GastroRanking-logo
whatsappWhatsapp
phoneCall
desktopWebsite
menuMenu
bookingBooking
3.5

Based on 860 opinions finded in 2 websites

site_photo3

Nº 81 in 95 in Orkney Islands

Nº 28 of 34 British in Orkney Islands

CUSTOMERS TALK ABOUT DISHES WITH..salmoncheesefishscallopslambroastoldpiechickencrabpuddingpastasaladsoupsteakcooked

comment_iconOpinions

I ate at the restaurant on 2 separate nights, on both nights my main meal was not good. The others present had very good meals however the food that I received was very substandard. The first occasion I had chicken stuffed with haggis, the chicken was dry and over cooked. On the second occasion I had Pasta Carbonara, the pasta was dry, overcooked and inedible. The sauce was tasteless and congealed. As I said my fellow diners really enjoyed there meals, however my experience was not good.

site_logo

Peter J . 2024-10-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We stayed at the hotel for several nights as part of a tour group. We had breakfast each morning, which was a mainly buffet arrangement. It had a good range of choices and dietary needs could be accommodated. Dinner was taken as a group on some evenings and members of our party were requested to order in advance from a menu with a range of choices. The food quality and portion size was very good and service from the mainly young staff was friendly and pleasant. There is also an adjacent well stocked bar area, where again we experienced friendly service. The bar and restaurant is open to non residents and we will probably visit again when in Kirkwall for one day next year.

site_logo

Chris M . 2024-09-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Vine para una cena, después de haber estado un par de veces antes. El personal era muy amable y servicial. La comida realmente no era lo suficientemente bueno - Las bolas de masa de haggis sabía horrible (opinión de alguien que le gusta haggis) , el queso grimbister era tibia y la crema que la acompaña, simplemente extraño. Nuestra red no era mucho mejor - sobre la carne salada cocida y verduras poco apetitosas. La actualización de la decoración es genial, la comida realmente lo decepciona. Ciertamente no volveré.

site_logo

TessnZed . 2024-08-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I actually first was taken to this restaurant decades ago by my uncle who was doing business in Kirkwall. In the many years since, it’s my go to restaurant when in town. The special that day was langoustines which we all decided to have. There was a generous portion, perfectly cooked, and succulent. I’ve had many other things there, always good.

site_logo

jjfiona . 2024-08-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Gezellig restaurant. Heerlijk gegeten en aardige bediening. Wij hadden de zalm, steak. Reserveren is aan te raden. Direct aan de haven met uitzicht op de boten.

site_logo

Ilse R . 2024-07-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We called in for lunch on a visit to Kirkwall. Very friendly staff and a good choice of meals, with good sized portions. A little pricey but worth it for the food and pleasant surroundings.

site_logo

Alison S . 2023-10-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Last visit was 14yrs ago, and our our latest visit did not disappoint. Our initial impression was questionable as we arrived 10min before our booking and were questioned about being too early - our table was ready but no menu was provided until our booked time.... This apart, the service was good and the food was top-notch: fresh monkfish was superb and the roast beef was top quality and large in size! Overall, was great value and an ideal setting to go for a highlight meal of your tip - would thoroughly recommend (but book in advance as is very busy)!

site_logo

Ayrdiver . 2023-09-17

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Very busy Saturday night in the restaurant but service was good. Grimbister cheese starter was great and the monkfish was fresh and delicious. Too full to sample the desserts but they looked good on the next table!

site_logo

Christine M . 2023-09-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had a lovely evening enjoying local freshly prepared food. The place where a quite busy. We emailed to secure a reservation. They have 100 whiskeys for the whisky lovers. We had the Beef and Guinness pie. It came with chips and vegetables. Our friends had the fish and chips. Like everywhere they are understaffed. The servers were friendly and attentive and set our expectations on when we would be served, which we appreciated. Desserts looked amazing but we were too full.

site_logo

donaldk16 . 2023-09-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We ate here a few years ago and this was our favourite place to eat in kirkwall, we were disappointed to find that standards have slipped since then, The food was average at best, bland and uninspiring not a patch on what it was on previous visits. I had the Ribeye steak and somehow it was dry and bland, the peppercorn sauce too was tasteless and as thin as water. The service too was poor, slow and felt amateurish, we were seated and waited around 25 minutes for our order to be taken, then another 20 minutes for our staters. Such a shame as this used to be our go to restaurant in Kirkwall, Sadly we can con longer recommend nor will we rush to return.

