Cafe Casita Ristorante Italiano in Dudley

Sadly, having heard how good this place was we , a group of four, decided the place was too expensive for the service we received. I appreciate when they are cooking we have to wait, but to put our food on the table when it is nearly cold? I am sorry, but our four meals were under cooked? That is not what I would expect from a place so expensive. To be fair the food once re heated was good, nothing special, but good. The premises are in an old pub, sadly, I felt it was a bit dark and dingy, tables were quite cramped and in truth it all needs freshening up! Sadly, we don't think we will go back even though the food was as I said above, nothing special but good!

The Best pizza in town,fluffy top, fresh ingredients and insanely good taste.

We had a lovely evening meal and were really pleased with our overall experience. The staff were very attentive, the food was served in very good time and tasted delicious. There was a very extensive drinks list, lots of vegetarian options, and the atmosphere was very good. We would certainly recommend Cafe Casita to others.

We love this place, always get the same table which we love thank you! food is delicious as always with lots of choice, a good selection of beers wines and cocktails and service spot on, lovely people very friendly highly recommend.

Great food. Setting is authentic and unique. Ambience is a relaxed one, but not too quiet. This was my second visit... so looking forward to my next 👍😁

Today me and my friend went to the restaurant as our day out expecting to go to a proper 'italian' restaurant, however we found the opposite to be honest. As the main meal I ordered a steak (fillet ross) for THIRTY POUNDS. When I received the steak after the mediocre starter and was genuinely annoyed. The olives where awful by the way. The actual steak was probably the worst I've ever eaten. It was in the shape of a square which is suspicious considering everything is fresh. The actual taste of it was awful and you could say it was similar to paper. It was served with potatoes that were definitely frozen and some vegetables. Overall the price was an abomination and the food was absolutely awful. I will never be coming back and I couldn't recommend it less.

Absolutely beautiful food and service quite expensive and the drinks are way overpriced shame really enjoyed it but the prices are too overpriced

Not as good as it used to be for food tried the pizza was like trying to eat a slab

Lovely meal, customer service very good, recommended

Food was lovely, service was great and lovely atmosphere. Not so keen on the decor. Highly recommend

Excellent meal & service. Very friendly & efficient staff..

I feel so lucky that Cafe Casita is a 5 minute walk from where I live, this is the second time I have visited this place with my wife since moving to the area and it is amazing. I believe it is a family owned Italian restaurant with a rustic Italian theme inside. You need to book as it is always busy, and rightly so, the food is absolutely amazing, tasty and is presented beautifully. Listen to the mature lady if she suggests a dish as my wife had the scallops that she suggested and I was left wishing I had the same. The outside of the restaurant could do with a slight uplift but when inside that really doesn't matter.

Fabulous place, lovely food, well worth the visit

Outstanding food and service will be going again

Our evening at Сasita was ruined. All the dishes were overly salty, and the drinks were terrible. When we asked to replace a salty dish, they brought us the same one without even trying to fix the issue. Moreover, we asked to remove the bacon from one dish, but the bacon was still there. Overall, our experience was extremely negative. We do not recommend this restaurant.

Extensive menu, well prepared food and very tasty. Pity that you get the feeling they are penny pinching, no bread with the soup and very small glasses of tap water for instance. And what is it with the red cabbage which they have been serving with the mains for years and years. Also the wine prices are staggering for what is pretty ordinary wine.

Lovely place, great food. Careful though, the portions are huge.

Great but quite expensive compared to other restaurants

Food was really nice, but service was slow. Staff seemed friendly.

Came in here for a midweek meal and was not disappointed. Food was well presented and cooked just right; I had the quattro formagio pizza which was delicious, and my friend had the spaghetti carbonara which she assured me was delicious: all the sides (salad, olives, bread) were tasty. The service was polite and genuinely friendly. The only fly in the ointment, so to speak, was the charge of £1.20 to have a small jug of milk with my coffee. I thought that extra charge was totally unnecessary and tbh I don't think I've ever been charged to have milk with my coffee in any restaurant! Also, their card machine was not working and I had to pop out to an atm to get cash.

We have just dined here, our second chance after our first visit. Unfortunately, the service was extremely slow again and staff were very forgetful with simple requests. After giving them the benefit of the doubt, we sat with empty plates for 10-15 minutes and asked three different people for the card machine. After another 15 minutes, the third person got very defensive and told us the card machine was down. The whole approach was very abrupt and no one seemed like they wanted to help. After spending £47 and no sincere apology or offerings, they have now lost customers and we will not be recommending in the future. I am all about second chances and understand when restaurants are busy, but this has been an excuse both times. I have been a waitress for many years but would never ignore or treat my customers this way. A shame as the food is lovely.

