Paesani in Sheffield

Real good, genuinely authentic Italian pizza. Staff were great and super accommodating. 100% recommend.

Paesani is unmatched for pizza in Sheffield! Not only is it top quality, their customer service is next to none. I accidentally (auto pilot brain) ordered a non-veggie pizza and they replaced it FOC. Absolute gem of a business. They also deliver to Two Sheds so it doesn’t get much better than that.

Went last night, food & service 5* and very reasonable prices

Excellent pizza and friendly service!

Yesterday afternoon at the end of school my daughter and I visited Paesani. We ordered a pizza each, which we were supposed to take home for our tea but on the way from the pizzeria to home we had already eaten half of it. We couldn't resist. My daughter says it's the best pizza and at least once a week asks me to order it. We cannot do without Paesani, not only for the pizza but also for the staff who are very friendly and satisfy us in everything we ask for. We can't wait to return next week.

I recommend it, tasty and nicely presented. Nice service.

The service was impeccable. I recommend this place for a nice evening with friends.

Absolutely brilliant lovely little restaurant nice and cosy, taken my family for my sons birthday and the food and drinks were excellent , very friendly staff and a nice big pizza oven you can see your food been cooked , will be coming back, thank you for lovely night

I will definitely return to eat at this restaurant. Everything was delicious...

Perfect for birthdays. They made my friend feel special with a celebratory song and personalized service.

Fantastic pizzas! Amazing taste served in a small, friendly restaurant. The pizzas are all fantastic. Amazing taste and the crust is superb. Would definitely recommend the dips too. Highly recommend for a good pizza in Sheffield

We booked the table a months in advance for 7pm for 5 people to get there and be told to wait outside for 15 minutes in the cold and wet. While we was trying to sort out with the women our booking the door had to remain open due to lack of space leaving other customers to become angry with us before we had even sat down making us feel uncomfortable. When we finally got in to sit down the women then asked us if it was 4 people and I confirmed the booking on my phone and said it was for 5 this lead to her sticking a chair onto the end of the table in a small restaurant that hardly has no room to begin with. This is when my friends who’s birthday it was got up and decided to go and look for somewhere elsewhere to eat as the service was not up to scratch. This is clearly an overbooked restaurant and the staff clearly don’t seem to care about people waiting around for them. I won’t be returning and will advise other people not to either.

courier can't use a map! food great though

The first time I've actually eaten in, only ever got takeaway. The pizza tasted even better with it being served straight from the oven. The service was great and I was amazed by the amount of delivery drivers that turned up in the time I was there. It definitely shows how much people love Paesani, and so they should!

Possibly the best pizza I've ever eaten, please do not go so that there is more room for me.

The best original Italian Pizza in Sheffield. Small Italian pizzeria making pizzas in a wood fire oven. Shame that I can give only 5*. Highly recommend!!

One of the staff is very rude.

The pizza itself was absolutely lovely and you could tell all the ingredients are freshly sourced, there is a wide range of toppings and something to suit every customer. Unfortunately we had to wait half a hour outside until our table was ready, when finally seated and the food came out, one of my friends pizza was forgotten about so everyone had finished their meals by the time it came out. The meal itself was great and the drinks menu had a great variety it was just a great shame about the missing pizza and long wait times. Hopefully if we come back again this won’t be an issue.

Amazing pizzas, with incredibly fresh toppings on delicious base. Highly recommend.

Top Pizza, the 3 chefs are the best pizza chefs in town and the service is amazing. There is not better pizza option in town

The BEST pizza in Sheffield hands down! We have been going to Paesani for over three years and it's consistently the best pizza you can get in Sheffield with very reasonable prices. It's a lovely restaurant and their takeaway service is great too. Couldn't be better!

As an Italian student in Sheffield for the past three years, Paesani Pizzeria has truly become my home away from home. Their pizzas are authentic and consistently top-quality, made with fresh, premium ingredients that remind me of Italy. The fritto misto is always a hit, perfect for sharing with friends or family. I also can’t recommend the desserts enough—they’re absolutely delicious, and the Aperol Spritz is always spot on. The staff are friendly and welcoming, and the prices are very reasonable for the quality. Whether I’m enjoying a cozy dinner with my girlfriend or bringing family along, Paesani offers the perfect atmosphere. They’re always on time with deliveries, and the experience never fails to impress. For anyone in Sheffield looking for a genuine Italian dining experience, Paesani is a must!

