GastroRanking-logo
whatsappWhatsapp
phoneCalldesktopWebsite
menuMenu
bookingBooking
4.6

Based on 442 opinions finded in 1 websites

site_photo4

Nº 92 in 672 in Rotherham

CUSTOMERS TALK ABOUT DISHES WITH..steakbeautifulcookedpie
Score
OpinionsNoteGoogle4424.6

comment_iconOpinions

Lovely little pub, very homely and welcoming. The pies are homemade and are out of this world. The bar area is also dog friendly with water bowls, treats and cushions available, and the staff were very nice with our Lab.

site_logo

Kirsty Boam . 2024-11-05

MORE AT Google

Myself and 2 members of my family visited for a meal on 23rd October. Our first visit everything was excellent. Would definitely recommend a visit and will be eating here again.

site_logo

Gill Wood . 2024-10-24

MORE AT Google

Excellent food and service. Highly recommended.

site_logo

Craig Dyson . 2024-08-31

MORE AT Google

Just had a lovely pie for tea at the Bay Horse. The steak & stilton pie was gorgeous and handmade chips were awesome. Great friendly service with nice chatty locals. Definitely worth a visit!!!!

site_logo

Helen Timms . 2024-08-22

MORE AT Google

Great pint , very nice food and outdoor seating area, will definitely visit again!

site_logo

ROBERT ARMITAGE . 2024-08-20

MORE AT Google

Good food. beer and service. Better to book as seem to turn people away if getting near end of service.

site_logo

Keith Ellis . 2024-08-16

MORE AT Google

Excellent friendly pub with first class home cooked food. Good selection of beers too

site_logo

Michael Bryden . 2024-08-16

MORE AT Google

Would definitely recommend good food good atmosphere. 👍

site_logo

Bryan Fisher . 2024-08-11

MORE AT Google

Like going back 100 years I love it

site_logo

elliot mcmanus . 2024-08-09

MORE AT Google

The landlord told me they served the best pie in the world, I was sceptical. Now, I haven’t tried all the pies in the world but they do in deed serve the best vegetable pie I’ve ever tasted. It’s been over 2 weeks now and I still can’t stop thinking about how good it was.

site_logo

Paul Ramsden . 2024-08-09

MORE AT Google

Really, really disappointing. Booked two weeks ago, asked all the relevant questions, received what turned out to be false promises as answers. Staff couldn't apologise enough but I guess one to put down to experience which was a shame as all in our party were really looking forward to our visit.

site_logo

Honest Daz . 2024-07-25

MORE AT Google

Lovely county pub food drinks and service excellent

site_logo

Christene Guest . 2024-06-29

MORE AT Google

Really nice pub, plenty of parking and a nice beer garden for those warmer days. The pub itself is clean with plenty of seating. The staff are really friendly. The menu has a good selection. It's all homemade which is fantastic - the cheesecake is particularly delicious. It is a reasonable price as well for the quality of food. Definitely recommend it

site_logo

Louise Green . 2024-06-17

MORE AT Google

Stopped off for a drink while out walking. Didn't order food but what I saw come out looked amazing so might visit again one evening. A nice place in a beautiful village that is worth a visit.

