The Bay Tree in South Somerset - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The people that own the Bay Tree are really friendly and gave us a very warm welcome.Staff really good.Food was top notch, great portions,fantastic flavours.And Pints of Guinness that are as good as any you will in Ireland.Thanks so much for 2 lovely night at the Bay Tree.Tom&Ann London.

What a fantastic find! By far the best pub in Cary. Friendly + very helpful publicans, lovely staff, warm hospitality + excellent food. Made our 2 week stay in Cary very enjoyable.

Amazing food as always. The Stilton pancakes are out of this world and the homemade ice cream is delicious. Really recommend the food at this hidden gem of a pub.

Really lovely pub/restaurant with very friendly and welcoming owner and staff. Our meal was delicious - best beef burger ever eaten and the most incredible home made ice cream! Will definitely visit again if we’re back in the area.

I can’t believe the positive reviews for this place, the food was dreadful. I have given 2 stars because the bar and waiting staff were good

Delicious food and great service. One of our party were coeliac and the options were brilliant. Would recommend and will definitely be visiting again

We booked a table for a Saturday lunch in order to catch up with an old friend we hadn’t seen for ages. The Bay Tree was new to all of us but was a convenient distance to meet in the middle, so to speak. We were given a warm welcome by both the staff and the real fires. It was almost like stepping into somebody’s sitting room and being invited to stay for a meal. The food was beautifully cooked and very reasonably priced. Even though they were supposed to close at 2.30pm, we were still chatting at 2.45 but there was no hint that we should be on our way. It was a great lunch and I hope we get a chance to go there again. Highly recommend you visit if you can.

Visited on a Saturday, the food as per normal was excellent and the service was top notch, you cannot fault this pub for what it does and while some might say it is without the bell's and whistles, what it does hits the spot every time! There is always a warm and friendly welcome and nothing is too much trouble.

Perfect place for a Birthday celebration. The food was delicious, the atmosphere was warm and welcoming and the homemade ice cream has to be tried to be believed! We will definitely be back.

Fantastic food. The beef pie in Guinness was the best I have ever tasted. A lovely pub fast,pleasant service at reasonable prices. In or near Castle Cary then visit this great pub for food

Lovely and friendly owner who clearly took pride and joy from making this a homely experience. Food was great. We had the sirloin steak and a beef and Guinness pie. Both cooked very well and sizeable portions. We will be coming back and can recommend others do the same.

Good night out, good food nice and hot all turned up at the same time. Was a little slow for food to get out but not terrible delay. Wasn’t a packed restaurant area, staff were friendly enough and didn’t overwhelm you with checking in like a lot of places. Helpful with a query. Would go again.

I visited The Bay Tree for Sunday lunch with family members. It is a very nice country style pub. We got our drinks and were taken to our table by a very friendly server. We ordered the meals, roasts all round and they were brought out a few minutes later. The portions were very generous and we loaded them even more with the vegetables brought separately. Our meals were excellent and were consumed with enthusiasm. Even though we were full, we did make room for dessert. My Spotted Dick with piping hot custard was very pleasant and flavoursome. Thank you Bay Tree. I will be back.

Popped in hoping to get a meal on our way home at 6 in the evening. Very friendly welcome, great service and excellent food

We went here for the first time today and I'm blown away. I really fancied the steak even though--until today--I'd never had a good steak in a pub and I even told them as such. Well the sirloin I had today was cooked well (to medium) and a nice cut of meat too. The onion rings that came with it were probably the best onion rings I've had out; they had a nice sweetness and easy to bite through without taking the entire ring out of the batter. The chips were crispy on the outside, golden, and fluffy on the inside. Perfection. And the crowning glory of my meal was actually the creamy pepper sauce. It was a generous portion that lasted my entire meal, including for the chips and onion rings. The taste and creaminess was spot on. It's by far the best peppercorn sauce I've had at a restaurant and reminded me of my grandmother's peppercorn sauce. In fact the sauce was so spot on if I didn't know she was no longer with us I would have had to check in the back of the kitchen to make sure she didn't make it herself. My wife was worried she'd have food envy of my steak when she ordered the lasagne. However, she was delightfully happy with her choice. And she loved the tolberone cheesecake for desert. Oh and the homemade garlic bread to start was really nice. Way better than garlic bread most places and very clearly homemade. I'd recommend this place to anyone and we will definitely be back. I want to try a burger next time, but I'm worried I'll regret it not having the creamy pepper sauce again.

