Based on 75 opinions finded in 1 websites
Based on 75 opinions finded in 1 websites
Nº 77 in 276 in East Lothian
Opinions
For a place that is slightly more expensive than others, I found food a little disappointing. The wood pigeon was extremely salty, the recipe didn’t pair the flavours well enough and it really didn’t work together. I also got the Sunday roast and the Yorkshire pudding must have been sitting too long in the oven because it was crispy. Beef was good but it had a strange aftertaste. Broccoli was bland and literally just boiled and carrots were burned. Also for a place of this type, I was surprised that when I requested still water which for restaurants always means bottled water, I received tap water. Additionally the water wasn’t poured for us. Also we were missing a menu in one of the menu holders. The service wasn’t very good despite the place being almost empty. For a place that looks really really cool, the restaurant would really do with improving their quality, both food and service wise.
Dinah Kolka . 2024-10-01
MORE AT Google
Such a great spot for lunch. Friendly staff, great food, lovely vibe.
Colin Ramsay . 2024-06-22
MORE AT Google
We went for dinner (not staying at the hotel) with family and had a wonderful time! The staff was lovely and nice and the food absolutely delicious in a nice atmosphere. Will definitely go back again!
Morgan Huvé . 2024-05-17
MORE AT Google
Interesting 'little' bistro primarily servicing hotel guests, but open to non-residents. I took my 80YO mother-in-law who had lived within 10 miles for most of her life, and she'd never been before ! OpenTable said no availability, so called them directly. They had no problem accommodating us and explained how they handle reservations. If they have a large occupancy of hotel guests, they limit non-resident reservations for the Bistro, to ensure they have tables available for their guests, especially as they can't just walk outside and choose somewhere else. The menu is simple, not extensive, but enough to satisfy most appetites. We found the food to be a solid 7/8 out of 10 and the service was very professional and friendly. Prices are commensurate with the quality of service/product and based on our experience, we will definitely return in the future.
Steven Smith . 2024-03-17
MORE AT Google
I booked a surprise lunch on-line for my partner’s birthday. We wanted to walk from Musselburgh but drive back and management were very obliging in allowing me to park the car there overnight in advance. The service from Judith was warm, friendly and attentive without being over-bearing. The utterly delicious food was served efficiently and stunningly presented. My partner, who’s more of a ‘foody’ than me, believes it’s bad form to photograph a plate of food. But even she felt a need to record the effort and care apparent in the presentations We were told most of the chefs have been there since pre-pandemic and it’s a happy team. It shows in the provision of such exceptional quality. The vanilla and maple syrup cheesecake was, in particular, a delight. Somehow the flavours matched the presentation (last photo). There was also a relaxed ambience in the busy bistro with lovely views to the wooded grounds. I was always going to provide 5-stars to all concerned for a wonderful meal and such good value but the waiving of my dessert by dint of it being my partner’s birthday made a lovely experience even better. My own birthday isn’t so far away and then we can return. Wonderful!
Stephen Wilson . 2024-03-08
MORE AT Google
Went For Lunch & Cocktails Great Food & Service & Friendy Staff.
Francis Sweeney . 2024-02-09
MORE AT Google
Wonderful tasty food. Service was second to none - Peter and his colleagues were top class professionals, friendly, polite and without doubt a key part of the relaxed ambience here. We had dishes from the lunch menu, and aside of there being plenty of lovely food, was also excellent value. If you've not been here, booking a table is recommended! The whole experience was so enjoyable, and despite us living in Glasgow, we intend to visit again. Well done to all the staff.
Ian Strachan . 2023-09-20
MORE AT Google
First visit, good choice of food, well presented and tasty.
Stuart McNeill . 2023-07-18
MORE AT Google
My husband and I are staying at the Carberry Tower Mansion. We had dinner at The Campaign Room. I had spinach gnocchi and he had lamb. We both had orange cheesecake for dessert. Our dinner was delicious.
Hether Belusky . 2023-05-29
MORE AT Google
Incredible home-made food and excellent service here at Carberry Tower. Prices are totally reasonable. Highly recommend!