site_logo

Martyn Etches . 2024-06-16

MORE AT Google

I've been going to this beautiful off the beaten track country pub for about a year now.. I've since introduced numerous family and friends and we all love it... I braved the jamming night on a Wednesday alone and was made to feel one of the crowd instantly, so grab your musical instruments and head on down for about 8pm...I don't play so I sing along .I've also joined Rotherham motor club as they have their meetings there on Thursday nights too. The pub has lots of history to it, Andy the landlord told us all about it one day whilst waiting for our meals..the main bar area's 250 years old and was a part of the Wentworth estate many moons ago..very old rural quaint pub with open fires when cold, a large beer garden with plenty of tables overlooking Wentworth rolling fields…and big car park, leave to the right-hand at rear car park if driving ( mirror on wall across rd to help with blind bend ) way safer than leaving to the lefthand side when sat in car park. What keeps pulling me back is the smashing friendly staff and the home made food, the pies are the best in the world Andy says! I'm not a chip fan but I have a slight obsession with Jeans chunky home made chips..at a guess I'd say triple cooked chips.. I'd be happy with a big fat chip butty me haha..We've tried numerous things on the menu and our favourites are the Tikka naan sandwich with the best chips I've ever had!....and my new love is the Halloumi burger with salad,chips,salad and sweet chilli. The fish and chips and steaks are on my list of favourites too! All the food has been consistently good and red-hot when delivered, waiting time is swift too. They make a small range of home made puddings too which are freshly made daily! You don't have to book, but I always do now to save a wasted journey, as many times it's been full of well fed happy customers. I've seen people walk in before and question why they're saying they're fully booked when the tables may seem empty, obviously some people don't understand what table reservation means.... just because it maybe empty as you walk in....odds on the people who have booked will be walking in very soon, they'd hardly give a table up to have to move you mid meal..... some people's black and white thought process always bewilders me . What I really like about this pub is that dogs are allowed in the other side away from the dining area, I've noticed it's a regular stop off point for ramblers and the pub provides shoe covers for the sludgy days. There's no steps to climb and have a large disabled toilet to the left hand side of the bar...I'll be attending the "Bayfest" live event this year as last year sounded great fun. Lovely place, all the staff are very friendly ...and the chefs are real chefs...not microwave warmer upperers like most places now!.. prices are reasonable, portions are....well I'm still stuffed at 7.30pm and we was booked in at noon haha. Always happy when visiting this establishment.

site_logo

jay Barber . 2024-05-07

MORE AT Google

Great food , lovely pub and friendly staff

site_logo

Brian Allott . 2024-05-03

MORE AT Google

Food is out of this world! Such a lovely village pub with friendly and welcoming staff. Our fave place on a Friday night 😊 P.s the best homemade steak pies ever!!!

site_logo

Emma Oliver . 2024-04-26

MORE AT Google

Lovely staff and very good food that is well priced.

site_logo

Clive Shackleton . 2024-04-21

MORE AT Google

Top quality home made food. Cosy and nicely decorated pub serving pub classics done very, very well. I love this place!

site_logo

Mark Armitage . 2024-04-16

MORE AT Google

Great pies and superb service from staff.

site_logo

Adam Warburton . 2024-04-15

MORE AT Google

Fantastic food and lovely staff 😀

site_logo

Nigel B . 2024-04-13

MORE AT Google

Gorgeous little village pub, pays to book to be on the safe side as its very popular but we were early so there was plenty of room for us. Been here a couple of times now and have never been disappointed with the food. Everything is homemade including the desserts. This time both my parter and I had the steak pie with veg and chips. The pie is always full of filling and the pastry is lovely, with a jug of gravy on the side. The staff are lovely and told us about their takeaway cheesecakes when we said how full we were. Would be rude not to so we took a slice of rocky road cheesecake home and wow! Just as amazing as the meals. Definitely one of our favourite local places to eat. Update - been back again and tried the Pie of the Week, which was minted lamb and potato. It was delicious, well worth a try. We were too full for dessert again but took home a bit of mint choc chip cheesecake, which also did not disappoint! Also brought friends who also can't wait to go back to try more on the menu.

site_logo

Jo MacGregor . 2024-04-07

MORE AT Google

Everything I want from a country pub. We went here for my brother's anniversary and preordered food. All the food was served promptly and was homemade and absolutely delicious. The homemade pies were a particular highlight. Service was friendly and helpful and the interior was cosy and inviting. An almost perfect pub. The only thing I would like to see is a small selection of craft beer on tap for example but other than that a stand-out pub. Highly recommended.

site_logo

J D . 2024-03-28

MORE AT Google

Beautiful home cooked food, excellent homemade desserts

site_logo

Janiece Duroe . 2024-03-20

MORE AT Google

Brilliant meal 🥘 I’m gluten free they couldn’t do more for me. Made steak pie for me had with mash n veg all fresh . Can’t wait to go again. Man who served us very friendly and quick service.

site_logo

Sandy Johnson . 2024-03-18

MORE AT Google

First visit but will definitely return.