Brilliant place to celebrate a birthday. Wonderful food and atmosphere - can’t recommend enough. The best place to eat in Castle Cary. We all need to suppprt this business.

Sunday 23rd July, wow, wow,wow. They accommodated all the children’s needs, food was piping hot and the amount was plentiful. Clean great service. Highly recommended. We’ve lived in Cary for 26 yrs and our first time for Sunday lunch.

We called in on our way through Castle Cary and we're very pleased we did! Friendly, welcoming staff and an excellent range of home cooked food. There was also a good range of gluten free options. The steak and ale pie was the best I have had and there was a choice of oaccompaniments. Desserts were also varied and excellent, would recommend the fresh pineapple and homemade ice cream. Would not hesitate to go there again, it's even worth a detour off of the main road into Castle Cary from the Sparkford direction.

Excellent Sunday lunch Honest, good quality pub food at very good pricing Despite Father’s Day lunch and being full service from the young girls was professional and accomplished A new find for us

We went for a drink at lunchtime, the day after the coronation. There were street parties going on elsewhere in the town and the place was very quiet as a result. Service was good, beer was good, food was good. We had veggie pancakes and a small pork roast. Both very good. Syrup pudding and homemade raspberry ripple ice cream - both excellent. It's not gourmet and doesn't pretend to be. Just good solid honest pub grub. Good value too. We'll definitely be back.

Met friends there as a half way between where we live. Had a lovely lunch steak pie with real chunks of tender beef. Lasagna in a smaller portions if wanted. Vegetable pancake very tasty. As we had not met for some time we chatted past...

Amazing food and service, as always. I can’t recommend the vegetarian pancakes and homemade ice cream enough. Well worth a visit, or two, or three ….

Eight of us went out for a meal and we weren’t disappointed. Great selection which made it really hard to choose. 8 clean plates said it all, thoroughly enjoyed our food and highly recommend.

We ate here last night as a change from cooking. The inside of the pub is really welcoming as was the service. The real ale they had in was great as was the choice of sprits. The food was plentiful in portion size and was...

Great food, fab and friendly, good prices, great staff, dog friendly, nothing too much trouble brilliant family run old school pub and great place to eat

Great traditional pub in the town of Castle Carey. Excellent staff and great traditional food. The pub is spotlessly clean in all areas and is a joy to be in.

We have just moved the Castle Cary and decided to go to the bay tree on our first Sunday here. Definetly worth the five stars, the food was amazing (proper British pubs food), there was loads of it (even a whole jug of extra gravy),...

We stopped in The Bay Tree, on carnival night for a drink, landlord and landlady made us feel very welcome, very warm, friendly atmosphere, lots of different drinks to choose from, beautiful pub, nice and clean toilets. Even the cat is friendly. Love this place...

Very nice pub lovely warm welcome. Staff, landlord and chef very friendly. Food was of excellent quality. Can recommend the home made steak pie and liver with onion gravy ohh and the toblerone cheesecake and Knickerbocker glory. Delicious. Just across from our b and b...

Had the privilege of visiting the Bay Tree last month, perfect surroundings, incredible customer service and first class food. The most friendly owners and staff made us so welcome. We will be back!

Had lunch with a friend, food was superb, price was good, and friendly service. Nice old pub atmospere.

Visiting area and wanted a nice pub lunch. The landlord was a very friendly chap and also helpful with providing local information to us. The food (pie and ploughman's both from specials board) was top draw pub food! Will be returning when next in the...

Lovely little pub with cute courtyard garden. Serves mainly an interesting British food type menu, but had some good vegetarian options too.

We found this place on a recent day out whilst on holiday. From the moment we walked through the door we were given a genuine warm welcome. The food was superb. If we didn't live 100 plus miles away this would definitely be a place...

Have been meaning to try The Bay Tree for a while now, and now have finally taken the plunge! Friendly staff, delicious food, great value, nice cosy atmosphere, will be definitely visiting again!

We visited as a group of 8 for a weekday birthday lunch. The pub was quiet, the server really friendly and helpful and the food was excellent. It was a very good experience and we plan to go back again another time.

This is a simple review, I have found that in eating out yo usometimes see pubs and restaurants given reviews that are of a variable quality by people of differing expectations. We chose the Bay Tree because the Tripadvisor reviews were uniformly good and wanted...