As the Italian Society at the University of Sheffield, we can confidently say that Paesani Pizzeria is our go-to spot for authentic Italian cuisine in the city. The pizzas are made the traditional way, with top-quality ingredients that truly capture the essence of Italy. From the soft crust to the rich, flavorful toppings, every bite feels like a taste of home. But it’s not just about the pizzas—there’s a fantastic variety of other dishes to enjoy, all full of flavor. Their desserts are a must-try, and the Aperol Spritz is always spot on. The cozy atmosphere, combined with the warm, welcoming staff, makes every visit feel like a true Italian experience. For anyone craving a genuine Italian meal, Paesani is highly recommended!

Really great food. Could be cooked a little crisper but absolutely spectacular.

My takeaway pizza of choice. Tasty every time!

My favourite pizza in sheffield. I’ve never eaten in, only ever had a takeaway but it’s seriously delicious. Every single time!

Incredible delicious pizza. Wonderful friendly staff. I'm so happy these guys are here. I'm also very impressed how they alway ensure my daughters Pizza (who has a severe milk allergy) has never had any cross contamination issues. 5 plus stars!

Always incredible food, service and atmosphere. Always accommodating of preferences and requests. Delicious and fresh ingredients every single time. authentic Italian-style pizza. We are repeat customers and have never been disappointed. Highly recommend.

I had CARNI pizza last night and that was the worst pizza I have ever had. A piece of burnt bread and some ingredients with the worst smell on. A kind of herb that was absolutely awful. You could test the best pizzas in Hut and Dominos instead.

Removed some stars after being charged 10% extra in a takeaway today without notice. Usually eat in and have never had 10% added before. Really puts me off a place. Great food again on Monday (as always). Squeezed us in as a group of four before a booking and served us great pizza efficiently and we never felt rushed at all. Hopefully back again this afternoon!

food was cold. we watched the driver go to the other side of sheffield before coming to our address

It was perfect. Please give me more

Been here a few times, mostly takeaway but sat in for the first time recently. Always incredible pizza and lovely service, very polite and have no faults with any part of visiting here. Will be back many times in the future. Torta Della Nonna is incredible and would highly recommend it.

Forget dominos and pizza hut pesani makes the best pizza in Sheffield the staff are polite and friendly fast service and I will be visiting again 👌👌👌

It’s got it all , no idea why anyone would visit a franchise when this feels and tastes authentic 👌

Love this place, the pizza is epic, the staff are so polite and friendly, prices are great!

Nice but cold pizza on arrival, slightly disappointing for the price

Great pizzas - had both takeaway and in the restaurant. One of the best pizza places in Sheffield.

Lovely vegan pizza options . I’m assured the non vegan pizza was also delicious ! Great atmosphere and very friendly service .

Amazing pizza and friendly staff. Make sure you book!

Really nice service here. The staff are friendly and welcoming. The diavolo pizza is incredible. It's definitely my go to order here and the menu is reasonably priced. Highly recommend.

Great pizza. I really enjoyed the food, and the service was great.

The pizza was top draw. The best I've had in some time. An item was missing but quickly refunded. Definitely ordering again.

Tasty pizza with fresh ingredients. Torta della Nonna was delicious. Friendly delivery person

We absolutely loved the food. Piping hot and delicious. We must have hit peak busy time as it took an hour and 40 minutes to arrive which was the only down side. Great food.

Nicest vegan cheese I’ve ever had on pizza. Came here once over a year ago and finally went back this weekend to see if it was as good as I remember..and it was. The service was quick and the atmosphere is really nice, cute little restaurant. I would say it’d be nice if there was garlic/chilli oil on the tables/menu as there usually is in pizza places.

Best Pizza in Sheffield for takeaway/delivery or in modest internal restaurant area (hence best to book as usually packed) Can be a squeeze and noisy, but all adds to the authentic Italian atmosphere and the Pizza's really are excellent.

