Get Stuffed Pizza in Pembrokeshire

Probably the most disappointing pizza I have ever had from a specialist pizzeria, I cannot believe for a moment that the base was fresh dough produced in the kitchen, just resembled a shop bought or frozen one. Paid £17-50 for a pizza that was not better than a £4-00 supermarket one. Will not be returning.

Excellent food, lots of options, well baked Pizzas. Staff are very welcoming and cosy atmosphere

Pricey but very good quality and pretty quick to deliver.

Best pizza about loads of flavour. And very warm and welcoming staff. Definitely be returning

Being locals and having passed this place many times, we decided to give it ago as the menu looked lovely. Unfortunately to our disappointment the food was absolutely terrible. Steak and Mustard Tagliatelle Sauce seemed to simply be cream with a jar of whole grain mustard chucked in. Chorizo and Prawn Pasta Chorizo hard and chewy Prawns - didn’t exist, the size, texture and taste were like potted shrimp. Was up most of the night ill after eating this! Definitely will never visit again and would recommend finding somewhere else if you want to experience quality food without the sickness.

We enjoyed the food overall but we did think the pre made pizza bases could have been of a better quality. There’s very little atmosphere in the place. The music and lighting could have been more ambient in keeping for a pizzeria and the lack of some Italian art on the wall etc renders the setting soulless.

My cheap frozen pizza tastes very similar and having ordered a medium size I could swear it was a kid's size. Staff was friendly though

Really great service, very friendly staff.

Great food and great choice always visit when we are in Narberth

Lasagne was lovely. Really rich Ragu. Both my daughter and husband enjoyed their pizzas. Garlic bread both as accompanying lasagne and the cheesy side were tasty. Would eat here again.

Had a really delicious takeaway delivered to Bluestone this weekend. Food was easy to order, arrived on time, hot and huge portions (plenty of leftovers for the next day) tasty and fresh. No complaints from a hungry group of 4 adults and 2 teenagers. Would definitely recommend and I will be back for more on my next visit to Tenby this summer.

The worst take out I have ever had. The Satay chicken was burnt, the chilli nachos consisted of a separate bowl of nachos with a separate bowl of dried up chilli beef and cheese on top. The thin based pizza was overdone and slightly burnt.

Cannot go wrong with dining in restaurant or having delivered, we haven’t had a time it’s been cold or chewy , would definitely recommend going with the mountain ,it’s worth every penny

Possibly the worst pizzas we’ve ever had - how can a pizza restaurant get it so wrong? Cheap frozen bases and barely cooked toppings, wish I’d paid the extra and gone to Top Joes for takeaway up the road, needless to say we won’t be going back!

Nice place. Great food. This was our 3rd visit and it didn't disappoint.

Took 90 minutes to deliver very mediocre pizzas 5 minutes down the road. Bases are clearly manufactured/bought in and nigh-on tasteless. Toppings are, when correct for the order which they weren’t for us, just warmed through enough to melt the cheese. Possibly the worst pizza ever and no better than an own-brand shop bought pizza.

We visited on a Tuesday evening, although quiet, we enjoyed this restaurant. The girl serving was polite and made us feel welcome, even taking time to chat with us. The food was amazing, my daughter is a picky eater and she ate everything. The restaurant was clean and comfortable. A definite must to visit.

Good Pizza's we had the thin crust base Hawiian and spicy one and they were both really nicely laid out with the toppings and cooked really well. My dad had the mushroom carbonara. The food was excellent, and the chocolate fudge cake was delicious too. The service was really good too. If you want to have choice for pizza and pasta, then this is a must visit

Excellent little restaurant (also does takeaway). Pizzas and pasta are superb and full of flavour.

We went here without a booking and were seated by a friendly waitress.. the food was great and the service was fantastic. We had 4 empty plates and the desserts were amazing. A great experience!

What a fantastic place. The garlic bread was perfection and the pasta delicious and in generous portions. Our waiter was excellent, attentive and quick. Highly recommended this place, it's a little gem.