Had lunch with a friend yesterday and it was absolutely delicious. We both had the gammon and chips and it was spot on. Generous portions too, so we shared a pudding of the homemade toblerone cheesecake which was out of this world! Really friendly service...

Lovley food young boy was waitering us delightful meal! Was a really nice atsmophere classic old pub!

Lovely, characterful old English cottage pub with restaurant. All table numbers in the form of rabbits all with their own miniature covid masks! Brilliant to find traditional food. Had the finest homemade steak and guinness pie with best ever cheese cake and cream. Lovely meal...

Just popped in today on our way home from Yeovil to Warminster. This is the perfect village pub, small but with a BIG welcome. lovely lady behind the bar and the choice of food was great, real British pub grub. None of the modern so...

Stopped by for some lunch on a work trip, food was absolutely fantastic and the staff and owners all so welcoming. The bay tree is a real hidden gem to visit. Would recommend to anyone. Thanks all!

Visiting family in Cary recently and we decided to come to The Bay Tree as it was recommended to us and it was definitely worth the visit. We had drinks and lovely lunch. The kitchen was amazing and catered to all of our dietary requirements....

On holiday in castle Cary , decided to try a meal at the Bay tree , was welcomed by landlord and all staff on arrival , food and service was excellent, would highly recommend, Mr L Wigham

Wife and i visit here about every 6 weeks or so. always a great menu with a good selection. very enjoyable food; good service and the guv is a caring host who appreciates his customers.

Popped in for lunch and a pint whilst in Castle Cary for the day. Initially tried the George in town but walked out after waiting an age to be served. The Bay Tree is a 5 minute walk out of the main town centre, but...

Called in for dinner whilst staying just across the road. Really nice welcome and very good attentive service throughout. Lovely home cooked food and what good portions. Having shared a starter (we had been advised about the portion size), I had the burger which came...

Had an amazing home delivered takeaway Wednesday evening, arrived piping hot, melt in the mouth steak and ale pie followed by chocolate fudge cake. Lockdown heaven. Just as good as eating in the restaurant.

We visited The Bay Tree for dinner while staying in Castle Cary for the week and can thoroughly recommend this pub. The food was lovely, the staff friendly and welcoming. Nothing was too much trouble. It is proper pub food; not fancy, but honest food...

Meal was delicious, I recommend the beer battered fish and chips. The kids were catered for well, the Sunday roast portions were immense, so my the Grandparents went for a small, which was ample for them. The atmosphere was welcoming and friendly. Plastic dividers between...

We had a delicious meal with great Service and good Covid 19 protections in place.....thank you....this is a lovely little family run freehouse pub and restaurant....do support our local restaurants through these difficult times if you can.

Had a wonderful meal at the Bay Tree. The burgers were some of the best we had eaten in a long time. Staff were very attentive and friendly and they had things very well set up for Covid.Again, the only down side was a lack of local ales which I was expecting and looking forward to. Seems to be a theme for local pubs in Castle Cary. However, this didn't take away from a really lovely evening.

My wife, baby son and I have enjoyed the hospitality of the Bay tree for the last couple of days. The atmosphere and welcome was fantastic. The food was superb quality, beautifully cooked and presented and absolutely delicious. The staff were friendly, professional and kind. The choice of food and drink is extensive - there is something for everyone! We can’t wait to return to the Bay Tree and would heartily recommend you visit here! We particularly enjoyed Tilly the cat and Rocky the parrot!!

We enjoyed our meal but found the menu sadly lacking Far too many chips on menu with just one pasta dish.... lasagne Which I have to say was very nice definitely not memorable but nice We had a NICE evening but wouldn’t return

Our order was taken very quickly, the staff were attentative and overall the quality was very good. Well worth a visit if your in the neighbourhood.

A wonderful country pub - wonderful hosts, fires and ‘house’ cats ! Such a cosy place to spend a few hours - recently moved into the area - what luck that this is now our local !! Food and welcome all you can ask for - Brilliant.

Great menu to choose from. Traditional food that’s cooked to a high quality. Lovely atmosphere. You won’t be disappointed.

I have lived within 3 miles of the Bay Tree and although I have driven past on innumerable occasions, am ashamed to say I have never been inside - until today. What a very enjoyable surprise. Firstly, how can a building be bigger on the inside? Once inside, the greeting is warm and friendly, and the general ambience is very comfortable and relaxing.As for the food, the menu is varied and interesting, with plenty for vegetarians as well as carnivores, and there is a good range of desserts too. What's more, the vegetables were all fresh, with a good variety. That makes a change from a token portion of one or two overcooked vegetables.The biggest surprise of all, was the bill. How they can possibly produce such good food at these prices, I do not know.It is a hidden gem,just not off the beaen path - that's all.