site_logo

DavidGreens12 . 2023-09-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Dinner was a bit disappointing. I had the pork (good), included roast potatoes, carrots (both overcooked) broccoli (underdone), Yorkshire pudding (stodgy) and gravy (thick brown glue drenched over everything). My friend had the burger which she wasn't impressed with, although she said her chips were good. We decided not to have a dessert as felt that too would be disappointing. Staff were helpful and friendly.

site_logo

Sheherizad . 2023-08-31

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We came here for food! Food was amazing, portion sizes were massive! Very flavoursome meals. Nice, clean restaurant. Staff excellent, will definitely be back!

site_logo

Karley F . 2023-08-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Really nice meal in a pleasant setting. The staff were very polite and helpful and they went out of their way to ensure we had all we needed. The lunch menu was great with plenty of traditional Orkney foods. I had the island burger which was really nice. I recommend for a lovely meal in a pleasant setting!

site_logo

86jaymiea . 2023-08-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had tried to find other hotels but they were all fully booked. The Kirkwall dining room was full, but they found space for us in the bar in a few minutes. The bar had regular tables so was just fine with us. I had the scallop souffle which was broiled scallops with a cheese souffle on the side. Both were excellent. So were the cheese fritters and cheese plate. You might think that's a lot of cheese for one meal, but each was different and very tasty. Service was very friendly and prompt. The decor is relaxing. Prices were quite good given the quality. One of my best meals in Scotland.

site_logo

Warren V . 2023-07-22

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The menu looked interesting. The service was amateurish and chaotic. We wanted to order wine, took time to get someone to serve us. There was a vegetarian menu on the site but there was hardly anything of it (we had three vegetarian who left hungry).. We ordered the seafood platter. We got boiled tasteless seafood with a lemon. When asked if we could get a sauce, mayo or anything to accompany this tasteless platter, we were served a hot steak sauce and were charged £2.50 on top of the £42.95 price of the platter. The salad was a tasteless mixture of salad leaved and boiled potatoes. The potatoes were covered with mayo.

site_logo

421ruthd . 2023-07-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Food is average, bar has a nice selection. Staff are young and undertrained. Found a hair in my mains. The server told me that it was from a brush (presumably from a pastry brush?) Was surprised to see I was still charged for the dish. Wouldn’t recommend, won’t be returning. There’s better food very close by.

site_logo

Jenny M . 2023-07-07

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The four of us had a most enjoyable meal on a Sunday evening. After starting off with very friendly and helpful service in the Highland Bar, we moved into the restaurant and were served in a very timely manner even with a large group in the restaurant. The choices on the menu suited all of us. The scallop soufflé was delicious with the scallops absolutely melt-in-your-mouth good. It was a treat to have the roast of the day which was lovely tender pork. Would have loved dessert too but just didn't have the room.

site_logo

DBAA . 2023-07-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Got off to a bad start. Was seated at the table and asked if we would like a drink. Told of the specials and what they didn’t have. Given the food menus, no drink or wine menu, then forgotten for the next 15 minutes. Ordered and asked for the other menus. The gin was asked for with a dash of lemonade and it came drowned in it. The wine came and was simply dumped on the table, not asked if we wanted it poured etc. starters was French onion soup which was good and a scallop soufflé. The scallops were well over cooked. We ordered a sharing main course of seafood and you would have got better at most seaside kiosks. Dry mussels, overcooked scallops, no finger bowl and 1 small pre packaged hand wipe for 2 people. Plates clear and no ask if we wanted a dessert menu. After about 10 minutes someone came up with a notepad and asked if everything was okay. Asked for dessert menu. Ordered the dessert of a cheeseboard and strawberry assiette. The cheeseboard was fine except for the most disgusting dry chutney. The strawberry assiette was not good at all. It had a green liquid in a cup, a strawberry tart which was a custard tart with an old strawberry cut into 4. Overall an experience we will not repeat and will tell our friends to avoid. The quickest part of the service was the bill to card machine. At £127 for the experience and no tip left.

