Nightcrawler Pizza in Liverpool

New York style pizzas, whole or by the slice, I used to come here years ago as a special lunch treat for a slice, glad to see it's still around and it's as good as I remember it, thin dough base, large slices.

It hits the spot. Best New York style pizza in town, by far. Excellent as takeaway. Edit Sept 2024: Now the pizza is thinner and drier than 2-3 months ago (and perhaps they changed the cheese as well). I tried it a couple of times already before updating the review and I have to remove one star. Hope it goes back to its original glory.

Best crust I’ve ever had. Fantastic service. Pizza served well done. Good variety of pizzas and available seating on point.

This is one of the worst pizzas I've had in a long time! Disgusting amounts of cheese, and I found a stray olive pit. Also waited 45 mins as they forgot our order multiple times. Oh by the way, no cutlery for this super floppy pizza that they serve in boxes. Never coming back!

My favourite pizza in Liverpool

One of the best pizzas in Liverpool for a very reasonable price.

I ordered a soprano pizza, the lady dropped my pizza first time and offered to make another which she did and didn’t end up cooking it for long which resulted in me getting charged for a raw pizza which I ate and had left me throwing up all night. Never again.

Been in the adjoining bar most of the evening, went to get a pizza at 22:20 and waited 10 minutes as no member of staff anywhere to be seen. At 22:30 a member of staff appeared and said to me “sorry we close at half 10” and despite Google maps showing a close time of 11pm I was still astounded as had she been there earlier (for as long as I had been waiting) I was well within the time frame for ordering. I think she must have gone walkabouts toward the end of the shift as did not want any more orders! Terrible service and customer experience

Really good New York style pizza, nice staff

Great pizza but more cafe than restaurant - slices of pizza, paper plates but just so good.

Got a pepperoni pizza and it was such good quality was great. The size was very big too. It was really good would 100% recommend if your the area

Went to get pizza by the slice. Ordered and grabbed a drink, after an hour I went up to check if our pizza (slice) was ready and the lady at the counter was to busy gossiping on a phone call to address me. We eventually just left without ever receiving our food

Went here to get pizza by the slice around dinner time. Found all of the shelves empty save two slices. Was told that they “make them to order” which I’m not sure how that works if you only want one slice, as you can’t make one slice of pizza by itself. We decided to order enough to make it a whole pizza to not confuse the young girl behind the counter. We went to get some beers at the adjoining bar, after 35 minutes we went to check on the state of our pizza. Unfortunately the girl behind the counter had her phone glued to her face yammering to someone on the other end and didn’t appear to be in a position to assist us. It also appeared that she was only just now getting around to making our pizza. Other potential customers came up to the counter to order, but she was too busy making our 35 minute past due pizza and yammering in her phone so she told them “we’re not taking orders right now, try again in 20 minutes”. Mind you, there didn’t appear to be a wild influx of orders that would prevent her from making another, if she could get off her phone. The pizza and the place are probably deserving of the 4.5 stars they have, this employee was not. 17/09/2023 @1800hrs

Amazing pizza amazing atmosphere we go here quite a bit because it's the nicest pizza place around Liverpool food tastes amazing and everyone is so friendly and polite.

Best slice of pizza in town! The manager there is very knowledgeable and cares about the little things. Not pricey. And a lot of flavour in their tomato sauce with good quality cheese.

I really miss the honey pepperoni pizza….I used to dream about it :(

Mhmm, yummy freshly made 'zas, and the crust is so perfectly thin! Excellent. 😛

Amazing pizza the slice is almost half pizza

Boss Pizza at a boss price point and the chef is sound. Took time to show me that there is a seperate station to prevent cross contamination as my misses has a bad pine nut allergy. Thanks again.

Bland basic pizza. The tomato sauce on the base has no flavour and its not mozzarella that's used. Ruby's round the corner is better.

This is, quite simply, THE BEST pizza in Liverpool. They are up against some serious competition but Nightcrawler's bases are light, crispy and delicious and the toppings they use are of the highest quality. The chef puts real thought into the combinations of toppings creating the best overall pizza in the city. Mr White is incredible as is Hulk. Even the humble Margherita (everything you need, nothing you don't) pops off the plate with flavours that are just superb. They also make their own dips from scratch and I can say that if they sold the garlic mayonnaise in bottles I'd buy a crate of it. The BBQ is also incredible and unlike most hot sauces theirs has such flavour before the heat hits the back of your throat that you can't help but go back for more. You can keep your Crust, you can leave your Rudy's, if you truely want the best pizza get yourself to Nightcrawler.

Great huge pizza slices! Loved the Dr. Pepper pizza. Definitely a great place for some pizza and drinks!

Pizza was very good. If you are hungry at midnight. A good place to eat and listen to music

Unreal service from the totally awesome Ollie, he was such a cool dude, went in late and got the best service ever, give him a pay rise or buy him a drink!! Cheers man 😎 Best Pizza ever by the way!!!

Great pizza! Vegan hoison duck is my personal favourite and Mary is the best! 😎

Great pizza especially the vegan hoisin duck. Huge slices as well.

Literally THE best pizza you can grab in the center of town. Big range of options, good vegetarian selection. Would recommend getting the Hulk if you do go. Staff are also very friendly.

friendly helpful staff, great pizza. Vegan pizza! thumbs up.

Excellent pizza by the slice. The Dr. Pepper with pepperoni and honey is worth making a special trip for.

V good pizza But… lady on tills wouldn’t get anymore sauce I asked shy and she just went back wouldn’t get it but weird All sauces and herbs empty and she wouldn’t refill hmmmm

Great value tasty pizza, good environment and quick service

Omg!!..Jay the best ever pizzas

Why would you want to get pizza from anywhere else - the best pizza is at Nightcrawler! Stop wasting time eating the fake stuff!!!

Surprisingly tasty pizza, freshly baked in front of you.

Proper pizza, big slice and original taste. The dough is also really authentic, and the chilling area to enjoy it couldnt be better.

Nice place, good atmosphere, good pizza. Not enough selection though. Only served Pepsi. Friendly staff.

Very nice pizza! 2-4-1 from Mon - Thur :)

Serves pizza until around 1am on a Saturday. I went for the pesto option. It was soaked in so much oil it was difficult to enjoy. Will def try other flavours as its unfair to to judge a menu from 1 slice

Great choice of pizzas, brilliant atmosphere and friendly staff, half price before 6 which is a bonus, definitely recommend this place.

consistently good, best pizza in Liverpool

Great pizza place. Several to choose from and nice price too. I am surprised that there are so little reviews from this place. The guys from the staff were very nice.

Superb pizzas, fresh from the oven and a very charming chef Kiara

really good pizza at a super cheap price, definitely a place to go! a nice outdoor seating area.