I found the atmosphere to be relaxing and enjoyable. Even though the restaurant was quite the sense of relaxation was very nice. I had the Potato Skins with cheese and ham followed by the steak, mushroom and mustard sauce on a bed of tagliatelle. The sauce for me was very smooth and tasted like velvet with a very subtle kick. The side salad what plentiful and crisp with bell peppers, onions, tomatoes and cucumber. The dressing was very sharp and sweet that cut across the pallet nicely. Unfortunately I was unable to try the deserts but went with the vanilla ice cream again very nice. Thank you guys please keep up the excellent service and work.

Lovely restaurant food was lovely would have given it 5🌟 but it could have done with more cheese. Will go back next year 👍🏻

Absolutely loved this place, and found it by accident after the place we intended to go had stopped serving food. It's a really lovely environment, very comfortable, nice ambience. The food is great if you like American style pizza like we do, delicious with lots of choice. Not just pizza, a decent amount of pasta dishes, and lots of starters. Prices were great. But the main thing for us was the lovely lady who served us, she really made the experience, what a gorgeous person . Definitely recommend going if you're in Narbeth.

Really good food, very friendly staff. I recommend the Pepperoom pizza...Will be back again for sure.

Excellent food and great friendly service, everything freshly cooked, couldn't fault anything. Will definitely be returning

I have never been to a place where the staff are so friendly and the food is outstanding such a lovely place and vibe when in the restaurant

Whenever I visit my mother in Pembrokeshire I looks forward to visiting Get Stuffed!!! The Lasagne is the best I’ve ever had…. One of life’s little treats!!!! Love it!!!

This week we ordered 2 large pizzas to be delivered, we were expecting a traditional pizza outlet, nothing like it. It cost us £28, the pizza bases were factory frozen bases, I could only compare them with stale bread. To be quite honest the children persevered and manage to eat only half, we tried to eat some and had to throw it in the bin. Absolutely shocking. I have been informed if your in Narberth then go to top joes, that is an authentic pizza outlet. The only person that’s been stuffed is me.

Great pizza and lasagne was one of the best I’ve had. Absolutely delicious. Would highly recommend. Service was friendly and efficient

Very disappointed with the pizzas, very poor quality, frozen bases and poor ingredients leading to a disappointing experience. The pizzas are no better than the cheapest supermarket pizzas you can get for less than half the price. The restaurant itself looked lovely but only one table so showing people are aware

Great to find a pizza restaurant with vegan options. We ordered the large deep pan options which turned out to be way bigger than we expected, but we took it home in a box to eat the next day. 😁

Wonderful experience, great food, lively staff. Would come again… In the centre of Narberth, a lovely town with plenty of attractions.

Grate place very good quality and service and best pizza and pasta dishes I've ever had. This is my third visit to get stuffed . 👍

Nice looking, cosy restaurant and friendly staff. Unfortunately the food wasn't worth the money. The pizza wasn't good - the base was like a cheap supermarket-bought one, definitely not homemade. Pasta was okay, but not great.

Really enjoyed the evening with very tasty pizzas and pastas, very generous on the toppings for pizzas and all food was piping hot. With lovely service from Helen, who made sure everything was perfect. Would highly recommend it if you want an Italian meal in the pretty town of Narberth.

Lovely Italian restaurant and far better than just a Pizzeria. We both had pasta which was cooked to perfection. Excellent friendly service.

Visited twice whilst staying in Narberth. Food was fab, service exceptional and restaurant is lovely. Our waiter, Lewis, was so helpful, even sending us a link to the music that was playing in restaurant. The food was delicious, from pizzas and pasta (lasagne and tagliatelle Bolognese) and desserts (lemon sponge and toffee cake) every mouthful was yummy. Would recommend 100%, will definitely be back.

It was surprisingly quiet in Narberth, but we had a very warm welcome from the lovely waitress who looked after us very well. The food was delicious and the music created a warm ambient atmosphere. We had a very generous and delicious tagliatelli Bolognese. They were obviously very busy with takeaways, but very attentive. Thank you.

Great food, had it delivered by a lovely chap. Have eaten in also which was very good ,can definitely recommend.