site_logo

Mario D . 2023-06-17

MORE AT TripAdvisor

A group of us ate at the hotel for several days and some meals were fine but others were well below standard. My friends ordered pork one evening and it was dry and you could not cut it with a knife. Another night I had the hamburger and it was tough and inedible. Others enjoyed their meals.

site_logo

Wongoola . 2023-06-01

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Really good food and a friendly service. They were really helpful. Place looked great had a nice atmosphere . The portions are quite large.

site_logo

paulm967 . 2023-05-27

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Excellent lunch with friends, good food, good drinks, lot of choice in whisky. friendly and helpfull staff.

site_logo

fabianvandiest . 2023-05-27

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Perfect spot for lunch after a stroll around the bustling shopping area. Their carrot and coriander soup was smooth and satisfying on a chilly day. There is something about the cows on Orkney because the butter will make you swoon. I would go back just...

site_logo

AllSeven2020 . 2023-05-20

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We have enjoyed eating here before but this time we left disappointed and still a bit hungry. The food was good but there was hardly any of it. A main course of Langoustines consisted of 4.. yes you read correctly just 4 langoustines which comes...

site_logo

rhiannonj888 . 2023-04-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

From breakfast to lunch and dinner every meal was great. Whether it was in the restaurant itself or in the bar, the food and the staff make it worthwhile. Even the soup :)

site_logo

Craigwjs1959 . 2022-12-19

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Beautiful Christmas lunch with colleagues. Restaurant not too busy at the time. Pre ordered food all came out in good time. Beautifully presented and delicious. Lots of empty plates in our group. Love what the owners are doing with upgrading, tastefully done. Thank you

site_logo

OrkneyGal7 . 2022-12-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Amazing selection of whiskies and great service. We missed the chance to dine there but the menu looked very appealing.

site_logo

Tringaligiuseppe . 2022-10-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We stopped in for breakfast, and enjoyed a lovely meal. One full cooked breakfast, one boiled eggs with soldiers - who knew that was an official “thing”?? Nice friendly staff, quick service. I would definitely eat here again!

site_logo

sheenat321 . 2022-10-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

This place has the most extensive bar of Highland Park (HP) Whiskys I have seen. It is a must for any fan of HP! The bar also has an diverse collection of Orkney gins and offer flights at reasonable prices to try multiple of you...

site_logo

Stylianos S . 2022-10-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Very impressed with the interior design, elegant but modern. Excellent food and great service. Good value for money too. Despite being extremely busy, food arrived in good time and all servers had time for us. Would highly recommend.

site_logo

Alikitten75 . 2022-10-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The Kirkwall Hotel oozes atmosphere, with its high ceilings and bookshelves; it's a bit pricey, though, but the portions are huge.

site_logo

binapiraeus . 2022-09-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I did not get to eat here as they were fully booked due to festivals and conventions in town. But I did take advantage of the bar and its amazing Whisky menu. I think nearly every type of Highland Park whisky ever made is available...

site_logo

Patrick F . 2022-09-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

My meal of rib eye steak with trimmings was disappointing (£27.25 for one course plus half a pint of Orkney ale) but I was happy to be there as the restaurant is dog-friendly. The rib-eye was thin, more like a flat-iron piece of meat, the...

site_logo

MalLondon . 2022-09-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Booked a large table for a family meal. We were, quite understandably, asked to pre-order from a lovely looking menu a week or so in advance which we were happy to do. After our arrival in the restaurant we were told some people had to...

site_logo

lumena2022 . 2022-07-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We were on a Viking Cruise around the British Isles when I had my 79th Birthday. My desire was to have a "sausage bap" to celebrate but the ship doesn't have proper British sausages so I told my wife we'd try on shore in Kirkwall....

site_logo

Travellers1970 . 2022-07-02

MORE AT TripAdvisor

My steak was paper thin when, a local speciality, it should have been at least 2cm thick and I asked for medium rare but it was overcooked. Vegetables not plentiful. Very high prices but roomy seating and staff were pleasant and efficient.

