Rudy's Pizza Napoletana - Sheffield in Sheffield - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

If you do great pizza that's all you need to do & these guys do it fantastically & the service was excellent.

Highly recommend, Will definitely be back again soonservice Friendly staff Marvellous pizza .🍕

Great atmosphere, super attending staff members, great selection of drinks, authentic stone oven-baked pizza, overall Fab experience

Great pizza and efficient/ friendly staff. I had the portobello as a white pizza, which was great, as was the three dips we tried.

Sometimes I get awkward when eating in restaurants alone but I never felt that at all as the waitresses were so sweet to me and welcoming. They were helpful about the dishes with my allergies and made sure that I had everything I needed :)

great pizzas and the best staff! Work next door and always enjoy getting pizza from here :)

Luke was our server and they were lovely and very attentive. All other staff we interacted with were equally courteous and warm. The food is incredible with good mix of toppings and choice, and very good value. The decor and atmosphere is great and will definitely come back/recommend.

Great service, good selection of drinks and great pizzas.

Amazing pizza and we were seated quickly.

We had a delicious Cinghiale pizza and rocket and Parmesan side salad. The service was very friendly and helpful and the decor was brilliant, there were even cushions to keep us comfortable!

The best staff ever!! The food is always impeccable and is now our go to for a Sheffield City dinner. Hamish and Harvey are so friendly and super attentive. We ended up chatting to them throughout our meal

Very nice staff, and the pizza is perfect

Best thin crust handmade pizza with affordable rate

First time I've been, excellent quality pizza. The food came incredibly fast. Definitely recommend.

First sent us pizzas with no cheese, then sent replacements with loads of cheese and next to no sauce?? Ordered dozens of pizzas from Rudy’s over the years, multiple branches. Never had a single issue, then get 2 bad orders in a row, same night… On top of that the woman was passive-aggressive and rude to me the second time I called to raise it with them?? Strange. Picture of my sauceless pizza (which she was adamant did have sauce). Like they literally only sell one thing - pizza. You’d think they’d be able to get it right!

Really good pizza served with a smile in record time. Great atmosphere.

Best Pizza in Sheffield , great staff

We booked a table for 9 people on a Monday evening. The pizza was great, however, less than one hour 15 mins, we were told that we had 15 mis left to leave as they had the table was booked, for another large booking. If we had been told this at the time of booking we would have chosen another venue. Really disappointed. S it was our anniversary and we wanted to spend a bit more time with our family. Won't be returning anytime soon. As my granddaughter was hoping for desert. Poor customer service.

Lovely place..made a special memory

Great pizza and good value. Recommend booking as it was busy!

Very good pizza. Lovely staff and nice atmosphere 👌

I have been here twice so far, both times with friends/family. The pizza tastes amazing and is really fresh. Lots of choices for food and drinks here. One of my friends keeps wanting to meet up just to come here again :D It's a 15 second walk from Creams Café too. You can stop there for an amazing dessert afterwards.

I found the experience lacking. The pizza was decent but nothing special, service was pretty slow from being sat to ordering etc. Generally the staff were pretty friendly and nice but unfortunately will not be rushing to go back.

I found the experience lacking. The pizza was decent but nothing special, service was pretty slow from being sat to ordering etc. Generally the staff were pretty friendly and nice but unfortunately will not be rushing to go back.

Very friendly staff, the pizza's were extremely good!

We came here twice during a 4 day stay, says a lot about how good they are! Very busy but the quality of food and service isn’t impacted by that.. everyone working there is so cheerful and kind. We tried the garlic bread (amazing and it’s an entire pizza) and the buffalo margarita both were amazing. W we’re always to full to get to desserts 😅 We loved their peach and tangerine syrup drink!

Fantastic pizza (I had Marinara with artichokes as extra). Nice surroundings. Great atmosphere. Quite reasonable prices to boot.

The best pizza in Sheffield also I would like to thank the staff especially luke who helped me today after I was taken ill. I'm on the mend and will be back soon.

Thank you... over the top and above, the pizza and staff. Very friendly atmosphere and our favourite pizza in town.

Great pizza joint in central Sheffield.

Beautiful food and excellent value for money. Speedy service - was great for a work lunch without a booking. Such friendly staff - why have I never been before? I'll be back!