I ordered for collection, it was a right faf, if the restaurant don't accept your order within 3 minutes your order gets cancelled and you are refunded. I did this twice and then had to phone the restaurant where the women said they were not that busy and she would stand by the iPad so she could accept my order. Once she did this I placed my order. I think this is a stupid way of doing online orders. We ordered 2 pizzas and tiramisu. Don't get the pizzas! It is like chewing cardboard I was very disappointed as heard great things about this restaurant. However tirimisu was beautiful🤩 went back for pasta this time and have to be honest it was beautiful. Such a shame the pizzas let this restaurant down :( if you go defo get the pasta not the pizza!

Amazing food 🥘 and best experience recommend 100%

An absolute gem. No issues from me about anything. Great food, superb staff. Well worth it!

We love Cafe Casita, food is always lovely and the atmosphere is good too

Beautiful food, cosy and homely atmosphere. Staff are lovely and welcoming. My new favourite Italian

Family went today for mother's day .food was fantastic and reasonably priced

Great service and excellent food. We had three Pizzas which were all equally tasty on freshly prepared handmade bases and baked in a traditional pizza oven... ...Delicious😋

Came here for the first time today, as it was mother's day. Really enjoyed the service and meal. The staff are great. We enjoyed the whole experience. Iazmina was particularly amazing. Simply magnificent. Not forgetting Tyler and Connie. They're all good

I just love this place, the two ladies are amazing, always on the ball with a smile on their faces even when super busy, the good is excellent, the lasagna even beats my favourite tattoria in Bologna. Michelle🥳🥰

Excellent pre valentine's meal food fab, it's not fast food but it's good!

Lovely atmosphere. Delicious food, excellent service and great wine will definitely go back

Not enough fish in my dish my husbands was amazing though, so would still go back

Amazing food hadn't been there for a while but will definitely be back

Gorgeous decoration, it's a very nice dining experience

First time in Cafe Casita,excellent service, excellent food and we will be back.

Great food and atmosphere with lovely friendly staff.

Great night spent for our friend's birthday. Excellent choice of food and the quality was superb. Finished off with a Lemonchello 🥂

Best restaurant in Sedgely gr8 food and super Staff. It makes you feels like your somewhere else when you step inside .

great place to eat, highly recommended

Great service, good atmosphere, the staff is friendly. The food is excellent and plentiful, the price is as expected, the parking is adequate for the number of spaces. It looks small in the photo but the dishes are big. I recommend it and will definitely go back.

Um lugar muito bom para um jantar especial. Comida deliciosa! E em quantidade. Um bom atendimento. Um ambiente maravilhoso. Voltarei assim que poder, novamente.

A lovely meal here this evening, enjoyable atmosphere with attentive staff

Been before. Was better last time . Food was ok. Service fair. Atmosphere ok .would go again but hopefully next time better

Nice meal just tend to put too much sauce on the plate so always ask for it to come separately. They ran out of Tiramusu which is one dish you expect an Italian restaurant to always have. Also uble to do a pina coloda due to lack of ingredients too.

After waiting 15 minutes to be seated and left standing like lost sheep at the front waiting at a bus stop, four of us had to wait a further 25 minutes to be offered a drink! Not a very Impressive introduction to a quaint and homely restaurant. What a shame the quallity of food, service and welcome did not meet any acceptable standards. As an italian restaurant, it really let the their Italian flag down with young staff that were overran like headless chickens on admittedly a busy Friday night - well the owner should have helped out. The owner's frosty nature was more aligned to a hard-nosed, unpleasant, bitter bull. The food was absolutely tasteless compared to a quality Italian restaurant. No thought, passion or care had been given to any of the sauces to our dishes - very un-Italian. My Linguini Di Mare tasted as if it had come out of a tin and would have tasted better if it had come from 'Iceland'. My wife's risotto was full of starch and collapsed to an overdrowned pool of bedded rice that resembled a dumplin in a soup: the lamb was overcooked (not chargrilled) and as tender as concrete. As for the Halibut it contained moist flakes at one end while dried out at the other with a hazelnut white sauce that reminded of a paste when tiling your bathroom. At least the poor standards were consistently maintained with the dessert - the waffle probably came from a packet with an ill-proportioned drizzle of a caramelised tasteless sauce. Then to add to our final pleasure, when eventually receiving our bill, it was decided to add VAT to the bill (as opposed to what was listed on the menu) - didn't realise we were in the USA! Even then calculations for the bill were inaccurate. If you want bad italian food, poor value and shameful service, then visit this restaurant. The owner should visit the Fiume Italian bar and restaurant in Wolverhampton and learn what proper Italian food, hospitality and service should look like!

