Based on 305 opinions finded in 1 websites
Opinions
Very average food. The menu promises more than it delivers. Our grilled haddock in garlic butter had to have been frozen as the plate was swimming in water when it arrived. To be fair one of our party enjoyed the steak and pastry pie. My advice is opt for the Shoregate instead if you enjoy good food.
Orlagh O . 2024-09-08
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Called into the Golf Hotel looking for breakfast rolls/coffees. Given friendly welcome and made to feel comfortable. Food and drinks brought quickly and all spot on, excellent value for money.
Catherine L . 2024-08-25
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Wasn't expecting a lot as rural Fife has few good eating places, but were pleasantly surprised. The service was excellent, from a very friendly team who gave us a lovely welcome. The Sunday lunch appeared at least part frozen but the lobster was terrific. Well presented with masses of really fresh tomatoes, with the whole lobster neatly dressed accompanied by a large pot of decent size prawns. All clearly fresh. We ate outside in the beer-garden as it was such a hot day. What a great way to enjoy Sunday lunch .
Paul Rusling . 2024-08-16
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Tried here on a day trip to Crail. Booked last minute and were easily accommodated. Had Sunday dinner... steak pie was excellent. The roast was mainly pre frozen,(roast mash and yorkies but the beef was delicious.. Would like to go back and try seafood. Service was excellent.... the beer gardens looks amazing.
Sharon F . 2024-08-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Upon arrival, the hotel was your average typical pub style/ hotel. The entrance is definitely not elderly friendly, and neither are both male and female toilets. The menu was your typical corner pub menu, nothing special. Although it stated the soup of the day was priced at £4.95, and on the wall board, it states soup was seafood chowder. Each bowl had a total of 2 2cm pieces of smoked haddock 3 shrimps, not prawns and around 4 very small pieces of potato. Not knowing what would actually turn up, we decided that with the information provided, we ordered 2 bowls. When we arrived home and read the receipt , not only was the soup lacking in content, but it was more of a clear soup consistency. To add insult to injury, we were charged £10 per bowl when advertised as £4.95. The pensioners steak pie had 4 small chunks of beef. The fish was nice, but unfortunately, the chips were dreadfully dry, which made them practically impossible to swallow. Speaking to two hotel guests, they both stated their meal was very overpriced and standard was very poor. They compared their room as below par and extremely uncomfortable. From our experience, we shall not return a letdown for all.
Stephen G . 2024-07-18
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Our first time in this restaurant and what a fabulous meal we had! The food was really excellent and a reasonable price. All the staff were friendly , the waitress we had was Megan , she was very friendly and efficient - lovely first class service ! We are only staying in Crail for 5 nights but we will be eating out in this hotel again during our stay
Geri M . 2024-07-10
MORE AT TripAdvisor
If you want to experience the local hospitality this is the place to go. The usual Scottish beers on tap with cellared beers mostly also available
InLondonAgain . 2024-07-03
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Centrally located in Crail, the Golf Hotel has a public bar, main restaurant and outside beer garden. The décor in in the main restaurant is quite plain but light and bright. Menu choice is pretty good plus there's specials on the blackboard. As it's Crail, I went with fish and chips which was delicious with fantastic fresh fish. The waffle with ice cream dessert was also good. With the non-alcoholic drinks and coffee it came to about £28, which I thought was reasonable. I'd certainly be happy to east here again.
nobodytoknow . 2024-06-29
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We used the restaurant 5 nights out of 7 for dinner when staying in crail. The dinners were excellent and very well priced. My husband loved the smoked haddock chowder and had the mint ice cream sundae every night! All the waitresses were excellent and friendly but especially Stacey who gave us tips on dog walking in the area We tried the other hotel right next to where we were staying. It was fine dining with a very tight expensive menu and not a patch on the crown. We hope yo come back next year for a wee week and will definitely return for all our meals
Kirsty M . 2024-06-14
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Highly recommend for afternoon tea ! Lovely sandwiches , sausage rolls , scones, cake and ad lib coffee and tea. Oops and Prosecco too
Gwen P . 2024-02-03
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Been a place to visit for the last few years when we have been in Crail. Lovely beer garden that gets the mid afternoon sun. Bar lunches always tasty and reasonably priced. The bar area itself is fairly small but all staff are attentive. Dog friendly for those that feel the need to take a dog everywhere. A tip don’t sit at the table just inside the bar door in Winter or you will freeze from the draught when the door opens.