site_logo

Malcolm Ellson . 2024-03-18

MORE AT Google

Food is always amazing. Portions are a bit too big for me but I'm sure other people love that. Cozy pub, and the bar staff are lovely. Very friendly, helpful and polite

site_logo

Natalie Wilkinson . 2024-03-10

MORE AT Google

Had a party of 35 people for a special birthday celebration and nothing was too much trouble it ran like clockwork . Everyone enjoyed it , amazing place, incredible food , lovely staff, chilled atmosphere thank you 😊 one of our favourites definitely 😀

site_logo

Donna Ellis . 2024-03-03

MORE AT Google

Managed to get a table at short notice on Sunday for 12. The food was amazing. Great quality and large portion sizes. 100 percent will be back

site_logo

amber kamara . 2024-02-12

MORE AT Google

Home made pies are fabulous, lovely place & staff too

site_logo

Wendy Ashton . 2024-02-09

MORE AT Google

Foods is fantastic. Brilliant staff Can't fault anything,highly recommended

site_logo

julie hewitt . 2024-01-24

MORE AT Google

Lovely place to eat some good food. The service was fast and very friendly.... although it was not busy...due to it being a Monday evening. Would definitely recommend you give it a visit.

site_logo

kathryn Baxby . 2024-01-24

MORE AT Google

Excellent meals served hot and fresh great friendly staff we will definitely be back

site_logo

Helen Bradwell . 2024-01-22

MORE AT Google

Oh my goodness! The meal was pretty amazing today, thanks to the staff for putting 100% into our meal today, we will definitely be back, it's our new favourite-cooked to perfection 👌

site_logo

lynn colley . 2024-01-20

MORE AT Google

Great homemade pie meal, nice surroundings top notch!

site_logo

Chris Phelan . 2024-01-16

MORE AT Google

Nice pub.great staff.not had food here yet.but saw the meals come from their kitchen and it looked great.so will be going back soon.

site_logo

Mike Wright . 2024-01-12

MORE AT Google

Food was good but it was disappointing that there were only a couple of craft beers on sale. The Landlord never moved away from his laptop and never engaged with his clientele.

site_logo

Jeff Roden . 2024-01-06

MORE AT Google

Thoroughly enjoyed the visit. The food was good and the atmosphere pleasant.

site_logo

Janet Hallatt . 2023-12-25

MORE AT Google

Went for pre Christmas treat with family. Seven of us and no issues. Chose the non Christmas menu and all meals were fantastic as well as desserts. Staff very helpful and friendly. Prices also good and meal sizes were generous. All members of family planning to revisit already

site_logo

Ivan Routledge . 2023-12-23

MORE AT Google

Been In for a pie and brew of ale 🍺 apparently been before so the father in law says ...can't remember as years ago however this is a little gem of the place. Nice beer, nice steak and Stilton pie 🥧

site_logo

Matthew Thorpe . 2023-12-21

MORE AT Google

Food is amazing. Always good service and friendly atmosphere.

site_logo

Rachel Smith . 2023-12-19

MORE AT Google

Had a lovely christmas lunch this week. Everything was cooked lovely and served piping hot. Nothing too much trouble. Been several times and never been disappointed.

site_logo

Janet Martin . 2023-12-15

MORE AT Google

Nice welcoming dog friendly pub with four real ales available. The one I had was on good form.

site_logo

Glyn Spencer . 2023-12-10

MORE AT Google

Great food friendly staff, there lasagne is the best for miles, All home made

site_logo

Antony Hodges . 2023-11-23

MORE AT Google

Booked for Sunday lunch. Parking nightmare as limited. Staff polite and atmosphere good. Food , Mt husband enjoyed his but I wasn't as keen. We both had Sunday lunch. I also had cheesecake which wasn't nice or set. Overall for the price we have enjoyed better but I suppose made a change. I wouldn't be in rush to go back thoe.

site_logo

Sherri . 2023-11-22

MORE AT Google

Had a lovely meal here, nice atmosphere, food really nice, plus dog friendly. Thank you x

site_logo

Joanne Gilbank . 2023-11-22

MORE AT Google

Lovely quiet homely atmosphere and all food home made! I have a potato allergy and they were so accommodating ensuring nothing was contaminated. Been a few times and will be returning again.

site_logo

Keeley Pritchard . 2023-11-19

MORE AT Google

The food was exceptional, the service was outstanding and the atmosphere was more than welcoming. Value and quality for the price.

