GastroRanking
GastroRanking header logo
whatsappWhatsapp
phoneCall
desktopWebsite
menuMenu
bookingBooking
4,5

Based on 575 opinions finded in 1 websites

4.5Cuisine4.5Price4.5Service
site_photo4
Score
OpinionsNoteTripAdvisor5754.5

comment_iconOpinions

During our stay in Edinburgh we have eaten in many restaurants and would like to mention that Pibroch is our favourite one, by far! We very much liked the dishes but also the very friendly service staff. We will come back for sure!

site_logo

TomZ8000 . 2020-03-22

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Piccolo ristorante a ridosso del centro. Solo complimenti, ottimi piatti scozzesi ben fatti ed abbondanti. Servizio gentile e disponibile. Buon rapporto qualità/prezzo. Siamo stati lì in febbraio 2019.Da provare l'haggis e mi raccomando prenotate!!!

site_logo

FrancescoNot . 2020-03-18

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Établissement atypique, les repas sont essentiellement des spécialités écossaises, les serveurs et serveuses sont très accueillant. Très bien

site_logo

franckb797 . 2020-03-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We visited as we wanted to eat Scottish & were stunned at how good this place is. Smiling, friendly & knowledgeable waiting staff are complimented by superb chefs & quality produce. I had the Cullen Skink which was the best soup I think I’ve ever eaten. I followed this with the chicken dish. To begin with I thought it was a tad sweet but then I added the haggis to my forkful (as the chef no doubt intended) & the combination of flavours was perfection! This place is very special - give it a try.

site_logo

WJB141 . 2020-03-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I picked this restaurant for a special birthday meal for my husband. From the moment we arrived we were made welcome. The decor is nice, and the music adds to the Scottish atmosphere. The food is lovely and the wine list, though short, has something for most tastes, at a reasonable price. The service was excellent and I was only sorry I couldn't accommodate one of the delicious-sounding desserts!

site_logo

L9628GIsusanw . 2020-03-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We went a bit early - 7pm - so it was a bit quiet when we arrived, but by the main course it was starting to fill up.For starters we tried the haggis parcels - pieces of haggis wrapped in filo pasty with a spicy fruity sauce. Oddly went together! Next I had the beef and ale pie - really very tasty and melt in the mouth beef - but such an enormous portion. Half would have been enough!

site_logo

137tinar . 2020-03-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Très bon restaurant avec spécialités écossaises, cuisine avec produits de qualité, personnel sympathique, service rapide

site_logo

74maguy . 2020-03-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

My daughter and I made this restaurant our destination for our first meal in Scotland after reading the TripAdvisor reviews. It's a small intimate restaurant with a small but wonderful selection of Scottish fare, but with a twist added by the chef. We are adventurist diners so we were keen to try anything. This is not a place I would take a family since you will not find mainstays like fish and chips, but if you want a lovely atmosphere with personable service, and a chef who looks out the window to monitor your pleasure with his creations, this is a restaurant to try.

site_logo

PamelaWestM . 2020-03-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

The restaurant was very busy which is always a good sign. The menu is quite limited which we like as it usually means the food is fresh. Most of the dishes are Scottish which we wanted. The service was good without being intrusive of pushy and they did check that all was OK. I had the lamb rump and there must have been the bet part of a pound of meat. The portions were generous. Pricewise, not the cheapest but good value. We would definitely go again when up in Edinburgh

site_logo

Crawford49 . 2020-03-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Une cuisine écossaise délicieuse tout en restant correcte du côté du porte monnaie. La panse de brebis farcie est excellente.

site_logo

ben78380 . 2020-03-07

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Επισκεφτήκαμε δυο φορές το εστιατόριο . Εχει πιάτα Σκωτσέζικης παραδοσιακής μαγειρικής. Το φαγητά πεντανόστιμα , μεγαλες μερίδες και ικανοποιητικές τιμές. Καλη εξυπηρετηση και φιλικό περιβάλλον!

site_logo

panagiotam791 . 2020-03-03

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had a very good dinner with a large group of friends. Especially the lamb was great! Service was good. Wouldn’t hurt to dim the light a bit. Location is slightly out of the city center but certainly on walking distance.

site_logo

orbond1 . 2020-03-02

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Cotture a timer, porzioni belle, servizio giovane e professionale. Abbiamo mangiato da Dio, l'antipasto con il black pudding del mio amico aveva sopra un poached egg perfetto, significa che lo chef c'ha il manico. 30 sterline a testa antipasto main course birra e side dish, usciti scoppiando. Consigliatissimo.

site_logo

Matteo B . 2020-02-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had a superb dinner in this excellent restaurant. Very cozy, friendly staff and incredibly welcoming atmosphere. We went for the Scottish dishes in the menu and they were amazing!

site_logo

Nir O . 2020-02-27

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Sublime food, quick and friendly service - you really get the feeling that the people who work there both know the (excellent) food and are proud to be a part of it. Excellent in every way.

