious,warm and very filling. *****

Very tasty food and very nice staff. Their pizza is one of the tastiest pizzas you can ever have in Birmingham

The pizzas are some of the best around. Have ordered many times and it's always incredible.

I did get a message telling me the food would be late. The pasta was absolutely to die for - really tasty and I am definately ordering it again, however, the garlic bread that came with it wasn't tasty at all and the bread was a little stale - but it came with the pasta, so I had it. The popcorn was like little chilli cheese bites and these were nice - had these instead of the popcorn shrimp as they were unavailable. I will order from here again