site_logo

liam chesman . 2023-11-18

MORE AT Google

Would be 5 and 5 for food but no vegan options

site_logo

James Heeley . 2023-11-18

MORE AT Google

Called in at 4 o clock on Saturday and was told they couldn’t even do a burger and chips as they were fully booked yet most tables inside were empty very disappointing

site_logo

Darren G . 2023-10-12

MORE AT Google

A great pub with friendly staff quality refreshments and great food

site_logo

David Price . 2023-10-03

MORE AT Google

Had an absolutely fantastic experience here. Lovely place, well priced, brilliant staff and incredible food. Will definitely be back soon.

site_logo

Richard Hall . 2023-09-30

MORE AT Google

Fantastic food, brilliant service. Well done to jess doing the job of 10 men 👏 lovely lass . A credit to the bay horse.

site_logo

Emma Beardsley . 2023-09-26

MORE AT Google

We've been a couple of times for a meal and the food was excellent as was the service. I decided to book for a family Sunday lunch recently and we couldn't have been happier. Everything cooked to perfection and plenty of it too. You'd be hard pressed to find a better place to enjoy a meal and drink locally. A big thank you to all at The Bay Horse for all you do.

site_logo

Colin Lindley . 2023-09-24

MORE AT Google

This is the best home cooked pub food, every meal is delicious and cooked to perfection. The triple cooked chips are just the best and every dish is plentiful. Would recommend it to anyone.

site_logo

debbie Robinson . 2023-09-12

MORE AT Google

Had a lovely pie here. Service was good and the prices very reasonable. Will definitely come back.

site_logo

Amil Patel . 2023-08-31

MORE AT Google

Lovely place to eat. The meals are very nice staff are friendly 👌

site_logo

Shaun Sears . 2023-08-27

MORE AT Google

Brilliant pub great service great atmosphere and excellent food with plenty of choice. Great value for money large portions, highly recommend the steak

site_logo

Terry Buxton . 2023-08-20

MORE AT Google

A girls catch up. Lovely friendly staff and the pies were amazing. Also a great choice of real ale. Couldn’t ask for better

site_logo

Jayne Booth . 2023-08-04

MORE AT Google

Went in for a couple of drinks. Comfortable with the feeling of a traditional pub with a modern decor

site_logo

Joanne Crooks . 2023-07-27

MORE AT Google

Exception food and service There was a large group of 14 of us, mid week Most of us had steak pie or steak and Stilton pie. The chips are the best I’ve had in a long time. We will definitely be going back!!

site_logo

Danielle Taylor . 2023-07-08

MORE AT Google

Very welcoming and friendly with great selection of food and beer's 🌝

site_logo

Philip Brown . 2023-07-06

MORE AT Google

This place serves AMAZING food. All home-made and delicious. The cauliflower cheese is to die for, one of the best I've eaten. (My Fav food) Desserts melted in your mouth. Highly recommended. I wish I'd taken a photo but couldn't wait to tuck in 😄 service with a friendly smile and great banter. Went with big group of friends (netball team) and everyone raved about their food. Thank you 👏👏

site_logo

Diane Taylor . 2023-07-05

MORE AT Google

Arrived early 12.15 started filling up quickly would recommend booking in advance, when I asked what's the pies like the bartender replied "best pies in the world" now a pretty bold statement I must admit it was absolutely amazing really enjoyed it probably best pub food you can get. Also had the chicken strips they was very tasty tasted homemade pretty sure everything on menu is. Really nice atmosphere and layout scenery inside an out beautiful so lucky to be close by will be coming back here... ALOT! Thank you

site_logo

Dan Barnett . 2023-07-02

MORE AT Google

Just been for a lovely meal with the family to celebrate my wife's birthday. Not been for a long time but was greatly impressed with what we had. We ordered our drinks first and then sat down to choose from the menu, the days specials board was also presented. We ordered 2 pies, 2 hunters chicken and a chicken curry. Everything arrived piping hot, tasted beautiful and everyone really enjoyed what they ordered. Hats off to the landlord as he was run off his feet with staff shortages and holiday cover but the staff that were there, did a grand Job. Only 3 of us managed a pudding which was 2 sticky toffee pudding with custard and a cheesecake with cream. Very well presented and tasted delicious , just as the main meals did. ,Plenty of craft beer, lager & wine to choose from with friendly staff to see to your needs. A nice big car park with outside seating and plenty of more seats at the far end of the car park. Well worth a visit, will definitely call again.