Droggs . 2023-10-19
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Lovely afternoon in Crail, although it was looking rather forlorn. Lots of homes closed up, many looking very tatty. Clearly too many air BNB and holiday homes. The Golf Hotel was very disappointing. We decided to sit in the beer garden, but wanted to see what beers were available. The barmaid was rude. Said 'What do you want?' in a tone that suggested she was busy and wanted to serve us as quickly as possible. One older gent sitting in the bar, not another soul in the place. We bought our beers and carried them out to the beer garden. It was moderately busy. We noticed that there was a lot of food left on the plates of the folks around us 2 plates on a table of 3 were virtually untouched...not a good sign. There was a large,dried bird poo on our table, seagull, I assume. The plant pots were weedy, and untended, there were cigarette ends around, the gates were open to dumpster bins with litter around them. A gate was propped open with a weed filled plant pot. What a sorry sight. Poor service, poor beer garden and what looked like poor food. Avoid it.
Di and Mike A . 2023-08-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
After a long walk in crail we fell across this lovely pub, amazing food and the staff are just so lovely. Very reasonable in price and a lovely welcoming atmosphere. Definitely recommend you stop by here when your in crail , it won’t disappoint
michelle_012983 . 2023-08-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Simple but great food - well worth a visit. Some outside space and steps, but clean and great staff....
NielCMacclesfield . 2023-08-14
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Ok for a drink in the beer garden but avoid food. Menu limited outdoors & served on disposable plates, despite drinks being served in glass! Frozen chips with poor quality burgers, wraps & halloumi.
Gmk690903 . 2023-07-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Family of 4 visited.... ordered one of the daily specials - salt & chilli squid. There was nothing salt and chilli about it, and it was £15 for 6 or 7 bits of small squid and a salad with no dressing..... Terrible. My husband ordered a chicken goujoun wrap, when it arrived it was chicken goujouns and chips with the same boring salad that came with my squid, no wrap and an extra £4 on top. Kids meals were fine. Service was poor and one of the waitresses quite rude when we asked to order drinks... sent us to a bar, then told us we were at the wrong bar.
anneb78 . 2023-07-20
MORE AT TripAdvisor
There's some pricey restaurants in Crail, so I was pleased to find decent value at the Golf Hotel. For a 3-course dinner and latte coffee I paid about £32, drinks extra of course. They take table reservations by email which is handy. The food, part chosen from the 'specials' board and from the menu was fine although I played it pretty safe with soup of the day, steak pie and a warm brownie. It's a personal preference but I'd have preferred the option of chucky chips rather than thin American style fries. I wasn't kept unduly waiting for food on a Friday night and the service from the waitresses was pleasant although a request for sauce was forgotten about. There's a decent range of drinks available from the (busy) public bar. The dining room is a touch spartan with bare tables and plastic covered chairs arranged for larger groups and families dining; it's not the place for a romantic tête-à-tête. I'd suggest the ambiance could be improved by putting some flowers on the tables, using table mats etc. It wouldn't take much to lift the experience, it's getting close to a staff canteen feel as things are. If you're a holidaymaker in Crail, the Golf Hotel provides decent fare without any pretensions.
nobodytoknow . 2023-07-01
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Popped in for lunch when passing.. Lovely fresh Haddock followed by a nice Lemon Meringue Pie . Good service and dog friendly too.
sandydee_7 . 2023-05-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Had Breakfast here as non residents. Made welcome by Staff. We both had cooked breakfasts and they arrived freshly cooked and hot. First Class. Will visit again for breakfast on our next Crail short break.
ferox85823 . 2023-05-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Visited on Saturday lunchtime for food and drinks and was not disappointed. Delicious food, generous portions and served by friendly and polite staff. Stayed for a couple of drinks in the bar, so cosy and atmospheric really enjoyed our visit!
Karenw824 . 2023-02-21
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Lovely place to sit and have a few drinks, lots of lovely locals who were friendly and keen to chat and tell us about the history of the east neuk. Staff were friendly and welcoming. We didn’t try food as had already eaten but enjoyed our drinks in the bar. Would go back
Venture52352742335 . 2023-01-11
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We had Sunday lunch. The service was lovely & the food delicious. Could not fault the restaurant. The restaurant was quiet.