As per other reviews a very disappointing pizza base made these pizzas very average. We ordered takeaway, all ready on time etc.

Excellent service however the food didn't match up. Pasta carbonara was just OK. Pizza was like something from a supermarket. Not good value for money.

Last minute decision to eat out and loved it. Great pizza, helpful and accommodating staff. Lovely surroundings. Thank you!

Absolute gem of a place. Exceptional service and fantastic food. We'll definitely come again when we next visit the area.

Great food and very friendly service. A friendly small venue but they happily accommodated our family group of 14

We ordered take away from here a couple of times and have really enjoyed it. Food was very tasty and well presented. Highly recommend.

We thoroughly enjoyed our meal here. As well as the excellent pizzas, we noticed careful attention to detail, friendly staff and how well families were welcomed. A pleasure to eat there - strongly recommended.

Had an amazing pre-theatre meal with my wife. Everything perfect from the start. Amazing welcome and polite and courteous service from the young man on front of house. Will definitely return and would highly recommend.

Great service and nice place but they need to stop misleading customers re fresh made pizza bases as these are definitely bought in. Perfectly circular and do not taste one bit like fresh baked bases. Cannelloni was also disappointingly not fresh made. Tasted like it has been bought in and microwaved. Such a shame as had high hopes and our waitress was lovely

It was OK at best. Dont like to be negative but for a pizza place it should be handmade pizza dough bases. They are bought in, in my opinion. There was hardly any cheese or toppings on any of the pizzas we ordered to take away. All i could see on mine was the tomato base. Toppings were sparse. But the prices I suppose are reasonable. You get what you pay for. Ordering was straight forward. Sorry get stuffed but you really need to make your own bases bit more generous on the Toppings too.

Disappointing experience at supposed 'authentic' pizza place. We visited this pizza place hoping to enjoy a more authentic pizza experience, as other options in the area were kebab shops. Unfortunately, our experience fell short of our expectations. Crust: The crust was disappointing, as it seemed to be a ready-made crust that was cooked to the bare minimum. Toppings: The toppings were tasty and the only saving grace of the pizza, which prevented us from giving a 1-star review. Service: The overall service was lacklustre. The restaurant was empty when we arrived to collect our order, which gave off an unwelcoming atmosphere. It seemed like an inconvenience when we collected our pizza, as we ordered 1 hour before closing. Misleading appearance: Despite the restaurant's purported authenticity, we found the place to be misleading. This view was shared by other reviewers. Conclusion: In summary, the pizza was okay, but the undercooked crust and lackluster service left us feeling disappointed. We feel this restaurant is not worth visiting again.

What a lovely pizza/pasta place in Narberth! The lovely lady serving made us feel right at home when we arrived, and the place felt well designed and perfectly clean. The food was great and well priced. We all had a cracking time, and we were all full as eggs by the end.

Always a great experience visiting get stuffed pizzas, from the moment you enter the restaurant your greeted in a friendly manner, the staff are always smiling and happy. The food is always delicious, highly recommend! Great service as always.

The place was empty on a Saturday night so a bit weird to start off with - but was clean and the decor fine. Sadly the food was awful. This is not an authentic pizza place. No pizza oven and the base was obviously shop (frozen) bought. Very disappointed.

Great food lovely friendly restaurant the manager Helen was very friendly and helpful. I would definitely recommend coming to get stuffed pizza in Narberth

Visited this restaurant with some friends after booking online. A great find in Narberth. I had a lovely pasta with chorizo in and my friend that I was visiting with had an Andy pandy pizza which he said was lovely. Really good cheesy fries on the side too. The man who served us had great menu knowledge and gave us advice of the local area. Really enjoyed the wine and vibe of the restaurant. Great value for money, will, definitely return if I visit Pembrokeshire again.