site_logo

Pete Shaw . 2023-06-29

MORE AT Google

Lovely old pub with beautiful views. Staff were lovely. I had fish and chips which I couldn't eat. It was completely saturated with crease. Chips were almost black and soggy. My family had the pie which they said was lovely. No problem, I wasn't charged for fish and chips. Such a shame as dessert was lovely. Cooking fish is an art. Nice crispy batter and golden chips but not in this case.

site_logo

Patricia Reade . 2023-06-09

MORE AT Google

Fabulous home cooked food at reasonable prices. Pies and cheesecakes to die for!

site_logo

Jane Hore . 2023-06-09

MORE AT Google

Very nice place, pleasant staff and the food is very tasty

site_logo

Pauline Cartlidge . 2023-06-06

MORE AT Google

Food was good but the service was poor. We had ordered before another couple but they got their food before us. I had to go in and ask where the food was and they hadn't completed our order. Nobody had bothered to come and tell us. It was not like it was busy for them to forget us. There were also two gardeners strimming around the beer garden and their language was not the most pleasant. Won't be heading back anytime soon.

site_logo

Guy Walters . 2023-05-27

MORE AT Google

A hidden gem, in a lovely village. Great pub, with very friendly and welcoming staff. Fantastic home cooked food. Can highly recommend the Steak & Stilton pie from the specials menu. This is a must go to place….

site_logo

Martin B . 2023-05-20

MORE AT Google

Out walking with a friend and called in for tea and cake. The barman was very nice and chatty. Friendly atmosphere and the cheesecake was delicious .

site_logo

lyn Butler . 2023-05-09

MORE AT Google

Lovely homecooked sunday dinner. Everything home cooked and very generous portiins. Cant fault it. Staff lovely the pub is very welcoming and clean.

site_logo

Vicky Wild . 2023-05-07

MORE AT Google

Fantastic Sunday roast and excellent service. Highly recommended.

site_logo

simon mayes . 2023-05-07

MORE AT Google

Went for a family dinner and it was amazing. Food was all homemade and definitely better than average. The drinks were also great. Had asked for a gin and tonic to find they had 14 different gins available and a great selection of tonic waters. Highly recommend this place.

site_logo

Michele Sam . 2023-05-03

MORE AT Google

Nice food atmosphere qish they did mix grill 😋

site_logo

Pacmac Kent . 2023-05-02

MORE AT Google

Nice little pub but way overpriced drinks. Food bog standard pub menu no light choices / sandwiches or wraps for lunch only main meals.

site_logo

G A . 2023-04-27

MORE AT Google

Service great, food delicious. The pie was positively perfect. Chips weren' t quite as crisp as I like but that's personal pref. Pudding amazing. Thank you!

site_logo

lindsey cooper . 2023-04-23

MORE AT Google

Dog friendly and lovely food. Thanks x

site_logo

Rosie Chitty . 2023-04-14

MORE AT Google

Arrived here with family for some pub food, only to be told quite rudely after ordering drinks that food was unavailable because they were too busy. It was 2pm on a Friday afternoon and there were only 3 other tables with people in and those tables had all got food, there was no indication that food was unavailable when we arrived. We asked if there was anywhere else to go nearby to which he told us the closest pub but said that the food at this other pub wasn’t as good as theirs. Such a strange thing to say to customers you are unable to serve. Would not come back here again or recommend that others go either.

site_logo

Molly Coombes . 2023-04-14

MORE AT Google

Me and my friend took our mums for Mother's Day yesterday. The food was delicious, piping hot, cooked to perfection and great portions. All the staff were really friendly. I am going again for my birthday. Wish I'd taken pictures of the Sunday lunch to show how good it was.

site_logo

Fiona Michelle Howse Newby . 2023-03-20

MORE AT Google

The food was excellent: home made, tasty with generous portions. The beer's good and the staff are friendly, helpful and efficient.

site_logo

David Braithwaite . 2023-03-17

MORE AT Google

Good pint of Farmers blonde. Toilets immaculate - would highly recommend

site_logo

Roger Harrison . 2023-03-06

MORE AT Google

Fantastic food, fantastic hosts, fantastic atmosphere, what more do you need!