site_logo

maureenlawrence77 . 2022-06-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We came for an evening meal here during a stay in Orkney. The restaurant looks far better from the inside than outside. We both had starters and mains. Our starters were both really good but I did not enjoy the main course of mushroom risotto....

site_logo

Neill H . 2022-06-26

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had lunch at the Kirkwall Hotel restaurant with my family. I ordered a burger and chips, my wife had fish and chips and my daughter macaroni and cheese. I was looking forward to a locally made burger but ended up with a warmed up frozen...

site_logo

Orkneyman888 . 2022-06-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We konden niet in het restaurant met de hond, maar kregen een gezellig tafeltje in de pub. Als voorgerecht hadden...

site_logo

lotjeenseppe . 2022-06-21

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Without a table booked I had my doubts of getting in but wasn't disappointed and taken immediately. The menu was fairly extensive and all the staff were efficient. Everything I had was cooked to perfection..

site_logo

Andy L . 2022-06-08

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Lovely welcome. Service was good, staff friendly and helpful and the dining room itself is beautiful to look at. We had cod with saffron rice and a delicate curried sauce, perfectly cooked. Our starters were squid (delicious) and crab doughnuts (different and very tasty)

site_logo

Stephen B . 2022-06-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Apparently this restaurant does not season their food as it’s up to the customer!!!! Disappointing attitude and response to some honest feedback. It would seem the customer views are not worth listening to because the front of house knows best…. Never experienced such dismissive behaviour...

site_logo

Darryl H . 2022-06-05

MORE AT TripAdvisor

we have visitors staying and thought it would be nice to go to the Kirkwall for an evening meal - I went into the restaurant to book and said there were two vegans in the party and was told that was not a problem, which...

site_logo

henanderson . 2022-05-31

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had a great meal in the Kirkwall Hotel, on a very bust Sunday evening, service was excellent, wonderful attentive staff, reasonably priced, although I did baulk at the £999 a dram whisky on offer!

site_logo

IainMcR . 2022-04-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great menu and service. Recent refurbishment and looks very nice. All of us had 3 courses and we all enjoyed what we had. I would suggest the burger

site_logo

keiran g . 2021-11-01

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Very helpful staff - able to accommodate two vegetarians and one coeliac very easily. Lovely helpful staff and food was delicious! Highly recommend a visit. The decor is so interesting with wonderful artefacts and mirrors on the walls.

site_logo

TrishN145 . 2021-10-19

MORE AT TripAdvisor

While the Kirkwall is not quite at the standard of some of the exceptional eateries in this island town, and there is room for improvement, we did enjoy our meal here. Quite a large eating and bar area here, but it soon fills up, so...

site_logo

MichelleS948 . 2021-09-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We popped in for a drink and ended up staying for dinner. The bar and restaurant service was friendly and attentive. We chose the hake which was very nicely cooked. Also the coffee was delicious. We didn't have to book, but it may be advisable.

site_logo

sc0ttie2007 . 2021-09-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great meal overall but we skipped the uninteresting starter options n shared the Seafood Platter under Mains - enjoyed the cold n hot smoked salmon, seared scallops, pickled n smoked mackerel, n mayonnaise shrimps. The duck confit n the grilled ribeye were v good. Service...

site_logo

Pinnacle Y . 2021-09-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Very busy when we visited so would recommend booking. menu reasonably priced and great service from the staff who were professional and friendly. Scallops were well cooked thought the hake was very small potion considering its not an expensive fish . soufflé was delicious as...

site_logo

robblorri . 2021-09-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Nice place, but not quite living up to its own aspirations of fairly posh, fairly expensive hotel restaurant. Our ‘haggis’ starter was more like chicken liver and the seafood platter was typical of the experience – mainly, but not entirely good. We had delicious smoked...

site_logo

BristolPog . 2021-09-03

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We ate twice at this restaurant in Kirkwall. Lovely staff, who really tried to make it work, What is really nice about the menu is that despite having a pretty captive audience ( in that it is the only good restaurant in the harbour, they...

site_logo

Clairelovessurf1 . 2021-09-01

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The restaurant makes a feature of its view over the harbour which is across the road. That's it, really. The staff seem to know little about food intolerance. When making my booking I was asked about food allergies/intolerance and specified that nothing connected with vinegar...