I have to split my rating into 2 parts - venue and food. Venue: Lovely place, well decorated and light. Background music was also just right. Our waitress was very polite and friendly 5/5 Food: With a name like Get Stuffed Pizza Co, I assumed that the pizzas would be authentic and amazing, unfortunately this not the case, although the pizza I had wasn't horrible, I expected more. Normally I like to see pizzas that clearly show they are handmade e.g. not perfectly round and not perfectly flat. The pizza I had was both, suggesting bases are not made on site. The tomato sauce could have been more flavoursome. The additional ingredients I added were good quality though. I think the pizza's could be more authentic - currently it's the only thing that can be improved 3/5 Overall 4/5

It just wasn't very good. Firstly, it's always a warning sign when you're there on a bank holiday weekend at peak time in the evening and the restaurant is empty. They clearly knew something I didn't. Maybe the cost of living crisis has hit them hard but everything seemed as if they'd gone to Iceland for their dishes. The garlic bread looked like what you get from Asda. The pizza bases were definitely from frozen. They were really bready and not like dough. The person serving was always trying to upsell which is fine but when your dish already comes with salad don't try and sell me extra salad. She also kept saying everything was home cooked. She made a slip and said homemade but swiftly corrected herself. Unfortunately the whole experience wasn't great and none of our party came away rating it any more than a 1 star. I do hope that they can get themselves to make more fresh made dough and home cooking. I'm all for supporting local businesses but unfortunately next time I'm in Narberth I'll walk the other way.

Absolutely loved it, get stuffed is the nicest pizza place around, couldn't of been happier with it and the service was excellent, will definitely be going there again!

Had a stunning take away delivered for our bank holiday date night! Have eaten at the lovely restaurant in Narbeth but first time at home. Did not disappoint. Hot & fresh to go with our 🍷

Great for evening out couples friends or families. We were there Thursday could not believe how quiet it was for a place serving such good food at reasonable prices with excellent staff and service. A must visit eating place in Narbeth

Me and my husband were told about this place as pizza lovers we come down and stay locally every so often and have loved this place staff were brilliant and the pepperoni pizza we shared was more the enough, location was Narbeth whom we had...

Tasty pizza, chicken carbonara was fab. My 8 year old son loved the pizza - best he’s had. Friendly waitress/owner(?). Puddings delicious. Highly recommended.

Great pizza, fresh toppings and really tasty. The environment is lovely, clean and staff are very welcoming. We had a great experience this evening.

Went here for meal whilst visiting Narberth. Had lovely lasagne and garlic bread with chilled bottle of Prosecco. Staff were very helpful and friendly and waiter was very attentive. Beautiful desserts, chocolate fudge cake and toffee sponge, both served with ice cream. Gorgeous meal in...

Lovely greeting when entering. Very nice place with a great choice of pizzas on the menu. Four of us had different things and we all enjoyed. Will definitely be back.

Very bad pizza was like eating bread with chicken on top very little sauce , shame as just moved to the area and won’t be returning

It does exactly what it says on the tin! The food is gorgeous, and the service is amazing. It's warm, friendly and inviting and the portions will definitely get you stuffed!

It does exactly what it says on the tin! The food is gorgeous, and the service is amazing. It's warm, friendly and inviting and the portions will definitely get you stuffed!

Ordered pizza and carbonara, the food was not bad but the tomato sauce needs seasoning, and the pizza base was very bland and so i think it would be worth finding a new recipe/ provider for the dough. The carbonara was nice but also lacked seasoning. The garlic bread was lovely and so were the spicy wings.

Great food, good value, nice atmosphere. Good choice of kids meals and we really enjoyed the pasta. Will try pizza next time.

Lovely warm restaurant with great food. Pizza was cooked to perfection. If your in Narberth visit this place. Pasta dishes and pizza for all tastes. Thanks for a great night. 👍.

Expected a fresh base, clearly came from a box, not worth the price paid for quality.

They don't really cater to plant-based diets or gluten-free vegan. It's really difficult to order these things from them.

Fantastic food and service, would highly recommend eating here, very clean and tidy as well,

I ordered a 9 inch pizza to take away from Get Stuffed as I wasn’t hungry enough for a 12inch. If I knew the thin based Hot and Spicy was going to be as nice as it was I’d have ordered two 12 inch ones...