Moritz Happerger . 2023-05-08
MORE AT Google
We were there recently for my husbands 80th birthday. The food and service were first class. The staff were very friendly.
Jean Smith . 2023-01-14
MORE AT Google
A great find that’s hidden away. I’ve been coming here. For at least 5 years, although the last 2 (2020 & 2021) I haven’t been in, obvious reason … Covid-19. Always friendly staff and the food is consistently good. Those in the know will know how good the food is here. The grounds are alway pleasant for a wander around.
Owin Thomas . 2022-05-17
MORE AT Google
This meal was the best I've had in a long time and I LOVE food. I ordered the grilled vegetable platter and my husband had the Vegan kofta. Both were AMAZING and bursting with flavour. The presentation wasn't just artful, it also contributed to the layering of flavour (so very important in vegetarian cooking). Our servers, Peter and Jess, were both friendly and professional. I found the decor interesting and comfortable. Another reviewer mentioned the paper menus... Which I think are a mark of COVID safe times as well as a fresh and changing menu. I can't wait to go back again! PS The coffee is fab!
Kaila Pettigrove . 2021-07-19
MORE AT Google
Service was good. Food was v good. We have tried fried halloumi cheese and blue cheese salad as a starter and burger as main. The place is clean. The only thing in the room bistro is that the place is not very well decorated. You feel it is like a just hall, there is no theme or atmosphere. Menu is just a paper.
Kareem Shaker . 2020-11-20
MORE AT Google
Here to celebrate our anniversary, staff were so welcoming, food delicious, beautiful surroundings, very relaxing, highly recommend.
Catherine Parker . 2020-08-28
MORE AT Google
Great meal. Very accommodating and friendly staff.
Kris Martin . 2020-08-06
MORE AT Google
Lovely afternoon lunch. Give it a try you won't be disappointed.
Laurence Calder . 2020-03-10
MORE AT Google
Enjoyed lunch in nice surroundings
Dawn Williams . 2020-03-02
MORE AT Google
Cracking meal and really nice beers. We had an itison voucher so not sure how much a meal would be as they seem to have a menu that they give to voucher customers as the only prices shown on that are any supplements there would be. Lovely setting too.
Jock Walker (Jock) . 2020-02-24
MORE AT Google
Lovely surroundings. Food very well presented and delicious.
David Waddell . 2020-02-24
MORE AT Google
Great breakfast in a beautiful building and surroundings
Finlay McLean . 2020-02-23
MORE AT Google
Beautiful surroundings, mediocre meal and service.
S&D R . 2020-02-23
MORE AT Google
lovely bistro and meal was good although couldn't understand why add £3 extra for a beefburger!!
maria preston . 2020-02-17
MORE AT Google
I really like it here. The staff seem very friendly and helpful and the setting is just lovely. My only criticism is I always feel cold!
Louise Young . 2020-02-08
MORE AT Google
The food and service very good no complaints
Nancy French . 2020-01-21
MORE AT Google
Lovely venue, the food was lovely
Jackie Hanna . 2020-01-07
MORE AT Google
My grandaughters took me for lunch, the staff were amazing, my great granddaughter was very sick, and the lady couldn't do enough for us. She helped clean it up, sorry we left a mess. Toilets were spotless. Would definitely go back again, and recommend to my friends.
Margaret Lawson . 2019-11-13
MORE AT Google
Superb food and deserts. 100% recomended
Vidmantas Zukevicius . 2019-09-28
MORE AT Google
Steak night from Groupon . Beautifully cooked and warm welcoming staff
Wesley Balloch . 2019-08-26
MORE AT Google
Great old building. Fantastic history. Nice friendly staff.
Thomas Kenny . 2019-08-22
MORE AT Google
We were there for the Steak Night . Amazing food sided and sauce all included in the price. Great friendly service as always.