site_logo

Haynest . 2021-08-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I did not stay here but I had afternoon tea with my aunt and mother. I loved it! Everything was so pretty and tasted amazing! I would definitely recommend to anyone staying here or that lives in Kirkwall!

site_logo

Aforeffort . 2021-08-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

My experience here wasn't poor, it was fair. We waited half an hour from sitting down to ordering and a further 20 minutes for the starter. We ordered the deep fried cheese which, as an item which has been on the menu for around 20...

site_logo

Felix P . 2021-08-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had an excellent 3 course dinner here with super efficient staff and a great menu which included lots of Orkney local produce cooked to perfection. After paying the bill we were told that if we returned just show you reciet and you get a...

site_logo

MikeBR . 2021-07-19

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Came here as a group of 6 Lovely friendly service, all covid compliant Great to see lots of local produce on the menu We visit here every time we come to Orkney, and are never disappointed I'd recommend the Grimbister deep fried cheese, followed on...

site_logo

Helen S . 2021-07-01

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Party of 7 really impressed by the choices on offer and our three courses, especially desserts which were amazing. Everything was beautifully presented and the service was great. One of the party thought their main course wasn’t quite up to the standard of the other...

site_logo

MandM192 . 2021-06-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had excellent hake with boulangère potatoes and fish and chips with prompt friendly service. Certainly a very reasonable place for an evening meal and very popular.

site_logo

LorettaL421 . 2021-06-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Could not fault from start to finish our evening, service was first class, as was food. Really nice welcome, got a Temperature test on arrival, we were then taken to our table where we got explain to us with regards to specials and catch of...

site_logo

Claire M . 2020-11-18

MORE AT TripAdvisor

With the country under lockdown the hotel was the only place to get an evening meal. There was a reasonable selection to choose from and the food was delicious. The service was attentive and it could not be faulted. Lovely meal.

site_logo

Brian7392 . 2020-11-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We visited in a party of 5 and there was an offer of two people for £15. The waiter happily applied all of us to the offer which was great. Lovely view over the harbour and of the whisky laden bar which was sadly off...

site_logo

RobScott1970 . 2020-11-01

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We have just had dinner here tonight.....very friendly helpful staff.....lovely hotel restaurant and a delicious meal too. Good choice of menu.....really enjoyed it. If your ever in Kirkwall go there ...good food and value for money.

site_logo

dianemW5010BI . 2020-10-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We visited he Hotel for dinner on two occasions and found the food to be of a very high standard .The staff were so helpful .The service was excellent and felt very safe with he procedures in place for Coronaviris .Would certainly recommend the Hotel...

site_logo

annedempster70 . 2020-10-03

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We went in here for brunch; it was very nice. Lovely surroundings and good, friendly service. We saw people at another table having lunch and their food looked good too!

site_logo

Seamus60 . 2020-10-01

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Due to Covid and it being the tail end of the summer season unfortunately many eateries in Orkney had closed so on an afternoon walk our friend Luise had spotted the menu outside the hotel so we decide to give it a go for our...

site_logo

hungryharold . 2020-09-21

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had difficulty getting a table for dinner but once I was in it was worth it . Limited menu ordered via a tick list but roast lamb was tasty . Service fantastic and they all worked as a team which was impressive. Even the guy on reception lent a hand . Would recommend.

site_logo

mollstone . 2020-09-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Used the hotel for take away food. They currently have a limited take away menu at reasonable prices.Covid precautions are clearly stated & followed. The hotel is also under going renovations but the staff are helpful & friendlyPhoned through order & choose pick up time. Food was on time, well packaged & hot. Had the steak & ale pie - very tasty.Had the cheese burger the following week - not as tasty & a little short on chips.Overall, the hotel is in an excellent location, town centre, harbour view & staff are friendly & helpful.