Pizza was great, staff were friendly. Ordered a cocktail here too and it was good

Amazing food, amazing service, great atmosphere and reasonably priced. Highly recommend!

One of those annoyingly loud clattery industrial styled reataurants BUT cheap ish cheerful good service quick service AND the BEST pizzas in town. I literally cannot wait to go back or get delivery. They are incredible.

Lovely atmosphere and amazing pizzas

Always excellent - but why did you get rid of the porchetta pizza! Best one on the menu by far.

Sarah is such a diamond. She has been smiling and had an amazing vibe throughout our whole meal.

Delicious pizza and fantastic service from Aidan and the team. We'll definitely be coming again!

Amazing pizza and service! We went for a birthday and from the moment we arrived, we were really looked after. Our server was called Will who was amazing! Very friendly, helpful and hospitable. Their pizzas are the best and highly recommend. We went on a Tuesday night and booked just in case, glad we did as it was really busy. Thank you and thanks again Will! We will be back!!

Always a great evening our favorite place to go

Our experience was fantastic. The staff were delightful, and the pizzas and garlic bread were exceptional. They feature monthly specials, and this month's special pizzas were bursting with flavor. Despite visiting on a busy day, the seating was comfortable. Unfortunately, there weren’t many vegetarian and vegan options and the restroom was unacceptably dirty and unusable, which were the only significant drawbacks.

Had a great time meeting two friends for a lunch date. Pizza was perfect.. lovely base and topping. Would definitely recommend and would visit again

Great tasting fresh pizzas for a really reasonable price !

Delicious pizzas,one of the best I have had.

Two mins from City Hall, soooooo good.

Fantastic food, service and restaurant. One of the nicest pizzas I've ever had 5*

By far the best pizza. Great food, reasonable prices, quick service. Well worth a visit if you haven’t already.

Such a brilliant place and all the staff were exceptional - in particular Kim who took brilliant care of us for my Grandpa’s birthday dinner. Everyone enjoyed their food and drinks (Hugo was lush) and Kim made a lovely fuss of my grandpa and made sure the cake was perfect when it came out.

Great 2 Pizzas here on Sunday afternoon.

First visit, I’m hooked, lovely pizza! Nice beer! Great service and atmosphere!

Busy Sunday night but food came quick. It was so delicious! Will come again :)

We visited on a Saturday lunch time, it was quiet when we arrived, but got busier. The staff were all friendly and looked after us. The pizzas were very tasty, I enjoyed one of the monthly specials, but was allowed to change some of the toppings on it to what I wanted. Would visit again definitely.

Excellent and speedy service and pizza was great.

First time visited as we don't live in Sheffield but would certainly visit again and recommend it to anyone who likes pizza.... Mentioned to my son we'd been there and he says he loves it there..... Georgia was our server and she was excellent, so friendly and welcoming.

Great pizza!! And the stuff 🍕👍👌

Went in on a Saturday night and it was busy busy busy! We had booked which I would recommend based on our visit this weekend. We had a fabulous time, the staff are lovely and we're working so hard. The food was delicious and came quickly and the base was so light. We were full but not uncomfortable. I liked the blackboard on the wall with a small explanation about the Neopolitan style pizzas, that was a nice touch! There are other authentic pizza places nearby but I believe this one to be the best.

Only five of our six drinks arrived. The sixth had to be ordered again. The server said that toppings can’t be substituted so a pizza ordered without prosciutto couldn’t have a different topping added instead. When the orders came the person bringing it explained how the kitchen had taken account of our shellfish allergy, avoiding cross contamination but it still had the prosciutto on it and he was explaining to the wrong member of the group. When we did all eventually get food there were no napkins….then no cutlery. The lady bringing the napkins didn’t check and had to go back for the cutlery. All a bit not on the ball and out of touch. The pizzas were good with an authentic Italian flavour and feel. It is a very lively and clearly popular place full up and buzzing: so I suspect most of the folk there will not notice what one of the staff described as their “communication problem”. There are two other really authentic pizza outlets in the Broomhill district nearby that we will continue to use, this one probably not.