Ann H . 2022-11-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We were given a warm Scottish welcome when we called in for coffee while waiting to meet up with family in Crail. We were shown the lunch menu and found it to be suitable for all the family. We were happy to book a table for 5 adults and 4 children for later on. The portions were large and tasty and the staff friendly and helpful. Will definitely return.
Compass68593398883 . 2022-09-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We visited this restaurant a few years ago but found it nothing outstanding but thought it was time to give it another chance. Boy, were we so glad we did. Ordered seafood chowder which was so delicious and plentiful. It was a meal in itself. Macaroni and cheese and steak pie also great with decent portions. Desserts are fabulous and really finish off good food. Suzie was an excellent waitress, cheery and very attentive even though she was mainly covering the whole restaurant herself. We will definitely be back.
grannywGlasgow . 2022-09-21
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Having read a couple of recent reviews I wanted to reassure people that covid measures were very good during our stay. We visited friends in Crail and stayed at the Golf for one night. We saw staff cleaning tables regularly and there were signs advising people not to move when seated. Our details were taken and we saw staff do this with others there. Our room was clean and we had no concerns that we wouldn’t be safe. The shower pressure was pretty bad but it’s an old hotel and we were only staying one night. We’ve experienced worse! We ate at the hotel and the food was fine. Pub grub but big portions and perfectly edible. Breakfast was great. Nicely cooked and presented and again with very good cleaning measures in place. We celebrated a friends birthday while there and were seated in an area with another three tables with people and we all could easily socially distance. We ended up all talking together and drinks were flowing but staff popped in and out of the area to check we continued to socially distance from each other. Staff were excellent. So friendly and professional and they definitely enhanced our stay.
weequeena . 2020-09-19
MORE AT TripAdvisor
This is an old run-down hotel which serves good typical pub food served by friendly inexperienced staff and managed by a local man who is doing the best he can under very difficult conditions. I guess his star reviews come from those who prefer rough food and basic surroundings. There is no communication between the beer garden staff and the restaurant and that leads to horrendous situations. The bar and dining areas are supported by some stalwart locals and that is commendable but if the Covid test and protect people become aware of the blatant violations which take place (my daughter - in - law was touching shoulders with the next door drinker)they could well be shut down. Regrettably this is the only bar/restaurant in Crail. If they did cease trading it would be worse for the establishment and for those diners who are not quite so fussy. Just not for me. By the way that lavatory seat in the gents has been like that since reopening (needs fixing) and the window looks like a health hazard but maybe that's me being fussy!! Just saying. I hope this helps
RestingEngland . 2020-09-09
MORE AT TripAdvisor
You can't visit Crail and not visit the Golf Hotel, which has such a great history. Nice relaxed feel about the place and such a close part of village life.
Ross A . 2020-09-03
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We had dinner here and best description is very average. Veg burger and Lasagne pub food that you would expect from a Brewers Fayre. The waitresses were all really nice and attentive but COVID controls were seriously lacking. Not all staff wearing masks abs absolutely no cleaning, wiping or spraying of tables between customers and tables allclose together. Overall disappointing and would not recommend
LouMac7 . 2020-09-03
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We were staying nearby at Sauchope links and walked into crail. Whilst there we had a couple in the beer garden which was well laid out and sheltered. All table service and very covid safe. Will definitely visit again whilst in the area.
DavidBN31 . 2020-08-31
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Good food, good service, good portion size, family friendly and pleasant atmosphere. Covid restrictions applied but didn't retract from the expirience.
Irene189 . 2020-08-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
After a long walk to Crail, we decided to have lunch here as online it said that it was taking part in the 'EatOut' half price deal.It was a nice day so we sat out in the beer garden. We ordered our food and while waiting I remarked to my husband that I couldn't see any signs for the deal, so he asked a waitress and she said that it only applied if we sat inside!This makes no sense as I thought It applied to all sit down meals and only exempt for takeaways. As I felt safer eating outside we had to pay full price.
ruthtJ7824MK . 2020-08-22
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We're locals and fancied a drink after a long walk, late on a hot Saturday evening. We hadn't been back to a pub since the lockdown started. The Golf Hotel beer garden is great: you enter at the back, from Tolbooth Wynd; it's spacious; it wasn't full at all; the tables are far apart; the place is very clean. You sit down and someone will come to take your order. Two pints of nicely chilled Shed Head APA and we were happy. No midgies! And it's warm enough outside if you put a fleece / cardie on. Very friendly service. Good to see the Golf Hotel open again!!