site_logo

U8982CDkarenm . 2020-09-07

MORE AT TripAdvisor

visited for dinner on our 2 night holiday. hubby had lamb and said it was delicious. I had pasta, bit overcooked and not much taste. desert was amazing though and certainly wouldn't complain as was on 50% off night. hotel being refurbished and I imagine will be lovely when comllete. friendly front of house staff

site_logo

R9367XXlisar . 2020-09-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Well it is a long time since I had to tick a piece of paper in restaurant for my food it was almost a return to school dinners. Menu was poor guess they are trying to pile them in to take advantage of 50 % government deal and doing it very badly. The starter was smoked salmon and frankly was thrown together in 30 seconds on top of three croutons basic level preparation. Steak pie gravy watery and tastless. Sweet potato and tomato soup no taste of sweet potato and over powered by tomatoes and split!! Now this maybe as they are trying to pile in as many people as possible during the offer period but 14 years coming to this hotel and this is by far the worst meal I have ever had here. Other hotels in orkney have the offer on and meals have been amazing they are putting quality over quantity and are streaks ahead of the Kirkwall. Kirkwall we have visited you for 14 years and had excellent meals not this time you really need to get your act together others have adapted very well to the current epidemic you have not

site_logo

kevinsmith29 . 2020-08-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Lovely surroundings pleasant staff limited menu thought it was quite expensive for what we had feel your paying more for the surroundings but the food was nice.

site_logo

I4793CAgailf . 2020-02-19

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had the pleasure of dining at the Kirwall Hotel Restaurant on a recent tour of the Orkney Islands. Location was convenient, restaurant and hotel were both beautiful. The dinner menu was quite varied and did not disappoint. Had delicious seared scallops, a lovely duck breast that was roasted to perfection. Wine list was perfect and the Sticky Toffee Pudding cannot be missed! Thank you for a delicious meal in a fabulous venue.

site_logo

Buffet11 . 2019-12-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had a lovely meal, food was excellent and entertain was top notch! A brawl took place in the neighbouring bar (skippers)! Only down side was the door through to the bar was shut during this event and we missed what happened next!

site_logo

rosehearts . 2019-11-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Very helpful staff, unfortunately the food is not quite up to scratch. Good menu and presentation, but possibly trying to be something it’s not? Also too expensive for the quality of the food and surroundings.

site_logo

401em . 2019-10-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

My spouse and I were on a tour of the north of Scotland after a visit to England. We were dismayed by the large number of chain restaurants all over England and in Edinburgh. We had many so-so meals and were done with deep fried food. Orkney is different. You won’t find American chain restaurants there. We arrived late into Kirkwall but managed to get a table at the Kirkwall Hotel restaurant. We had no expectations but were seated quickly and met our friendly server. My wife and I like to play cards while we travel so had the cribbage going when our scallops appetizer appeared. The game stopped while we enjoyed the perfectly prepared local mollusks. My entree was a steak and ale pie while my spouse had the salmon. Both were great examples of creative use of local ingredients. The pie was superb with a savoury filling and delightful puff pastry on top. We had such a great time eating, playing and chatting with our server that we pretty much closed the place down! The Kirkwall comped us a bottle of Prosecco if we were to come back so we did. The bar is excellent at the Kirkwall as well and I enjoyed many tasty local beers and some fine whiskys. I had the monkfish and my wife had the lamb dinner the second night. Both were excellent if not as draw droppingly good as what we had the first night. Another note is that the service was good. I am from Canada and used to good service in restaurants because restaurant staff are paid so poorly they rely on gratuities to survive; they often crank up the service and I compensate accordingly. In the UK, table service isn’t universal and where it is provided, it’s usually not up to the standard North Americans are used to. At the Kirkwall, the service was friendly and great. The staff we dealt with seemed to be happy in their work. We met the manager and the chef and they seemed kind and on the ball so perhaps that’s the difference. Happy travels.

site_logo

Matthew B . 2019-10-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

2 weeks into our trip. First mistake. It was to be a “special meal for a special event”. Not!Fish dish was fine. Orkney rib eye steak wasn’t. Very small and amazingly thin. Ordered medium rare. Arrived lightly seared and raw. I know I should have sent it back. Also came with fries and a container of gravy?A local couple we had met earlier had suggested that Orkney beef was great. Well not hereWhen asked how everything was. I complained. They comped our cappuccino.

site_logo

John B . 2019-10-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We did stop here for meals every time we were in Kirkwall, lunch was ok. We booked for an evening meal and the meal was a complete let down, won’t be back. Shame because we’ve been going for years.There are plenty other lovely restaurants close by.

