Fairy Pizza in Rotherham - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Wonderful food and very quick delivery! :)

Been ordering from here for so long now and I cannot say how much me and my family enjoy the service and food

Been going here since i was at school in the early 90s. I've never been disappointed yet with anything I've had.

Not nice at all, really sorry to say.

I don't enjoy writing negative reviews but I really was so disappointed with the thin, vegetable pizza I ordered. I honestly think it's the worst I can remember. The dough was dry, cardboard-like with no flavour. Tomato sauce was spread so thinly and I guess must have dried out during cooking. Again no flavour at all. Then the veg; dumped with no care all over the place and lightly heated rather than cooked. It was more like a salad dumped on top and I really hate raw red onions; it's all I could taste all night. I had to pick them off. I'm a pizza fiend but even I gave up after eating half of this and put the rest straight in the bin. It's not even cheap either. 2 stars instead of 1 because at least I didn't get food poisoning! Will NOT be returning.

Been ordering from here for years and never disappoints, still the best pizza you can order by far!!

Been going here for 20 years+. And I say to everyone Fairy pizza is different its unique. And we are never disappointed

Always polite and friendly. The food is always nice and good value for money...

5* food and service as always. Best pizza place in the area. Always order from here, great food and friendly staff

Great pizzas at reasonable prices. Friendly staff and reliable delivery. Highly recommended.

We’ve just been here for the first time and OH WOW. AMAZING! This is by far the very best pizza in the area! The base was hand stretched and cooked to perfection. It was clearly fresh dough. We ordered 2 x Margaritas, 1 x Pepperoni and 1 x garlic bread with tomato and cheese. All 11 inch thin crust. Toppings were delicious and there was plenty on each pizza AND it all tasted so fresh. The staff were all really lovely too and so we are now customers for life. PLEASE never stop. Thank you so much. Delicious!!! Can’t wait to try other things now.

Been going here since I was a youth. Same chap still making them. Lovely pizzas always consistent never had a bad one or been disappointed. Best pizza takeaway around.

Lovely welcoming premises. Friendly staff, the best pizza I have had in a long long time. Tasty and plenty of toppings.

I’m amending this review due to the service, be warned when they say 45 mins they mean 90 mins!!! On a number of occasions and not necessarily busy times. Such a shame as a nice pizza but service is abominable which means we will go elsewhere in future.

Worse Pizza that's ever been delivered to my door, flat cold, with all the topping piled up high in the middle of the pizza that are literally uncooked with sloppy cold doe, horrendous waste of money. I'm not even going to waste money on gas heating this thing up, straight in the bin, shocking!

Probably the best pizza I have ever tasted, the ingredients were so fresh and lovely thin base, also had a mixed platter for 2 and the dips you get especially the garlic is excellent, should sell it as I’d buy it by the bucket load .. it’s delicious

The best pizza . Nothing else needs to be said

Been going here for 20 years plus always nice fresh pizza and pasta 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

Friendly pizza shop. Not as greasy as standard pizza places.

The staff are incredible. Really made our visit memorable!

Fantastic Pizza, Nachos & chips tonight. Friendly service & fantastic freshly cooked food.

Just placed an order with fairy pizza. Unfortunately when our order was delivered a pizza was missing. I phoned them up and they couldn't apologise enough. Within 10 minutes the pizza was delivered along with a fresh portion of fries and also a bottle of wine. Can't fault them at all. Amazing customer service. I wasn't expecting anything extra. Just the pizza. Can't fault them. That's how you treat customers. Thank you fairy pizza.

Fairy has been a stalwart of the Wickersley food scene for well over 20 years. Top quality pizza, hand made in front of you, and burgers and pasta dishes. Genuinely the best pizza around, friendly and efficient staff and that includes the delivery peeps. There's a reason they've lasted this long. 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩

Very good Pizza, we had the vege Spinach and chicken ham and sweetcorn...fresh ingredients cooked to perfection. Would be 5 stars only I like oregano on my pizza,..that is not a criticism though...would recommend

Fab food, fab service all round. Thanks for last night's tea 👌💕

Clean and Friendly. Do the most amazing Garlic Burgers won't go anywhere else for a burger!