Lovely food a usual never disapoints

First time visiting, we were greeted by friendly staff who were very attentive but not in an uncomfortable way. Food was delicious and the portions were very generous. Will definitely be going back.

Anna and her team were excellent, as usual the first was first rate. We highly recommend Cafe Cassita

Nice choices, enjoyed the mushroom starter and the main (calzone) was okay. Very busy restaurant so they are obviously doing good stuff.

Best Italian restaurant anywhere 😋

A lovely evening with friends. Enjoying fabulous food and great service. Many thanks to all at Cafe Casitas. See you again. 😘

We dined here for my Husband’s Birthday, it’s a beautiful place great atmosphere, food was excellent homemade, served hot we will return soon.

Great Service, lovely food and friendly staff xx

I was there yesterday with my fiancé, it's a great place, we recommend it to everyone, delicious food, great service and atmosphere. Thank you 😘🤗😘

Great - they made a horrific mistake with our meal which I won't go into detail, but left me feeling like giving a one star. On the other hand, they swiftly corrected this without a fuss. Great.

Top notch as always, food, staff and the surroundings. One of our favourite places.

Group of 6 attended, Steaks were good but Italian dishes not meeting expected standards. Service was quite slow.

Fabulous place , staff is very helpful and polite, food is amazing , very nice atmosphere, highly recommended 👍

Great meal, brilliant service and reasonably priced too. £7 for a cocktail, what a leaky little place. Thanks Casita, we will be back soon

Friendly staff, good food, lovely atmosphere. We thoroughly enjoyed our celebration evening. We will be back.

This place is adorable, I can’t believe I haven’t been before. It feels like stepping back 20 years, down an old cobbled alleyway in Italy, it doesn’t feel like Gornal! Slight mix up with our booking, although we had confirmation via email and the booking app, the staff assured us we hadn’t, even after showing them the email etc, so it was a disappointing start and then no one came to serve us for 20 mins. HOWEVER, the service got a lot better. All staff were helpful but we did have to call people over, I think where we sat, couldn’t be seen by staff. Every dish was clearly made fresh and there was no rush between courses. Full of flavour and nicely presented. I love the authenticity, it just lacked the going out feel for a Saturday night. This may have been due to our booking being overlooked, so tucked into a last space. I would go back, as I think it deserves another chance, I just don’t think we got you all in your glory! It’s clearly a well loved restaurant.

Spare of the moment thing..... Me and the Mrs where stuck for a place to go, friday night and it was about 8pm when we finally decided to eat out someplace!! but where?? we had called a few places and they couldn't fit us in due to time kitchen was closing! Called Cafe Casita and they had no problem seating us for an evening of delight. ill begin with the service, felt like part of the family from the moment we stepped through the door, the people make you feel like your eating in their own dining room, service was quick food came out fresh and hot we had starters the Mrs had Salmone Affumicato amazing!! I hade Muscles in a garlic butter sauce also out of this world, for mains i had the sirloin steak with the Barolo wine & bacon sauce, she had Spaghetti Polpette we were both gob smacked on how amazing this food was. For pudding i had Connoli and she had Tiramisu and one of the best sicillian wines i have ever had the pleasure of drinking. to say the least i will be back as often as i can. 5* review isnt nearly enough for our experience here. Thank you

I had a great time here, enjoyed all of our food and was served promptly and precisely. Excellent portions excellent quality.

Plenty of parking, food was very nice, staff pleasant. I would recommend this restaurant

Wonderful food and atmosphere but drinks a bit expensive

Great food as usual. Just had a 30 minute wait for our order to be taken. Or would have been 5 stars.

Ordered two pizza, pasta and garlic bread for takeout, the pizza was horrible, soggy cold in the centre not nice for the price I paid. The garlic bread had no cheese, the pasta was very strangle it was like rice the taste was ok Was looking forward to an Italian pizza, best off going to Pizza Hut Paid £40 in total

First time eating here after saying for several years that we should try. How dissapointed I am that it took me this long! The menu had not one thing that me and my partner would not want to try, the staff were attentive and very polite and the food was unreal. Very authentic and a gem on our doorstep.

I have been here many times, however my last visit was not so good ,the waitress was very charming polite and worked extremely hard nothing was to much The food was not ,we ordered bread and olives the bread was burnt on out side frozen on inside ,the garlic bread was just warm didn't have any cheese on ,my food was hot on out side and slightly warm in middle, that tells me the food is not fresh as I expected it to be ,not sure if its different chef if this was my first visit I wouldn't be going again.