1Magnus . 2020-08-09
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Not a single decent beer on tap today! only Tennents or McEwans and even the Guinness was off What a disappointing experience despite supposedly being a Cask Marque pub
davidmG8987PC . 2020-08-09
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Crail itself is a spectacular place to visit and when in the area The Golf is one of the best for a spot of wholesome bar food, good beer, and a warm & welcoming atmosphere to boot.They also have a cracking little sun trap of a beer garden for those rare days when the Fife climate allows, but well worth a visit year round regardless.Steak Pie or Fish & Chips would be the obvious nods of recommendation!
GaryMenzies . 2020-08-03
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We visited with family, having stayed in Crail many times, but not water here for some time. Although a reduced menu, there was plenty to choose from. The portions were very generous, and service very friendly. Would recommend if you are in the area.
LJ-MA1 . 2020-07-28
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We popped in here for a late lunch and it was superb. My husband is still raving about the dish of the day , sausage casserole! The food was great , the staff were friendly and attentive. If you are in Crail definitely worth a visit
Fiona S . 2020-03-01
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We had a lovely meal here and a couple of drinks. I had the freshest piece of haddock which was lovely and light and the batter delicious. My wife had scampi which was really tasty and plenty of it. A couple of pints and gin and tonic and all for a reasonable price. Our second visit and will definitely be back!
NeilPuddy . 2019-12-01
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We stopped off here for lunch and found that the food was wonderful. The fish was so fresh and the home made desserts were equally as good. We were served by some lovely people who were so friendly and efficient and the prices were reasonable. The food is of very good quality and we would not hesitate to eat there again if we are in the area.
Curious65849876254 . 2019-11-28
MORE AT TripAdvisor
3 of us dropped in for an early lunch we took the Leek and potato soup and the garlic mushroom starters followed by an excellent Lamb Curry ,Steak burger and Chicken burger no complaints there with superb burgers and huge portions Still quiet when we left but the bar was reasonably busy . Service was warm and friendly .
craigluscar . 2019-11-16
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The bar in the Golf Hotel is a cracker. Low ceiling, beams, thick stone walls, traditional furnishings and a real fire in the grate. Add pleasant service, a nice atmosphere and good beer and you’ve pretty much got everything. It’s a super pub.
johnhouston2 . 2019-11-14
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I came here for dinner on a Friday night, booked a table for 6 people for 7pm. When we arrived we were seated in the restaurant, we did notice that it was very busy but we weren’t in a rush. We ordered, 2 kids fish and chips, two steak pies, pensioners steak pie and macaroni which took quite a long time to arrive, no apology or warning that there was any sort of delay. We waited patiently and were rewarded when the food came and was delicious. Dessert, however was a different story...From the specials board two of us chose strawberry pavlova we were so disappointed when it arrived and it wasn’t pavlova. What we had was an individual meringue with a scoop of ice cream with some strawberries scattered on top, it was ok but not a pavlova as advertised. Three of the party ordered Apple crumble with custard not sure what crumble there was but nothing was crunchy it had become mush and was a cross between porridge and raw cake mixture completely tasteless and not at all enjoyable. We all tried this refusing to believe that it could be that bad however all agreed it was inedible and a massive disappointment. One of our party had the vanilla cheesecake which was delicious. When the waitress came to clear the table she just a asked if the plates were finished despite the almost full portions of apple ‘crumble’ still intact and when informed that the crumble was not nice she said she would speak to the kitchen. When the bill arrived there was no apology for the length of time the overall meal had taken, no apology for the poor dessert or explanation of the bill. On checking we had only been charged for one of the three Apple crumbles which i was glad of however given that none of us had eaten the equivalent of one pudding from the bowls I’m not sure why we had to pay for any. Needless to say I won’t be rushing back and on looking at the recent reviews it appears the hotel does not take criticism well so doubt there will be any improvement in the near future.
rolo-dog1 . 2019-10-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Just eaten in the Golf Hotel tonight. My husband and I had the Pensioner's special which was very good value for money. However, the service was very poor....we arrived at 6.30 and there were only 4 people in the restaurant. We ordered some dark ale and the waitress brought us pale coloured ale. We didn't make a complaint! We then had our starter about 25 mins after we had ordered, fine but then our main course never appeared until 1 hour 20 mins after we ordered. The waitress apologised but we weren't even offered a drink on the House for our long wait. Won't be back or recommending the hotel because of our shoddy treatment...it spoiled our evening.