We ordered a selection of pizzas including vegetarian, garlic baguette, potato wedges and wings and they were AMAZING!!.All perfectly cooked without any greasiness. We ordered in the restaurant to take back to our holiday accommodation. The staff were extremely helpful and recommended options when we...

Prompt service. Not the best I've ever had but not the worst either.

Gorfeous food helpful and friendly staff

On the look out for a pizza and tried this place after the supposed hot place to go in town (T** J***) couldn’t be bothered to open or answer the phone. This turned out to be a very happy accident. We had the warmest of...

Family friendly, nice atmosphere and good food. Waitress friendly and helpful. Would recommend.

Been here 3times staff very friendly and helpful very accomating lovely food

The whole family had been struck down by covid and I called to see if they were happy to deliver pizza to us. Amazing, the delivery was like a military operation and very professional. The kind lady that delivered our pizza was very kind and...

Came out fancying a pizza and was not disappointed. Lovely staff and the food was freshly cooked and amazing. If you have the chance would certainly recommend. The waitress was lovely also. Very family friendly

It's alright. It's obvious the bases aren't home made. If they were it would be 4* if it was mozzarella it would be 5* toppings all nice & generous. Not worth the £30 for 2 pizzas + a sauce but could be awesome if the bases were fresh. If I lived here, I'd go again but it could be better.

It was fantastic and the pizza was lovely! :) me and my family went here and the staff were so kind and welcoming, indoor and outdoor seating, all in all a lovely family dinner, would defo visit again! 😊

Came across this restaurant after searching for pasta in the Tenby area, stunning pasta - had the chorizo and prawn. Super quick and brilliant service!

Staying on a farm in the middle of nowhere but no problem for these guys, they delivered exactly when we wanted and what a beautiful meal it was probably the best kebab I have ever had

Staff very friendly and helpful. Food absolutely excellent and good value. Would thoroughly recommend this restaurant.

We went in by chance, looking for something to eat on a Sunday evening. Everything was well cooked and hot but lacked any authencity of a true Italian. Perhaps their not trying to be. There was plenty of topping on our pizzas so no skimping there. The bases were unleavened, tasteless and not dissimilar to cardboard. Supermarket pizzas can be forgiven for this type of base but not a pizzeria. We also ordered dirty fries and was presented with curly fries and parmesan sprinkled on top. Not what we expected. As seen on this forum, they have plenty of 4 and 5 star ratings so plenty of people would disagree with me.

Another visit to this amazing restaurant. Down on holiday locally & called in, they were quick to accommodate us. Very family orientated & felt relaxed bringing my 10 year old. Had 2 pizzas & garlic bread. Great red wine too. Excellent service again from the...

Zeer vriendelijk onthaal, gezellig terras, ruime keuze aan pizza´s en pasta. De eigenares maakt graag een praatje en is oprecht...

I visited Narberth for the first time and managed to get a table here despite it being exceptionally busy. This place had a contemporary interior contrasted with some run down in other restaurants I had visited. I was served by a young gentleman who was...

A regular at Get Stuffed Pizza, I always get consistent pizzas which beat all others around. With due consideration to the quality and consistency of the food, clean and healthily bustling atmosphere, and low cost this must be one of the best restaurants in the...

myself and partner love pizza and pasta and this is perfect restaurant for this. We were greeted in a very friendly manner and the service was exceptional by all members of staff. My partner is a chef and very hard to please when we eat...

Whenever we visit Pembrokeshire, wherever we are, we always take a trip to Narberth for one of the highlights of our holiday; GET STUFFED PIZZA. We have gotten to know the owners; they always make us feel as though we are locals and more importantly...

lovely time with the family. Place is great to eat in and food was amazing. definately will be coming back soon.

Agree with the previous review regarding the pizza . Firstly the sizes aren’t accurate , they appear to be very small for a pizza . The pizzas are dry, overcooked and tasteless . If you have pasta then prepare for it to be very oily...

Our family were excited to have their favourite treat, pizza. Get Stuffed appeared to be exactly the type of restaurant that we were looking for, how wrong this decision proved to be. Our server was a very pleasant young man, the same could not be...

Very helpfull staff and great tasting pizzas with plenty of toppings