site_logo

timh160 . 2020-02-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

This is a bit off the main drag but is well worth a visit for traditional Scottish food. The atmosphere was great with plenty of tartan and pipe music. The staff are really friendly and helpful with meal advice. I can’t recommend the Haggis parcels and the beef and ale pie enough! Best meal I’ve had in Scotland

site_logo

T378GEdavidc . 2020-02-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Brilliant got a few bits of the order wrong, but no fuss made & sorted easily. Food was very tasty and full of flavor

site_logo

moi4567 . 2020-02-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great ambience, the food was amazing haggis, Cullen skunk soup, salmon , steaks and home made pies. Great Scottish staff with a fabulous sense of humour as a party of 8 they made us very welcome and nothing was too much trouble, Highly recommend.

site_logo

angel1234091 . 2020-02-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

While on short trip to Edinburgh (4 days) we visited Pibroch twice and glad we did. The food is excellent, tasty and well presented, proving they have excellent chefs who take pride in what they serve. A good range of wines and drinks, especially whisky as would be expected when in Edinburgh. The staff at front of house are very friendly and the level of service they give is exceptional. This is a lovely restaurant but make sure you book as it can get busy,

site_logo

Adrian F . 2020-02-18

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Went in early at 6:20 pm and decided it was lacking any atmosphere with only one table eating, so we all met up at The Holyrood 9A which is almost opposite. Plenty going on here, with excitement and good service. Went back to Pibroch at 7:30 the time our table was booked. A few more diners, but with identical tables in a grid, canned bagpipe music and an old set of bagpipes on the wall (just in case you don’t know the connection) it wasn’t very alive. The waiter was pleasant enough but not engaging. Our party of 5 hardly changed the funerary mood of the Pibroch.

site_logo

Simon14Says . 2020-02-18

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Lot of what a call touristy restaurants in Edinburgh. As half a tourist really enjoyed Scottish flavour and choice. Food was excellent. Also would point out it was the night of storm Ciara - heave rain - shortage of taxis as rugby was on. We called to sat running late - not a problem for them.

site_logo

Geoffrey D . 2020-02-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had lunch in this typical Scottish restaurant and we really enjoy our meal. Food and the beers were good, the place is warm and quiet. Honest price and very kind service.

site_logo

I6952LFirenep . 2020-02-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We booked this restaurant for the 14th February , and were delighted that they steered away from the rip off ‘Valentine’s’ set menus that abound on this day ! The menu was great and it for a difficult choice , what to have ! I opted for haggis parcels and Cullen skunk for my main both were delicious . My husband had the black pudding and beetroot starter . I tried the black pudding and it was amazing .He then had the lamb , which he raved about .The staff were delightful and very nice, making it a wonderful evening

site_logo

warrenswitch . 2020-02-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Last minute booking with the family, the staff were extremely friendly and the food was very tasty. Will be returning.

site_logo

Campingto5star . 2020-02-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

If you are new to Scotland/Edinburgh, you need to visit Pibroch. Pictures tell it’s own story! Happy dining :)

site_logo

rdevlin442 . 2020-02-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

this was an excellent find. will definately go again as the menu was awesome. when asked for advise it was very informative and helpful. when we visit again it will be our first choice. Its basic inside but the food and staff doing it justice. Food served very quickly once ordered. We found out on leaving that we had been served my the manager and he was so cheerful and funny, im sure his business will be very successful. I cant wait to go back. Never had haggis or whiskey before and both when tried was lovely. We never got to look at the desserts as we both had starters, the blackpudding and beetroot with poached egg as a starter (hubby) and I had cullen skink......WOW as we were so full. I would highly recommend this place

site_logo

slimbikerchicnan . 2020-02-07

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Locale accogliente a gestione famigliare, gentili e disponibili. Menu e prezzi in linea con lo standard della cucina scozzese. I piatti molto abbondanti e il cibo direi molto buono. Da consigliate

site_logo

robertadC9362TO . 2020-02-02

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Lovely poached egg and black pudding followed by beautifully cooked rump of lamb. Couldn’t resist the tarte tatin. Including a bottle of Malbec was £83. Very good value. No pretensions here, just good food. Friendly staff as well which is always good.

site_logo

Heyhey49de . 2020-01-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had booked for an early dinner during the Fringe, so when we arrived the restaurant was pretty empty. The starters were very average, though the pate was served with a tiny amount of very soggy toast. The steak pie mains were an improvement, but overall nothing to write home about. The setting was quite cool and pleasant, with lots of dark wood.

site_logo

bunnyofdarkness . 2020-01-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We were in town kilt shopping so stopped in for an impromptu lunch.

site_logo

Helen C . 2020-01-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Non è in centro ma vale la pena fare una passeggiata per raggiungerlo! Locale tipico, molto carino, atmosfera rilassante. Abbiamo cenato in tre, porzioni abbondanti e cibo di qualità. Il servizio eccellente. La "Scottish Beef and Edinburgh Ale Pie" con patate, abbondante e buona; la "Scottish Salmon Fish Cakes" deliziosa; l"Aubergine Tart" favolosa. Il dolce, "Sticky Ginger and Date Pudding" abbondante e buonissimo! Merita!