Sandygirl321 . 2019-10-07
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Stayed here many times,not one complaint.dinner many choices and great and courteous staff.great area outside if you have pets or kids,and you cannot beat the breakfast.
davyboyScotland . 2019-09-22
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Friendly staff served excellent Pensioner ‘s High Teas ....well cooked good quality food . Great to be able to get a Pensioners portion although the portion was by no means small ....went twice in 3 days ,!!
Topsy45 . 2019-09-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The Golf Hotel is like taking a step back in time! Super friendly staff, so quiet and lovely homely rooms. Breakfast will not leave you hungry and there is a great bar that the locals drink at for your evening entertainment! 5 stars!
alansco . 2019-09-05
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Although, for whatever reason, my expectations were not high when we arrived, the Golf Hotel turned out to be a gem. Our room was large and had a view of the street. Very clean. Smallish bathroom but what one would expect in an older building.
Alaskantraveler20 . 2019-09-03
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Last day of our holiday, so we popped in here for breakfast before we set off home.
U8357BEalisons . 2019-08-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Absolutely livid! You guys just lost our business forever and everyone one of our friends too. I will also be posting on every single review site known to the world. We come to Crail every summer and I’ve been following you guys on Facebook for years.
DarCyber . 2019-07-18
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Stopped in here for an evening meal as it was dog friendly.
SS1875 . 2019-07-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Tout y est : cadre, amabilité, cuisine de qualité (dont le saumon fumé chaud, à découvrir !), service...
JJFOS . 2019-07-05
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Great service in a friendly hotel. Food was excellent. A large party and handled really well. They don’t do many weddings but it was for a couple that used the hotel many times.
JamesM12856 . 2019-06-17
MORE AT TripAdvisor
My family and I were once again holidaying in Fife.A day in lovely Crail meant another visit to the Golf Hotel for lunch.Once again it didn't disappoint, we sat in the sunshine and ate a smashing meal.Good food, lovely location, friendly staff.
Sheena K . 2019-06-04
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Up in St Andrews area for a weekend of golfing and booked into the Golf Hotel. Made to feel welcome right away, check in was easy and very soon settled into the bar which is quite historic and at the time was busy with a great atmosphere. Bar staff were cheery and helpful. Had dinner there too(haggis, neeps and tatties to start followed by steak pie) which was excellent. Rooms were basic, but clean and comfortable with good showers, everything you need. First class breakfast in the morning. Nice upstairs lounge area where you can relax too. One of the oldest inns in Scotland with a connection to the battle of Waterloo if you like your history. Great place to stay.
Alan P . 2019-04-08
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Lovely staff, cosy bar, great atmosphere.Lovely Tennants !! Very quaint bar with low ceilings and lovely nooks to sit in. Great mix of locals and visitors.
annaCo_kerry . 2019-01-11
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We had two very enjoyable evenings here, good food, very chatty friendly staff and great service sitting next to a lovely roaring fire and sipping well kept beer on a cold evening. Very much appreciated!
boppsey . 2018-12-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Stopped in here whilst waiting for the bus back to Anstruther, we went into the Lounge Bar as we had kids with us and the lady organised some drinks and crisps from the public bar for us. Service was friendly and helpful. quite a few in the Public bar but the Lounge bar was quiet after the lunch time period. Plenty of space and a good range of menus to be had here. Pleasant surroundings and right beside the bus stop so was vey handy for us. Certainly would go back here if in Crail again.
Kelvin T . 2018-12-08
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Dropped in for lunch and we took the Prawn starters followed by the superb Chicken Curry and a huge portion of haddock with chips .We were the first ones in at 12.00 so service was fast and friendly . The place was starting to fill up when we left at 12.40 . The lunch menu looked quite good . There is a nice ambiance to the bar with some of the locals but there are not many tourists or golfers at this time of year
craigluscar . 2018-12-06
MORE AT TripAdvisor
If you want to see history and eat Scottish Pub food then this is the place. Though I never stayed at the Golf Hotel they have just updated the decor. I believe you would enjoy staying at the Hotel
171valencias . 2018-11-08
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We stopped into the Golf Hotel for some lunch before driving back down to Ayrshire after a lovely weekend in Crail. There was a lovely cosy bar but we sat in the restaurant as there was more seating. The girl who served us was lovely and welcoming but it appeared she was on her own. The service was very slow due to this but we didn't complain as it is understandable. 2 of us ordered burgers and the other 2 ordered the braised beef (special of the day). Firstly, the beef was really tough and not like braised beef at all. It seemed it had not been braised for long enough or the wrong choice of beef was made. Braised beef should fall apart and this was actually difficult to slice. The burgers were just ok, nothing special and really salty. Also, they came in a very dry bun and not a brioche bun as stated on the menu. We asked for cheese on the burgers and I was really disappointed that there was a 'plastic' cheese slice melted on there and not a slice of 'real' cheese. The chips were fine as was the salad.