More than happy to support a local business and have done for a few years, more so now than ever. I must say though, after a minor error on our order, we were sent something extra as an apology, which wasn't required but is very much appreciated

Just the best authentic pizzas around. Wouldn't go anywhere else. Friendly staff, great value for money, and delivered hot.

Fantastic food. Great quality and value. The pizzas are absolutely fantastic, even the French fies are perfect. I take my hat off to the guys that run it, hard working, polite and dedicated. Thank you guys.

First time using Fairy Pizza and it won’t be the last. I have to say the Pizza and Garlic Bread were delicious and can’t wait to to work my way through the menu. Highly Recommend hence 5 Stars

This is the best pizza shop I have ever come across. Get the deep pan. The toppings are amazing!!!

Hours of business are rubbish, close early, says open on google and is closed a lot of the time anyway. Unprofessional. If your going to have a business be open when you advertise, it’s not hard.

Have been a customer of fairy pizza for about 15+ years. The food is always awesome and if anything, it's so good that me and my partner are becoming fairy pizza-aholics. The staff are wonderful, always friendly and very understanding when an order goes wrong. Shall continue to be customer for as long as Fairy Pizza exists.

I have been working in Rotherham for the weekend and came across this pizza place. I went in and ordered a pizza. WOW! The pizza was perfectly cooked and so tasty. I would recommend anyone the try it. Shame I'm not here longer as I would have liked to have tried the burgers too.

Absolutely the best Pizzas 🍕 for miles. Staff and service are just amazing. 20 years of excellence. Thanks guys.

Disappointed sorry.. last 3 small pizzas were over £23. The pepperonis was bland, thin and dry. Vegetarian was ok. Lovely people and service... but not again I'm afraid.

The best hand made pizza in Yorkshire.

Amazing Pizza, great place and friendly staff and owner.

Best pizza anywhere. Friendly people

Still one of my favourites for over 25years

First time we have been here great food and all cooked fresh will be going there agan

Just ordered a alfungi, not had one for years from them...absolutely disgusting..raw mushrooms, no cheese...fries rank, changed hands must have blahh

Been going for as long as I can remember and it's never let us down.

Love this pizza place. We wouldn't have pizza from any where else. After nearly 26 years of ordering from them they are still the best.❤

Beautiful pizza and lots of choice of toppings for a good price!

To say this is on my door stop don't normally bother with takeaways but this was very very good better than the big chain pizza place

Excellent fast fresh tasting pizza best around this area by a country mile

Fantastic food, great service......why go anywhere else? First class.

Great food great great staff been ordering from here for over 20 years and travel over 15 miles by far the best pizza shop in Rotherham

Amazing pizza, still the best in Wickersley

Never had anything that we didnt like from them. we go there regularly. Very friendly, excellent service as they are not a chain they can do specials if you ask.

An authentic Italian experience

Freiendly staff gud food been goin for last 25 years

Amazing food been having food from here for years no other pizza shop cuts it when you have tried a fairy pizza xx

Honestly. Best pizza house in rotherham. Not frozen pre made bases I'm talking freshly made infront of you with great customer service! Definitely recommend.

Superb, hand made pizza, while you wait. There are no frozen pizza bases here, watch as the chefs hand roll and throw your pizza in front of you. Almost all the ingredients are made/ prepared in house, from hand chopped fresh vegetables, to hand made dough. They also make sumptuous pasta dishes, Chilli-con-carne, and serve flame grilled burgers, with numerous side order options. There is not a friendlier place around. Forget your large chain stores, this is how it should be.

Had first time order ,delivered on time , pizzas were spot on will be using again 5 out of 5 for Fairy Pizza. Try them you will not be disappointed. .

Had bolognaise pizza and garlic mushrooms last night friday 29th july. Worst ever bolognaise ive ever tasted and garlic mushrooms was exactly that mush. My partner n i are both ill diarreah and vomitting. Will definitely not be ordering from here again

Fabulous best pizza in Rotherham!!! Staff are great always remember my name and what I like. Quick delivery, hot on arrival truly gorgeous pizza xx