site_logo

StacksnTressels . 2019-09-21

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The food was fine but nothing to get too excited about. My wife ordered terrine which stated with Melba toast. However no Melba toast arrived, when we asked the waitress where the toast was , her reply was you only get a little bit anyway. The roast beef was lovely but there must be a shortage of vegetables In Orkney !!

site_logo

Angus170362 . 2019-09-21

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Wij hebben niet in het hotel zelf gegeten maar in de inpandige pub/restaurant. Het was hier prima toeven qua eten en drinken tegen redelijke prijzen. Het is een modern ingerichte pub/restaurant met een 4 tal TV,s waarop sport wordt vertoond. Bediening is vlot en vriendelijk.

site_logo

JohanM365 . 2019-09-19

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Excellent from start to finish.We booked a few hours before we wanted to eat and were accommodated even though they were busy. Food was delicious and service at a leisurely pace.Salmon cooked perfectly and hubby enjoyed his steak & ale pie. We shared a dessert of soufflé & it was quite memorable. We had a lovely bottle of Shiraz for £18...bargain price for a hotel!Would definitely recommend.

site_logo

Frogsgirl . 2019-09-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had lunch as part of a business meeting . There was little acknowledgement to our presence & service was slow. We had soup (which was very nice) - the waiter had to ask what type though - & sandwiches. Water was presented at our table but we weren't asked if further drinks were required - constantly had to ask rather than being offered.

site_logo

U8982CDkarenm . 2019-09-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Excellent roast beef dinner with all the trimmings. Great price, friendly service. Best to make a reservation. Relaxed, laid-back atmosphere with lovely big windows facing the harbor. I loved it.

site_logo

jeanettec529 . 2019-09-01

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Me and my with and our friends visited the Kirkwall Hotel for our evening meal. I had haggis and potatoes, my wife had rib-eye steak, my friend chose the same as my wife and I. One of the steaks had to be taken back to the kitchen to be heated up. My friend wasn’t happy at all as this restaurant had been recommended by someone. He won’t be going to this place again

site_logo

caithnessmwm . 2019-09-01

MORE AT TripAdvisor

6 people, 1 vegitarian, all were happy with their starters, mains, drinks and desserts. Everything would have been perfect... if there wouldn't have been 1 specific member of the serviceteam, who managed to mishear lemonade for whitewine, forget to note all starters, didnot remove dishes in time, remove full classes, and topped all of that with unfriendly behaviour.

site_logo

pepich2019 . 2019-08-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Dined in the Restaurant on 2 evenings.Good varied menu.Quick and pleasant service.The salmon starter was great.

site_logo

Bernard L . 2019-08-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great food, service and staff!! Highly recommended for lunch or a quick snack. Great location on the harbor.

site_logo

Tom B . 2019-08-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great food and a 3 course meal at a reasonable price. The food was presented very well and we all thoroughly enjoyed it.

site_logo

jetsaver . 2019-08-20

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We are here as working in the area, great food all very nice, good menu and good service. Definitely recommend

site_logo

Squawking44 . 2019-08-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We were a party of 20 and unfortunately we were not all seated together. It was a very busy Saturday evening and the staff did their best to manage.

site_logo

AlanM603 . 2019-08-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We really enjoyed our stay in this hotel. The food was delicious and the service for both the accommodation and restaurant was very efficient and friendly. Highly recommended especially if you get a bigger room overlooking the harbour.

site_logo

Jeneileen . 2019-08-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Det var virkelig dejlig laks og monkfisk, men fisken havde måske fået en anelse for meget, men det var yderst delikat. Servicen var derimod, meget bagud. Først fik vi ikke noget kort med drikkevarer, derefter ventede vi 20 minutter på at bestille drikkevarer, vores nabo fik deres forret, inden de fik vinkortet. Andre borde sad og ville gerne betale, medens tjenerne gik og dækkede bord til morgenmad, nogen af dem med hvide handsker, andre uden. Der var ingen der spurgte om vores tomme glas skulle fyldes op. Vi bad om menukort til dessert, og måtte selv finde en tjener der havde lyst til at tage mod bestilling. Desserten, blev bare plantet på bordet og så var han væk. Vi fangede en anden tjener der fortalte hvilke lokale oste det var vi fik serveret, samme med 4 købe kiks. Maden var så god så vi nok kommer igen, trods alt.