Louise L . 2018-11-05
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Looking for a coffee and a bite to eat after a walk along the coast. Didn't look too promising from the outside but really friendly staff and the coffee and pancakes deal was amazing. Beautiful freshly made pancakes (not crepes) with butter and jam. Exactly what we needed!
I6024ZEandys . 2018-10-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
My wife and I had spent a morning in Crail and were looking for a quick lunchtime snack. I'm very glad we chose the Golf Hotel. The bacon rolls were superb, the best we've ever had, and the tea and coffee were very good. The staff were welcoming and helpful and the service prompt. The Hotel is clearly popular as it was getting very full when we left. The food we saw being served looked excellent. The bar looked very snug and inviting too!
Michael G . 2018-10-23
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The fish platter was as usual superb. This must be one of my favourite dishes. The homemade pate was also delicious.
threecolouredy . 2018-10-09
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Let me start with the positives.
DMCK63 . 2018-10-08
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Vandaag hier een pubmeal gegeten. 1x de leverpate, 1x Fish & chips en de Caesar salad met kip. De eerste 2 gerechten waren prima. De kip bij de salade was een beetje so so. Bediening attent. Jammer dat de Krab op was.
benl852 . 2018-10-04
MORE AT TripAdvisor
It’s certainly worth a try,,,,food is good, menu is typical, service is above average, nice bar on the lower level.... good old local establishment....
KenE1502 . 2018-09-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Had a good few drinks in here and met and chatted to several locals, made me feel very welcome, as did the owner, nice atmosphere
Graham C . 2018-09-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We had high tea, the pensioners size on the menu, which was very generous. The service was excellent. We both had crab which was so fresh and came with a lovely salad and your choice of potatoes, fries etc. There were scones and cakes which were very tasty and more than we could finish. There was also a large pot of tea and more was offered. Altogether couldn't have been bettered. Added to this Mr Guthrie went over and above with service. Excellent value for money.
Shelagh D . 2018-09-11
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The mushroom soup was delicious. I had stroganoff and it was very good, as was my husband's lasagne. The waitress was very pleasant and helpful. A most enjoyable meal. We did not eat in the bar lounge as it looked rather dark. The dining room was fine, pleasant atmosphere.
Kefi74 . 2018-09-09
MORE AT TripAdvisor
I thankfully only stayed one night. I picked this hotel as it said it was dog friendly. I even called to ask were I can eat in the hotel when eating with the dog. I was told only in the bar. I thought ok I know the bar area can be nice. WRONG.
darrbert . 2018-09-09
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Third time we have dropped in over the last 10 years and always leave feeling we were doing them the favour by dropping in and spending our cash. We were moved form one table to the other side of the dark lounge area (even although the place was empty) the food was OK but not hot enough and once served no one came near us. Next time in Crail we will find somewhere else.
Alan S . 2018-08-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Fish and chips was OK but the batter wasn't amazing, the tartare sauce was too sweet (homemade would be better) and the chips were average (I'd suggest double frying). Peas should be served as mushy peas. Little things like that make the difference.Can't fault the service as everyone was nice.
McGmanGla . 2018-08-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The pub/hotel has a restaurant, a lounge, a garden area and a bar. We wanted to eat however we had a dog with us. Dogs are not allowed in the lounge bar or restaurant. It was too cool to eat outside so we went in the bar. Not the ideal place for a nice meal. Very few tables not particularly comfy and we busy/noisy with mainly men who were stood at bar drinking. Just not the right place for a meal. Ironically the lounge bar would have been ideal and wasn’t that busy. The food was average - pub food. I wouldn’t return.
Gail R . 2018-08-07
MORE AT TripAdvisor
There does not seem to be many places to have a meal in Crail. A local suggested the Golf hotel. We tried it and were very impressed with the fresh seafood. The portions are quite large and after a starter and a main course, we did not have room for a dessert. Well worth a visit if you are hungry in Crail.