Fabulous meal .been a few times now and not been dissappointed. Good choice including gluten free options / value for money friendly staff with a very warm welcome ..thanku

Had a great time here.Food was excellent, homemade and top quality. Staff were ace and overall experience was second to none. Tend to go out a bit for food and often disappoints but this was one of the best meals I have had in ages.

We had a super tasty Sunday roast today, cheerful and helpful service, sat in the garden with the dogs, Thank you.

Really good service and lovely food. Welcomed on arrival even though the bar was busy. Would recommend a visit

Really enjoyed our visit here. Kevin the publican is super nice. He is very friendly, warm and very, very welcoming. The other staff knew what they were doing and while we did have to wait a little while for the meals, we were kept in the "loop" with accurate information. Ordering Beer Battered Cod was a fairly tame choice but, was probably the best I've ever had. Sampling my companions plates, was only to experience more delights. Good range of drinks available and the other customers friendly too. Well worth diverting off the A303 to visit. Hope to get back there some time. Thank you Kevin, Emily and all the others.

Coped well with a number of people for Sunday dinner. Excellent value. We were all offered the smaller roast, but all declined. Loads of meat and veg, and we were wrong as there was some left over. Up to 3 meats for 10.95 excellent and even allowed my little boy a taster so he could pick his favourite pudding. (Lemon meringue won). Staff were nice and friendly and no rush to get us out at the end.

This was a pre-booked birthday meal for 18 of us , we were asked to pre order our meals . On arrival we were greeted by Kevin (the owner) who helped us get a disabled member of our party in. The table was all ready for us including 2 high chairs for the babies . The food was swiftly served, it was hot , fresh and beautifully served . We were all served together so no waiting for others to get their food , we could all eat together , they even served one meal as a take away as one of our party was fasting. Nothing was too much trouble , they even gave the birthday girl a card . Well worth a visit for anyone local or visiting the area

Staff very friendly, fantastic service good quality food. Great size portions, you will not leave hungry. Nice gardens. Def recommend it.

Friday evening with the Family or Saturday night with friends visiting; always looked after very well. Lovely country Pub with the added bonus of a dining room for good food.

This is the second I have eaten here and the Sunday roast is excellent, well cooked choice of meat, beef, pork, turkey and chicken. Beautifully cooked vegetables and roast potatoes. Excellent friendly service. Tip if you haven’t got a huge appetite op for the small portion even that is plenty of meat and vegetables. Choice of deserts is fantastic as well. Highly recommend

Had a wonderful meal in this great old style pub. Guinness and ale pie was superb, smoked haddock was very nice. Excellent service, friendly people, totally recommended.

Super friendly, great atmosphere. If wandering around Castle Cary a must visit. Chat to the landlord, he knows everything about the town.

Excellent, friendly staff who make you welcome. The food is well prepared and presented home cooking with Sunday lunch being a speciality. Don’t miss it.

We have again had a very good roast Sunday lunch at the Bay Tree, freshly cooked food and a nice pub atmosphere . A very big thank you to Tracey and Troy for Mums treat (and mine) very good value for money and a good pint. A big thank you to all the staff

Returned many times as we enjoy the freshly cooked tasty food. Great selection on the menu and alternatives on the specials board. Great place to take friends when they come to visit. Exceptional waitress Jamie Lee looks after the diners very well.

This old pub has a cozy, friendly atmosphere. The staff are so helpful. The food, all we tried, was delicious.

Good wholesome pub food. Fabulous Sunday roast. Warm friendly welcome. The staff are brilliant and attentive bringing service which is superb

Having visited the Bay Tree today we enjoyed our meal so much I felt it was a must to do a review.

A group of 20+ went to the Bay Tree last night for a meal for a meal.

Great with young kids as a very relaxed environment. Staff very friendly. Had the pork medallions and lemon meringue pie - both vsimple, yet very tasty. Children very happy with the kids menu. Street parking outside.