site_logo

Rejsemus . 2019-08-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Despite initial appearances, the restaurant within Kirkwall Hotel provided a great dinner and charming service. We racked up a fairly large bill, but overall, it represented good value. As with other Kirkwall establishments, booking ahead is essential.

site_logo

DMWEdinburgh . 2019-08-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We spent one afternoon alternating between the regally decorated bar and the scenic outdoor seating. Ewan provided exceptionally friendly and knowledgeable recommendations about local drinks. We enjoyed it so much that we booked dinner for a different day. Dinner in the dining room was equally pleasant, from lamb to salmon to pasta. There’s also a pub attached, so all your bases are covered! Definitely recommend that you stop by when you’re in Kirkwall.

site_logo

carross71 . 2019-08-07

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Good service. Nice surroundings. But poor vegetarian choice. In fact no choice. A breaded cheese dish, a bigger version of the starter.

site_logo

WalesJones67 . 2019-07-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

A big crowd of us, set menu, but dealt well with pre-warned allergies/aversions. Haggis starter, roasted salmon fillet with excellent vegetables, local Orkney ice cream. Great staff, good atmosphere, good food.

site_logo

MaeveMcP . 2019-07-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Fresh well cooked and presented meal. Only popped in for lunch but best to book for evenings as can be very busy.

site_logo

Carina M . 2019-07-24

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We stopped here for dinner after a long day of touring. The service was pleasant but quite slow. We eventually had to request our bill as did the table next to ours. The restaurant was extraordinarily hot and it was uncomfortable to eat in. Eventually, they cracked a window but it did little to help the temperature. The food was ok; I ordered the roast beef but did not get the promised Yorkshire pudding with it. There was some problem with them in the kitchen. Overall, the experience was fine but nothing to rave about.

site_logo

Meagan H . 2019-07-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Used to go here on special occasions, so not very often

site_logo

mam2seven . 2019-07-22

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We tried most of the restaurants in Kirkwall (including the Foveran) and the best food we had was here. Scallops were excellent.

site_logo

Synman . 2019-07-20

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Went for a family meal on Sunday 13th July. All had a brilliant meal. Food well presented hot and service was excellent. Good choice and well priced.

site_logo

Alanheatherorkney . 2019-07-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

This is an ideal venue to retreat to on a wet or windy evening to enjoy local drought beers and an immense range of whiskies and gins. The decor, sofas and bookshelves are excellent

site_logo

AlanofHove . 2019-07-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Similary restaurants in Highlands and Islands

restaurant_img
4.0

32 Opinions

location-iconKettletoft Village
British
outdoor_seating_122526takeaway_122526delivery_122526

Popped in for an evening meal. 2 x very tasty burgers and some good beer later we left very happy. It isn't the grandest of places, but it does deliver good food at a fair price. Would definitely return if we were staying longer.

restaurant_img
4.0

221 Opinions

location-iconAlbert Street
British
outdoor_seating_125167takeaway_125167delivery_125167

This place having a relaxed and friendly atmosphere, was a nice place to enjoy our breakfast. The service was top-notch. Bacon and burgers were delicious.

restaurant_img
4.2

271 Opinions

location-icon14 Main Street
British
outdoor_seating_125147takeaway_125147delivery_125147

Convenient and central but too expensive for this type of rooms and establishment.

restaurant_img
4.3

540 Opinions

location-icon6-8 Shore Street
British
outdoor_seating_125165takeaway_125165delivery_125165

Great wee place ,just next to Kirkwall Hotel.It belongs to Kirkwall Hotel and breakfast is in main Kirkwall Hotel.Nice and quiet room.

restaurant_img
4.5

1759 Opinions

location-icon14, Harbour St
British
outdoor_seating_125173takeaway_125173delivery_125173

Not good.Waiter very poor. Dumped the food down with a grunt. 3 prawns for £11. Really ? Won’t be back.Great quality but unbelievably overpriced for what you get. If you’re a tourist and get taken in by all this overpriced nonsense then go and visit ……..if you’re a bit more savvy……AVOID!!!!