Brian M . 2018-08-06
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Good quality home cooked style food at reasonable prices. Service could be better. Good vegetarian options
Sandra K . 2018-08-05
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Very disappointed with the snacks we had. My daughter had the cheese and ham sandwich, cheap white bread and presentation could have better with all three meals. I had tuna mayo toastie and didn't like it. More mayo than tuna and tasted very cheap and slimy. Chips were not of good quality. The few salad leaves and half a cherry tomato could have been left off the plates. My grandson had a ham and cheese toastie which he ate because he was hungry and as I had paid he didn't want to waste too much. Better quality and good presentation would have made such a difference and happy to pay more. Couldn't fault the cider, draught, tasty and cold. A lot of flies going about that were a nuisance and a fire door for getting on to beer garden banged shut each time people came in and out. I don't think I would go back. I doubt if the place is suitable for disabled.
OLDWITCH61 . 2018-07-26
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The Fish & Chips at The Golf Hotel are amazing. What a huge portion too. Friendly staff too. I’ll be back!
Colin S . 2018-07-26
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Dropped by on our way to St Andrews. Thoroughly enjoyed our tea had the chefs salmon and smoked haddock fish cakes delicious my husband had fish and chips fabulous. Came back down to Crail for dinner again few days later and on our way home on Friday had morning coffee and fresh pancakes then stayed on for lunch did not want to leave. Food delicious staff lovely so kind and helpful. Garden area ideal for us with our elderly dog we will be back again in a few months.
elizabeth5142015 . 2018-07-15
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Excellent food and service. Food was plentiful and waiting staff couldn't be more helpful. We both asked for slight alterations to menu, these were readily agreed. Plenty of on street parking in this rather nice village.
ALE1502 . 2018-06-26
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Had lunch in the bar, a must if you are visiting. Very local feel and the people are very friendly. Food and atmosphere was just what we wanted. Highly recommend!
coxcs . 2018-06-25
MORE AT TripAdvisor
My wife and I had pre booked a table in the restaurant to celebrate our wedding anniversary. First class service, and absolutely first class food. Very reasonably priced.
BillyJ2267 . 2018-06-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
In Crail with six friends for a golf vacation, the Golf Hotel was a great stop for drinking (no driving...centrally located) and eating. It was so convenient that we ended up going there for multiple meals and multiple drinks...one of my friends went back for drinks almost every night. The staff was very friendly, even though we could get a little loud.
slm999 . 2018-06-21
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We just went for a drink in the Golf Hotel but the friendly welcome we received every night was fantastic. The landlady knows how to keep the real ale well and kept a steady choice of three ales on the bar.
Harris0n2 . 2018-06-18
MORE AT TripAdvisor
While me and my boyfriend were wondering around Crail, we decided to try here. We were pleasantly surprised by what we found!
a1ana3 . 2018-05-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Found this hotel which has been recently refurbished dates back to the 1700's lots of character. Sat outside in their new garden area pretty had our dog with us so ideal nice weather too. Food super had some dressed crab salad fresh and tasty. Staff super so helpful.
elizabeth5142015 . 2018-05-22
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Very disappointing meal. Poor service and uneatable chicken curry. Beef burger over cooked and dry. Beef pie over salted. Would not recommend this establishment.
Joan H . 2018-05-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Petit restaurant familial. Nous avons pris du crabe un vrai régal !
Bertrand D . 2018-05-11
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We visited several times during the Easter weekend. We had great food - fresh dressed crab and home made pate for example. They were happy to cater for gluten free diets. And what a lovely atmosphere - lovely big open fire and cosy corners for family games of cards! Thank you
Ellieedin . 2018-04-03
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Enjoyed a lovely meal in this hotel. Bar staff attentive to detail. Warm towards guests and our four legged friend harley.
Anne H . 2018-03-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
staying at the nearby lodges. Went in for a couple of pints with my wife and wee dog, sat beside coal fire. :) Nice and friendly lady serving and the Crail Ale was great. Went in again with my parents a couple of days later and they also thought is was a really relaxing pub.
BrianScotland73 . 2018-03-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Stayed locally at Seabreeze Cottage a 5 minute walk from the pub. We were a party of 2 couples, the men enjoyed the sky sports and hospitality over our weekend stay.
brad123186554 . 2018-03-01
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Dropped in for coffee, enticed by the pancake offer.