Food was as always really nice and arrived at the table very quickly before our drinks had which didn’t bother us. We’d arrived around 5-10 minutes before our booking and were able to be seated straight away which was great and the atmosphere in the restaurant was very nice. As we were coming toward the end of eating it felt as though a couple of staff members were hovering over our table, we are fast eaters and this was probably only 10 minutes after the food had arrived at the table. As soon as my partners fork hit the plate staff came and took our plates and we were asked if we wanted any drinks or desert. We declined this as we were still not half way through our first drinks as these had arrived after the meal. Moments after this the same staff remember returned and asked if we wanted the bill which was brought moments later and paid but we were told to take our time and there was no rush. A couple of minutes after this another staff member came and informed us that they needed the table in 10 minutes, I still had quite a bit of my drink left at this point which I quickly finished and we left. This was at around 8.45 and only half an hour since our booking time had started, we were in the restaurant for around 40 minutes total and after our meal really felt like we had been ushered out of the door as quickly as possible which really added a down note to what was a very nice meal. It made us feel like we had had more of a fast food service then a sit down meal. We were very surprised to being asked to leave at 8.45 when our booking had been for 8.15. Especially when there were other groups in the restaurant who had been there before we arrived and left after us. We are big fans or Rudys and it felt a shame not to have a great experience on this evening as we were celebrating an event.

Lovely place with very well priced pizzas. I only walked past for a take out. Next time, I will eat in as the atmosphere was great. Well worth a try.

There was a great atmosphere. it was a busy Saturday night but the service was still quick and friendly. we didn't feel rushed, and we weren't kept waiting. the spritz were really great. Harvey served us and he was a gem

Best pizza in Sheffield with fantastic staff

Excellent pizza, top quality ingredients and produce Fast, efficient and friendly service Could not recommend it more

Confidently the best pizza I’ve ever had. First time in Sheffield and was told about the Tuna pizza, was a bit confused at first but if you like tuna then I’d 100% recommend and get the chilli honey. Insane. Daisy was a sweetheart as well very good worker and extremely hospitable and genuine. She’s doing very well. Next time in Sheffield I’ll definitely go back. Very fairly priced too.

Good atmosphere Pizzas Good size topping are amazing Friendly staff

Excellent pizza. Best since I was in Sorrento last Summer. Will be back!

Great 2 Pizzas here on Sunday afternoon. Did not have a booking, but shown to a nice table by great staff, who explained the menu really well (being in Italian). Both Pizzas were extremely well cooked, and really, really tasty. Really enjoyed them, large and really juicy, super dough. Will return 100%

Called in for lunch yesterday. The best pizza we've ever had! Staff are lovely. Highly recommended you try this place!

I visited Rudy's Pizzeria in Sheffield for a special occasion, and while the pizzas and drinks were enjoyable, my experience was marred by some disappointments. Despite calling hours in advance to request a specific table, which was confirmed and noted in my booking, upon arrival, we were informed that someone else was already seated there and the lady knew this herself as she told me, so she was aware we wanted to sit there! This lack of attention to detail and failure to honor a simple request was frustrating. Additionally, the restaurant was nearly empty on a Monday evening, yet we were seated uncomfortably close to other diners, diminishing the intimate atmosphere we had hoped for. After working in a restaurant myself anybody would know to place even a simple piece of paper saying reserved. It's disheartening when basic requests are overlooked and when seating arrangements are mismanaged. On the positive side, the margarita pizzas were deliciously large, and both the wine and mocktail we ordered were satisfying (even though they came to us after our pizzas, again when the place is empty). However, the overall experience was tainted by these shortcomings in service and seating.

The service is fantastic here, all the staff are so welcoming and attentive. The pizzas are so so good! It has a great atmosphere this place. Definitely recommend. Well done Rudys 🙌🏻

Always top quality pizza at a good price.

What can I say! Perfect pizza and perfect service! We shall be back.

The food was very nice, the service are fantastic

Were in Sheffield for a gig and wasn't sure where to eat. Initially was going to go to Bungalow and Bears but after going in we were told they were closed, spotted Rudy's so thought we'd give it a try. Service was great, staff were efficient and friendly. Pizzas were pretty good too, decent size and a generous amount of toppings; only minor complaint was that the dough in the middle was slightly soggy, but they still tasted nice. The Rudy's lemonade was also a welcome change to the usual soft drink offerings and was really refreshing.

Server was lovely food was amazing just love this place so much

The pizza was so delicious that even the base by itself I would consider buying 10 of and eating as a whole meal, the base really really shone through for me deliciously chewy and the right floppy texture with char marks that weren’t just aesthetic

Best pizza restaurant in Sheffield without question!!