site_logo

Michelle Slater . 2023-03-01

MORE AT Google

Been 3 times now and never had a bad meal there

site_logo

Yvonne Barnett . 2023-02-03

MORE AT Google

As always really good food and great service

site_logo

Sonja Hurt . 2023-02-02

MORE AT Google

Good home cooked food and so welcoming owners and staff bonus 🐕 friendly 😀

site_logo

Ian Pepper . 2023-01-25

MORE AT Google

Great food - sizeable portions - good price

site_logo

Dave Smith . 2023-01-24

MORE AT Google

Great food really enjoy the relaxing atmosphere

site_logo

Chris M . 2023-01-12

MORE AT Google

Always good food good atmosphere friendly staff. Quiiz nights are great.

site_logo

Kathryn Ward . 2023-01-05

MORE AT Google

Had a great meal here in April , friendly staff ,good service ,lovely food, good portions 2022 coming back up north in 2023 and will definitely stop here for a meal

site_logo

Karen Layton . 2023-01-01

MORE AT Google

First time visiting the Bay Horse, we thoroughly enjoyed our dinner and will definitely return 😀

site_logo

Toni Hughes . 2022-12-30

MORE AT Google

Great food. I’d advise pre booking a table though.

site_logo

Stephen Garrett . 2022-12-26

MORE AT Google

Fantastic little pub. Staff are brilliant and the food is top notch. A little off the beaten track but well worth making the effort. We will be back again soon.

site_logo

James Cutts . 2022-12-26

MORE AT Google

Delicious home cooked food and a good price . Varied menu and good quality produce. Probably the best pub meal we had . Faultless. Pub inside is very clean and warm welcoming place. Dogs welcome with their own area which is equally warm and comfortable. Will definitely be back and if you ha ent tried it we reccomed it . Nice drive too from Sheffield and surrounding areas.

site_logo

Richard Smithson . 2022-12-20

MORE AT Google

Excellent Christmas lunch with all the trimmings. Quality ingredients, superbly cooked and exceptional value for cost.

site_logo

Lynne Brown . 2022-12-18

MORE AT Google

Friendly and welcoming , good service , lovely food

site_logo

Lisa Foster . 2022-12-15

MORE AT Google

If you’re looking for a good, reliable pub with hearty warm meals and a space for muddy paws, look no further. You and your pooch are in for a treat! Every time I’ve been here I’ve never been disappointed. My favourites are the pies and Sunday dinners. The staff are so accommodating to dogs as well - there’s more than enough treats for them too!

site_logo

Ashlea Jeffries . 2022-12-06

MORE AT Google

Relaxing and amazing food. Very comfortable experience

site_logo

Barry James . 2022-12-03

MORE AT Google

Fishcakes were lovely. Friendly accommodating staff that moved us from a high table to a lower one due to one of us struggling with mobility. Biggest handcut chips I've ever seen!! Highly recommended.

site_logo

Eve Harrington . 2022-11-29

MORE AT Google

Jean and her staff are superb, the food is excellent especially Jeans’ cheesecake

site_logo

Bryan Linfoot . 2022-11-23

MORE AT Google

Similary restaurants in Yorkshire and The Humber

restaurant_img
4.6

2894 Opinions

location-iconHellaby Ln, Ravenfield, Bramley, Rotherham S66 8QD, United Kingdom
outdoor_seating_348285takeaway_348285delivery_348285

Always a decent place to stop ! Great carvery

restaurant_img
4.6

139 Opinions

location-icon61 Great Park Rd, Rotherham, S61 3PN, United Kingdom
outdoor_seating_374134takeaway_374134delivery_374134

Excellent service,good pint,pool, snooker,darts,sky tv

restaurant_img
4.6

211 Opinions

location-iconGreasbrough Rd, Parkgate, Rotherham S62 6HG, United Kingdom
outdoor_seating_374638takeaway_374638delivery_374638

very friendly atmosphere staff very polite

restaurant_img
4.6

61 Opinions

location-icon60 Wales Road Kiveton Park
British
outdoor_seating_71782takeaway_71782delivery_71782

Great little cafe friendly and great food

restaurant_img
4.6

1384 Opinions

location-icon284 Bawtry Road
Italian
outdoor_seating_239440takeaway_239440delivery_239440

Being the last to finish at 930pm we were asked to wait in the entrance hall because they wanted to clear and close even though the place doesn't officially close until 11p.