AMCUK . 2018-02-01
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Mid afternoon meal as food not available at golf course at that time. Had the lunch specials of lamb casserole and mince, haggis, needs and tattles. All OK but nothing special. The menu had some decent choices. All reasonable prices.
ifand . 2018-01-29
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Classic pub food, well prepared, and efficient service make the Golf Hotel a good choice for a meal. The menu...
ann m . 2018-01-20
MORE AT TripAdvisor
As we were staying in the cottage across the street it would have been rude not to have visited, lovely...
johnrawlinson . 2017-10-30
MORE AT TripAdvisor
We were not impressed with the hospitality of this restaurant. No one greeted or seated us, and it took awhile...
Alison K . 2017-10-27
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Popped in with some friends for a pint went back for a meal. Good value pub grub, the staff were...
FlamingoFleming . 2017-10-24
MORE AT TripAdvisor
The place is much larger on the inside that it appears from the outside. There is a pub in front,...
geismom . 2017-10-13
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Good pub with a friendly atmosphere plus a sunny beer garden at the back. The food looked very nice although...
Chubster106 . 2017-10-12
MORE AT TripAdvisor
My wife and I both tried the haddock and chips based on previous reviews and were disappointed. Whilst the food was adequate and filled a gap, it is also of average quality.
Romiley . 2017-10-11
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Popped in here whilst in the area. Small, friendly bar:) We just had a cheese toastie but nicely served with crisps on the side.
karenhutcheson . 2017-10-02
MORE AT TripAdvisor
Similary restaurants in Central Scotland
17 Opinions
Went for steak night but extremely disappointed. Asked for medium steak but was more rare.Few soggy chips, hard peas and two underdone soggy onion rings. No salad as advertsed. Food was also cold. Asked for a prosecco and was told had no cold ones . Was given small one off top shelf behind bar but when I opened it it was completely flat and very yellow so I think it must have been on the shelf a long while! Lady opened big bottle which again came from top shelf so was not cold but was bubbly. Can't believe there was no bottles in wine fridge. Sticky toffee pudding was good though. Seeing as there was just one other couple in the restaurant there really was no excuse for steak meal being so poor as kitchen not rushed. Won't be rushing back!!!
43 Opinions
Great location on the Old Course. Beautiful modern terrace on the top floor with stunning views across the fairways to the sea. So wanted to like this place but were disappointed. Food was standard golfing fare - steaks and lobster - OK but nothing special . Wine list reasonable for price and choice. What lets the place down is the lack of management oversight. Tables with broken legs, jet lagged golfers asleep in the lobby, incredibly noisy ambience all overseen by a well meaning but overwhelmed serving staff. Not what you expect when paying $400 for a meal for two. Dinner took three and a half hours. We had to track down staff to order wine, coffee and get the check. Could be a good dining alternative to the Old Course Hotel but its let down badly by the service. Seems its owned by one of those absentee investment companies and it shows .
521 Opinions
When the weather turns cold, shops closed, you don’t want a restaurant, just a cuppa, Alexander and George will make you welcome. Enticed by the chips! Feel much better now. Thanks guys!
156 Opinions
Had afternoon Tea today(Sunday). The view is stunning, overlooking the golf course and the Forth. We had to wait around 10 minutes and received 4 types of sandwiches, a plain scone and fruit scone and a variety of cakes. The scones were some of the best I’ve ever had- warm from the oven, the cakes were light. We received a bottle of water and large pot of tea but had to ask for glasses. The toilets were a bit more dated than the restaurant but clean
76 Opinions
Arranged to meet friends here for a lunch and a catch up. This is a very popular visit with very pleasant surroundings through a very large conservatory contributing to a very well lit area. There are a number of tables within the conservatory and your extensive menu is on the table. There are hot and cold food choices ordered at the server and brought to your table. We opted for chicken and rice soup and tomato and vegetable soup. To accompany the soup we ordered cheese and onion toasties and cheese and ham. We had carrot cake put aside for later that was the last of it. The chicken soup had a distinct homemade stock flavour with generous amounts of chicken through the rice and veg. The toasties came with crisps and side salad and coleslaw on the side. They were very well cooked with a generous filling. Finally the piece de resistance the home baking carrot cake came bursting with flavour very moist and topped with a very sweet icing. Would not hesitate to recommend to anyone and will definitely be back.