Great pizza for a good price. If you see lloking good and authentic neapolitan pizza, this is the right place. Service is good as well. However, they get quite busy sometimes.

Had seen good reviews of this place so decided to try it for ourselves. Extensive menu so was spoilt for choice. Opted for the Carni Pizza. Service was quite fast. Pizzas are huge. Just the right amount of toppings too. You can watch your food being prepared and cooked. Always a bonus. Staff were really friendly too. Was our first visit but won't be out last.

Just tried to book a table for 3. Answering machine suggested that the best way was to use the automated service. Duly complied and received confirmation with reference number. Rang to check they could accommodate our turnaround time for a city hall show later on and was advised that my booking did not show and that staff could not access the booking via the reference number. What is going on???

This is a fantastic place to meet up and feast, drink and soak up the awesome atmosphere and tunes. I highly recommend. The food is fresh, authentic and utterly superb. Make a bee line for it. The service is friendly, helpful and very welcoming. It is one of the iconic places to visit on the eclectic Division St, make it a must visit.

Love these pizzas, fresh, tasty and always good service

Go to spot for pizza! I always get Margherita + Garlic Aioli + Salted Chips. Can’t go wrong with this place! Such a cozy environment and prices are great as a student. Food is so yummy and filling. Easily accessible on foot/bus.

Aiden was absolutely fantastic. Possibly the best service I've ever received in a restaurant! Thankyou for a lovely evening! 😊😊

Really excellent pizza, I had the margherita with boar salami, my partner had the vegan lamb. Best pizza I have had in Sheffield! At very reasonable prices. Great attentive service from Kim. Will be back for sure!

Incredible evening, we popped in and were accomodated even though we hadn't booked and it was busy! The servers immediately asked about allergens and brought over their allergen information- an immediate win for a nut allergy sufferer! The food was beautiful. Simple fare with no fuss or frills but honestly the best pizza bases, so fresh light and tasty. Server's continually asked if we needed anything and made the whole experience brilliant. Talked with the team behind the service counter who were so helpful and friendly- this place was absolutely buzzing on a Friday evening and has made our night. Thank you!!

Had an amazing lunch here! Our server, Luke, was very attentive and friendly. Food came quickly and was delicious (very big pizzas as well!). Lovely atmosphere too!

The staff were some of the best I’ve seen in a while and the food and atmosphere were great, and very good value.

Great pizza - we had a Margherita and carni and loved it

This restaurant was so noisy that we could not hold a conversation. Despite our requests for the excessively loud volume of background music to be turned down, this was refused and we were advised to move to a quieter table, which was just as bad. In the end we gave up and went to dine at a nearby restaurant where the staff were happy to turn down the background music and we enjoyed both food and conversation.

Best pizza in a restaurant ever

Highly recommended if you fancy Neapolitan pizzas. The taste is amazingly good! With a thin crust and puffs around the sides, it's my favorite style! The atmosphere is warm and nice.

Extremely Rude waitresses. Pizza that tastes slightly better than Aldi pizza but you pay 10 pound instead of 1 pound for it. Dont trust the other reviews its employees that rate themselves. Avoid At All Costs. Utter waste of money.. with bitter and unpleasent attitude from waiters.

Pizzas are very good, large and tasty. You can easily change the recipe if you want. The staff is really nice. Just a little bit noisy, but the setting is cool !

A lovely experience at Rudys with a friend. Great pizza, good quality ingredients, friendly staff and a warm atmosphere. If drinking, you must try the Sospiri Spritz. Can’t wait to return again, whether it be in Sheffield or another one of their locations.

amazing food, really good service. best pizzas in the UK.

Vickys service was the best,.we had ana amazing time

I went on my own was sat down and then completely ignored for ten minutes no eye contact or any interest in me sitting there. Staff just going around without notice. I left I got the impression I was not the right demographic. So RUDE 😔

Pizza really good and nice atmosphere inside - service a little disjointed and they forgot our dips. (Visited December 2023)

Incredibly good food. Staff are absolutely top drawer. Perfect place for any occasion!

I was disappointed that the only meat toppings were pork based, however, I opted for the plant based lamb and various other toppings. It was the best pizza by far that I have had. The staff are friendly and efficient.