We booked a table at this warm and inviting restaurant/pub, we had visited previously and the food was again of the highest quality and we were well looked after we sat by the table of six by the log fire and all 4 of us really enjoyed the food on offer. Excellent steak & Guinness pies and beef,stilton and port pie was the choice of the day. Lovely plentiful vegetables with lashings of tasty gravy. Well recommended for excellent food and service

Excellent evening at this warm, friendly pub, serving delicious home cooked food in generous portions. Staff all local and a real joy to be served by younger adults who really engaged. Go there if in the area, you will not regret it

It is difficult theses days to find a straight forward, no nonsense pub. No fancy menus just good food. A warm and welcoming atmosphere, with prices reasonable. This pub and its landlord is an asset to Castle Cary.

This is one of my favourite places to eat, the food is delicious, served in large portions, in particular the roast dinner and the toblerone cheesecake, and the service is excellent.

The B.B. we were staying in recommended this pub. As soon as we walked into this pub we were greeted by a very happy & friendly landlord, it was a lovely clean pub, they had a great menu, prices were very reasonable, we did not have to wait long for our food, it was so nice, cooked beautifully, all the time the lovely landlord made sure we were ok, a wonderful experience, highly recommend this place.

Friendly landlord and staff. I had the haddock and mozzarella fish cakes with chunky chips. Hubby had the scampi. We shared a toblerone cheesecake which was delicious. Thatchers ciders on tap. Will return and recommend.

Friendly pub serving great basic food and good service. Interesting menu and the toblerone cheese cake was yummy. Ticks all the boxes for me.

Lovely atmosphere, great food, at the top of town, worth a visit easy to go into if you are on your own as everyone so friendly they make you feel very welcome.

A fantastic pub, great beer and brilliant service. We were visiting family and went in for food which was also great. I fully recommend you give this place a try if you are in the area.

We pop in here on occasion when our visitors come down to see us. Always a great selection on offer. Friendly staff; most enjoyable meals, would give this 5 stars at any time.

2 days on the trot and still as good , definitely recommend .wish there was something so good locally to us

Food was great, but the best thing was the service. We arrived for a late lunch with our toddler who ran around the pub very excited about the cats and the coasters. The staff were really relaxed and we were able to enjoy ourselves and not feel like a an inconvenience. Thank you!

We had a lovely time at The Bay Tree. Our dog was made welcome, & we sat in the garden, on a warm evening.

First time at the Bay Tree and we will be going back , food and service very good a

It was my daughters birthday and me and my fiancee thought we would treat her to an excellent meal at The Bay Tree and we weren't disappointed. The steak and Guinness pie was the order of the day for the three of us and as before beautiful. All three of us tucked in to their delicious deserts and a bottle of prosecco to wash it down absolutely scrummy

We had a wonderful time at The Bay Tree on a warm Saturday afternoon in May. The restaurant opened by special arrangement for a large group of adults and children of all ages (as part of a touring band “On The Raggedy Edge”). We pre-arranged the menu choices, which ranged from starters of garlic mushrooms, tomato and basil soup, cheesy garlic bread, and fish cakes - all very good. The mains also covered a wide variety of steak, pie, fish, chicken and vegetarian options - all superb and delicious! The chunky chips were a particular favourite and the kids meals were also much appreciated. The portions were generous and the prices were very reasonable. Thank you to The Bay Tree - you exceeded our expectations!

The Bay Tree is a very welcoming pub. We had a great meal. The menu is simple but all the food was very tasty and the portions are generous. Well worth a visit.

Really nice meal in a friendly pub with good pub food. Lots of choice on the menu plus extra on the specials board. Recommended.

Having read the reviews submitted for meals served here, we decided to have the Fish and Chips. We were disappointed despite it being well presented. The fish appeared to be a typical frozen fillet. Chips were well cooked and there was a choice of mushy/garden peas. Service was very good and very friendly.

took my dad out to Haynes motor museum for his bday and went here after to finish off out lovely day. we were a group of 9 adults 2 toddlers and a baby, so a roudy bunch to say the least. the food, staff, atmosphere were most welcoming and not one of us went away hungry! can honestly recommend the jacket potatoes, steak and pies!! really really good value for money and a lovely place. if we lived closer would be freqency visitors!! only downside is parking, there is a small car park at the back and a few street parking spaces so on a busy day I'm not sure where you would park.

Only live a short distance a way but never tried this restaurant. Food was great, service was great and setting superb. Really enjoyed our time here and a real bonus the prices were reasonable. The service was both friendly and swift, nothing was to much trouble and all 5 of us were impressed.

Just love this place, have been coming here for 3 years, the food is excellent home cooked meals. The atmosphere is very friendly as are all the staff. Really can’t recommend this pub enough.