Amazing pizza. Atmosphere was a bit noisy for me, but I got take away anyway.

Fantastic atmosphere! Some of the best pizza I've ever had which is saying a lot... because I've had a lot of pizza. It's got a real family business vibe to it with the pizza making on display

Great pizza and a good wine list make Paesani a good choice when you're craving pizza The restaurant was busy with a good atmosphere and everyone enjoyed themselves. This would have been a 5⭐ review but there were one or two disappointing things: The Antipasti salads just weren't great - neither the Burrata or Caprese had basil with them, the Olive Oil didn't make an appearance and the tomatoes were neither rainbow nor sliced. They were in fact very cold cherry tomatoes that set your teeth on edge. The service was slow and disjointed with the food, especially the pizzas, seeming to arrive quite randomly. We were a party of 3 and after waiting quite a while the antipasti salads appeared just two or 3 minutes before two of the pizzas while the other pizza came more than 5 minutes later. Overall Paesani is a good local restaurant that serves great pizzas but seems to be a victim of it's own success. Take away orders were constantly going out of the door which was probably why the pizzas for diners didn't arrive when they probably should have.

My pal Josh just ordered this for dinner and OMG! As far as I can remember this is the best most authentic pizza I’ve ever had. Literally the opposite of big chain pizza. This is authentic, adventurous, steeped in culture and unbelievably tasty. Giaconto I salute you 🇮🇹

The food was amazing, cooked to perfection with fresh tasting ingredients, the tiramisu was especially delicious, I definitely recommend ordering from here

This place must be one of the best places to get pizza in Sheffield.

The pizza here is truly amazing! I thoroughly enjoyed every slice and found the prices to be very reasonable. Highly recommend to anyone looking for delicious pizza at a great value. 💕

Food arrived on time, but the pizza looked like it had been dropped, as most if not all the filling was in the box, and not on my pizza. Not impressed as first time order, although what was there was rally nice.

A wonderful place with very friendly staff who are always accommodating. Great options including options for vegan and gluten free friends.

Great pizza and service 🍕 the mozzarella is so fresh!!! we are keen to find the best pizza place in every city we visit, and we may just found the one for Sheffield …

This place just gets better in terms of flavour and the selection of pizzas are for everyone. Even the chips are delicious. It's friendly and the ambience is good. Service it's fast despite being super busy.

Lovely restaurant, quiet on a weeknight

9 of us for dinner a variety of pizzas all very good, pleasant staff good service.

Great food and service at a good price.

Lovely relaxed atmosphere, superb and large pizzas. Loved the authentic feel

Just amazing. Best pizzas ever.

Amazing pizzas Sheffield's best Limoncello spritz

Small pizzeria with Amazing food. Always go back.

Amazing food and service :) thank you

Delicious pizza, lovely atmosphere and great service!

Delivery Driver forgot one part of the order but the restaurant noticed and drove it themselves to my address. Really nice and friendly plus the food was great!

I had Diavola pizza and it was delicious! This is what real pizza taste like;) Friendly staff, highly recommend!

Ordered 30 for a naming ceremony/birthday. Went down a storm. Can't praise them enough. Just superb. Everyone super impressed. Best best best pizza place around. Thankyou. Really helped make it a great day

Order was wrong, food was cold. Almost impossible to understand how to add extras to pizzas in meal deal

My new favourite pizza place! Tasty base, tasty toppings, tasty olive oil, tasty cocktails. Just all round good! - update: still amazing

Wow a delightful pizza for a change a breath of fresh air to get quality pizza around broomhill/crooked area keep up the good work

Amongst the best pizza in sheffield for sure. Always lovely service here too!

Simply excellent pizza. Probably the best I've had in any Sheffield pizzeria. Good service and drinks selection.

I ordered two pizzas, mixed fry and chips. Very good pizzas with traditional flavors. I don't recommend mixed fried food, it's definitely the frozen one, it mainly tastes like oil. Overall not bad, certainly better than Dominos...