Jacqueline Cymber . 2019-07-20
MORE AT Google
Lovely place and food and service very good
Colin Whiteford . 2019-07-15
MORE AT Google
Food was excellent had lamb. beautifully presented did have to wait an awfully long time for service with everything! which was otherwise Avery pleasant experience staff pleasant and courteous there was a wedding on which probably accounts for delays will be back and will recommend but please consider waiting times even for drinks
Fiona Robb . 2019-06-12
MORE AT Google
Nice selection of food for lunch
Kim Clark . 2019-03-29
MORE AT Google
Absolute stunning venue, we really enjoyed out meal and it was fairly priced. We enjoyed a walk around the house after our meal. Cozy bar area within the house, we love the place.
Phil Cass . 2019-03-15
MORE AT Google
Good food but need to watch description of deserts
Eddie Nolan . 2019-02-24
MORE AT Google
The atmosphere and good were lovely but be aware of the menu and ask about ingredients especially in the puddings.
Hazel Nolan . 2019-02-24
MORE AT Google
Went for brunch and don't think we'll be going back. It's a stunning location and the lady at front of house was really friendly and professional, but there were more negatives than positives I'm afraid. We were left waiting ages to be seated with no sign of anyone. My husband actually had to go back to reception, where he was told we could sit anywhere. While he was gone, I was ignored by the waitress who had turned up with food for the one other table there, so we did indeed try and sit anywhere... only to be ushered away by the waitress who finally acknowledged our presence, telling us all except three small tables were booked (nobody came to sit at ANY of those tables the whole time we were there.) The decor is interesting, in keeping with the building, and great if you like skulls and antlers. However, it is in need of a good dusting and the walls are actually filthy in places. There was food spattered on the wall by our table. We both ordered lattes and the full scottish breakfast. The lattes were very nice, and certain elements of the breakfast were too, in particular the sausage and perfectly poached eggs. Unfortunately the one slice each of bacon was overcooked and leathery, the tomato was mushy and tasteless, the mushroom was swimming in liquid and the promised stornoway black pudding was absent altogether, having been substituted for haggis without anyone mentioning it to us. All in all we were really disappointed; the quality of food and the service did not live up to either the price, its reputation or the stunning location.
Lorna H . 2019-02-10
MORE AT Google
First visit for a venue that is very local. Good staff, great food, lovely venue. Booking recommended at weekends. Great place for a treat. We wandered round the building, looks lovely....
Grand MoFF . 2019-01-10
MORE AT Google
Amazing service and staff are very welcoming and friendly
Alex Rae . 2018-09-01
MORE AT Google
Beautiful hidden gem of a place situated in parkland close to Musselburgh. Friendly staff, food was good quality and the portions were generous. Great place for a quiet Sunday afternoon.
Nicholas Couts . 2018-02-20
MORE AT Google
Great lunch. Treat yourself for Christmas!
Alistair Mackay . 2017-12-06
MORE AT Google
These schedules may not be completely accurate on special days. Please always confirm with the restaurant
Similary restaurants in Edinburgh and Lothian
377 Opinions
Can't say enough good things about this hotel. Room was nigh on spotless and very fresh looking so I'm guessing was refurbed quite recently - I hadn't looked at photos before booking so I was pleasantly surprised by how nice it was. The bed was really comfy and the shower was great. The temperature of the was perfect too despite it being a cold night. I didn't have dinner but the cooked breakfast was really good and the portions were generous. I couldn't think of a way to improve it. The man with grey hair I spoke to on the phone and on reception was very pleasant. I don't know if he's the owner or a member of staff, but if he's staff then the owners should know how good he is. Location is good as is only a 5 minute walk from the train station, has a car park and is right on a main road so easy to find (but not noisy). Price was reasonable, too. All in all, 10/10.
933 Opinions
231 Opinions
£6.80 for a salad box is outrageous! I don’t pay that in the city centre. Had to double check it was Prestonpans I was in…
11 Opinions
top gluten-free muffins, the butter icing is to die for, banoffi and also lavender were amazing, will definately be back. Sandwiches had fresh gf bread and were very tasty.[buffet-you did sat]