Lovely food, very hot. No air con on there.

Lovely, local and authentic Italian! The restaurant has a very comfortable, homely feel about it, and the staff add to that sentiment. Great range of dishes available which, of what we had, was delicious. The only negative I could mention is that the music was just a little too loud.

Excellent , great atmosphere and fantastic food. I can't believe this has been on my doorstep and I've only just discovered it. We'll be back again and again.

Really pleased with the service here. The decor is quaint and eclectic-the food was tasty and good value for money.

Had a lovely meal here with my family for my 60th birthday. Everyone had clean plates.

So dissatisfied with the standard of food. The 'Pollo Valdostana' was an instant disappointment, for the most part it was a plate of plain, pale burger van style fries, the breaded chicken was dry, overcooked, burned in places and essentially reminiscent of a chicken nugget. What a waste of money, at £15.95 I couldn't recommend unfortunately.

Delicious! The food was amazing, really good portions - especially the starters. There was a young waitress working here who was really good, Iazmina. She was really polite and efficient Would recommend and return Edit - returned, food was still amazing however service was slow. We had an older lady looking after us, mains took 40 mins from starter, not asked if we wanted more drinks.

Great restaurant, was a very lively atmosphere. The staff were attentive and friendly, the food was excellent. Would definately recommend 👌

We have visited Cafe Casita multiple times in the last couple of years for intimate family meals and larger celebration events. Every time the service is flawless! Our server is always polite and knowledgable on the menu. Food is always delicious, hot and pretty fast being served. The restaurant has a great authentic Italian feel, is always well presented and clean. Highly recommend!

Well what can we say about Cafe Casita, first of all the atmosphere, decor and staff are beyond anyone's expectations. It's a lovely authentic restaurant, especially at Christmas where they go above and beyond a bit of tinsel! Staff are really polite, very on the ball and quick to take orders etc. The food is delicious, absolutely delicious and the best Italian we've had. Mario and Anna are lovely hosts, if you get a chance to visit, you won't be disappointed.

Best food in whole of birmingham my favourite restaurant, I visit it every 2 weeks and never fails to impress us with its delicious tasty food. It’s Hank and Anna

Great tasting food. Service was friendly and attentive. Atmosphere was warm and cosy. I will definitely be going to cafe casita again.

Found the staff friendly and attentive. Service was excellent. Food was good but a found it a bit pricey for what we had. Overall an excellent venue and a great night . Would definitely recommend.

What a great place and busy for a Thursday. O and the food was superb 👌 😋 👏

Very little effort put into the dishes served ,the risotto was heavy the side salad lacked any freshness and the service except for the young waitress who took our order,left a lot to be desired,quite rude actually,won’t be recommending

First time tonight dining here and wasn't disappointed,very friendly staff and professional, place is fantastic inside very clean and cosy,food was fantastic , very well presented home cooked Italian food,will definitely be visiting in near future.

Beautiful food and cosy atmosphere, i will return. My kids loved the food too. Xx

Food is fantastic, some of the staff were a bit abrupt, lovely atmosphere, but very expensive

Food was just above average. It's hard to say as we only have dined there twice. Carbonara needs more flavor. Focaccia is dry. Pork belly is delicious and yes just average. The staff are a little miserable but hey what can you say? Long days. Drinks were limited too Price was ok but hey not bad

Food excellent, service not so good,.

Very nice authentic italian look and feel inside. Lovely food but not the best lasagne I have had. That title still goes to wildwood in Stratford. Will definitely return and try other dishes as the food being served looked gorgeous.

Food was amazing my wife and I both had Risotto: vegetarian and Sicilian sausage....fantastic

Outstanding service and the food yumyum ever time flavour and taste 😋 👌 5x ratings not anuff

Food wasn’t bad but the price is extortionate given location + what you get. My prawn pasta had 4 prawns in. Service was good. Pizza oven wasn’t working which was a let down. Probably won’t return

Disappointed in this particular visit. Exceptionally busy but the food was cold. However they were very apologetic and it was rectified very quickly.

Lovely meal; tasty food and attentive staff.

Lovely romantic restaurant, food is exceptional service is really good and a lovely atmosphere

The food is amazing and would highly recommend. I ordered the linguine ai funghi which tasted so good and fresh. I ordered through Uber eats but it was efficient service from both the restaurant and the driver, with my food actually arriving hot for a change. Would love to try dining in next time.

Fantastic food service and atmosphere

Great place for authentic Italian cuisine, staff very friendly and helpful, good choice on the menu and nice quality wine. Thank you for a lovely evening.