Very disappointed. Have been wanting to try a pizza from here for ages heard very good reviews about it. We had one last night and the dought was very tough and chewy. Even the pizza cutter wouldn't go through it. The cheesy garlic bread was the same and the cheese was only in the middle and not up to the edges. Might have been a one off due to being busy and popular. I might try again in the future. And hope it's better than what we received last night.

Great ambiance, ideal for either couples or a family. Pizzas are probably the best in Sheffield. Shared a starter which was a burrito I think, it was simply sublime. Nothing to dislike.

Best pizza we've had in a long time. Really glad we finally made it here, never managed to get a table before.

The best pizza in all of South Yorkshire. The guys go above and beyond every time. It would be my death row meal for sure. Taken family here from Manchester and they are just wanting to come back for the pizza alone.

My new favourite restaurant in Sheffield, its like a real slice of Italy at home

We’ve had takeaways from here a few times. The food is always delicious and the staff are lovely. Be prepared to wait they get very busy and work very hard. Watching them work while you wait is mesmerising. Highly recommend ❤️

Best pizza in Sheffield! Really recommend it for a sit in meal, great vibes and genuinely lovely staff. Definitely leave some room for desert as well - we got tiramisu and pistachio ice cream and it blew us away. Can’t wait to come back!

Absolutely lovely! Very friendly waitress, who had a very impressive memory! All of our orders were exactly correct, and they were happy with us mixing and matching pizza toppings! Extremely delicious pizzas that were beautifully presented! Amazingly fast service - we received our pizzas after only about ten minutes for a party of five! (Although the restaurant was basically empty) The decor inside is also beautiful!

Very friendly staff and good pizza.

By far the best pizza you can eat in all of Sheffield, I am pretty sure we tried them a(the traditional ones). We are an Italian family that has been living in the city for three years, and the pizza we can enjoy at Paesani is the absolute best, superb! If you're looking for a traditional pizza and an exquisitely Italian culinary experience in Sheffield, there's no better place than this. Not to mention the staff, kind, welcoming, and smiling."

Great pizza 10/10 am definitely eating here again

Always love the pizza here. There are other good pizza places but this is the best in Sheffield (imo)..... Keeps getting better. Excellent balance between Neapolitan and more well cooked varieties. Puddings also improved a lot.

Just lovely 🍕 Marge was lovely so was the meaty fella

Food was delicious, the staff were lovely and engaging. Made it lovely experience for myself and my little one when we visited.

Always a fantastic pizza at Paesani! A firm favourite and one of (if not THE) best pizza establishments in Sheffield. Well priced, quick service, very friendly and a great spot in Crookes. Starters are lovely too but beware the pizzas are very big so make sure you save some space! They do a pizza sandwich which is nice if you pop in for lunch or don’t quite have the appetite for a full pizza. Also do takeaways, why not pop into one of the local independent beer houses and have a quick one whilst you’re waiting! Overall a brilliant choice… you won’t regret your decision!

Really nice authentic pizza. Fairly small place but good is good and reasonably priced

Went in for a takeaway and wished we rather sat in. Lovely staff and cozy ambience. Lovely restaurant with a good selection of the most UNIQUE pizzas you will find in Sheffield. The quality is outstanding for the price.

beautiful authentic italian style wood-fired pizza. by a long shot one of the best in Sheffield however loses two stars when the menu says coke £3 and what arrives is a 330ml can

Exceptional staff and food. The owner is especially kind and chatty. Will definitely come again!

Delicious food made with passion. Not much space inside, I recommend booking in advance

Siamo stati ieri per la 1 volta con mia figlia, che abita qui a Sceffild.e sono rimasta molto sorpresa non mi sarei mai aspettato di mangiare una pizza Margherita molto buona con una base sottile ma più croccante rispetto alla classica pizza Napoletana ,faccio i complimenti al proprietario una persona gentile e simpatica eal suo staff.

Ate here last week, we had Mortadella and burrata, capricciosa and a margarita pizzas, they were delicious and cooked to perfection. Service was efficient and friendly. Will definitely eat here again.

We've had pizza from Paesani a few times and are never disappointed. So tasty and service is very quick. Would highly recommend 👌 🍕

Bought a pizza from the place, it was total burnt one of the worst pizza I have ever had in my life wish I can share the terrible picture of it in front me.