site_logo

LUCA369 . 2020-01-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Accueil charmant restaurant moderne avec des touches écossaises. Cuisine délicieuse et écossaise. Choix de bière important.

site_logo

182eliab . 2020-01-22

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Cibo scozzese tipico con porzioni abbondanti, locale tipico (non pub), c’è spazio tra i tavoli grandi, personale gentile e veloce. Prezzi onesti. Molto consigliato. Un po’ fuori dal centro. Buonissimo il dessert

site_logo

B93437 . 2020-01-15

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Amazing fresh food. Had the fish soup for which was the best we have had. My friend had the lamb and I had the salmon, cooked to perfection. Staff very attentive and lovely, I really recommend this place. Thank you for a wonderful meal

site_logo

Englangteacher . 2020-01-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

This restaurant took my haggis virginity and I couldn’t have asked for a more thoughtful provider.

site_logo

AietChalkers . 2020-01-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Il locale è piccolino e il personale è molto friendly.

site_logo

perfezi0nista . 2020-01-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

In the heart of the University Campus area, Pibroch restaurant offers tasty traditional Scottish dishes. Absolutely awesome. Excellent service and super friendly and charming staff.

site_logo

Andrea C . 2020-01-06

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Très bon accueil et service de qualité, agencement de la salle permettant une intimité. Du choix dans les spécialités écossaises.

site_logo

Peggy Z . 2020-01-05

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Best meal to be had in Edinburgh over the Christmas New Year period. Choose whatever you fancy from the menu, you won't go wrong! Lamb Rump was to die for and the Cullen Skink, simply magnificent. Finished off with a Rusty Nail, perfect.

site_logo

stevencM7503SH . 2020-01-03

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Ristorante piccolo ma molto curato, abbiamo preso due zuppe di antipasto favolose e due main a base di filetto scozzese, cura nei dettagli ed ingredienti di qualità. Prezzo giusto, personale attento e cordiale.

site_logo

crive_fabio . 2020-01-02

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Booked in advance and only just got table over the Hogmanay period. Homely feel, good service, Scottish decor, maybe more suited to tourists however the food was beautiful. The haggis was a big hit with our party, as was the lovely honey roasted root vegetables (carrots & parsnips). WC very clean. Fairly priced. Will probably go back on our next visit to Edinburgh. Go and try it!

site_logo

thewatts88 . 2020-01-02

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Ristorante piccolino con ottima atmosfera! Buona attenzione verso i clienti! L’acqua fatevela portare in caraffa anziché in bottiglia così evitate di strapagarla! Assaggiate l’antipasto di haggies...è favoloso! L’unica cosa quando abbiamo pagato il cameriere ci ha detto: “posso tenere il resto?” Beh diciamo che sarebbe stato più educato portare il resto e se il cliente vuole lasciare la mancia sarà lui a dirlo. No? Comunque è consigliato! Prezzi in linea con la città

site_logo

Alice D . 2020-01-01

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Enjoyed a spot of lunch here yesterday. Received a warm welcome and were seated quickly, the food was excellent, prices reasonable and service very good. Would definitely recommend and go back.

site_logo

Paul C . 2019-12-31

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Sono stato con mia moglie 2 volte in questo locale molto carino con personale estremamente gentile. La prima volta abbiamo preso 2 zuppe (kullen) eccezionali poi del manzo e patate (buono). Il secondo giorno abbiamo giustamente bissato con le zuppe seguite da assaggio di haggis (buoni) Birre artigianali alla spina di ottimo livello. Prezzo contenuto.

site_logo

fabrizio724 . 2019-12-31

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Merita sicuramente una sosta per assaggiare piatti gustosi, saporiti e con una buona materia prima.

site_logo

SENTIMENTOOVERLAND . 2019-12-31

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Un po' fuori mano rispetto alle solite vie turistiche, abbiamo mangiato molto bene in un ambiente tranquillo e cordiale. Possibile prenotare anche online. Prezzo nella media

site_logo

littleje84 . 2019-12-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Lovely no frills cosy restaurant in the Old Town . Service was excellent and the staff were very friendly and attentive .

site_logo

JimT40 . 2019-12-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Haggis excellent, relevé et fin. Tourte au bœuf délicieuse ainsi que les autres plats de la carte. Cuisine fine, personnel souriant, belle décoration du restaurant, ça vaut le détour !

site_logo

505ma_t_b . 2019-12-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We prebooked this place after reading reviews and we were not disappointed.Great choice from the menu, good portion sizes and the food was absolutely fantastic. Good wine choice. We thought excellent value for money with great quality food.

site_logo

treesy74 . 2019-12-21

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I've walked past this restaurant a few times when staying at the MacDonald Holyrood Hotel. Given it was a cold December evening we didn't want to stray too far and decided on a whim to see if they had a free table, fortunately they did!

site_logo

minstermen15 . 2019-12-19

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Ottimo ristorante scozzese nel centro di Edimburgo

site_logo

italians1383 . 2019-12-17

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We were referred to Pibroch by the staff at the Scotsman Hotel. Couldn't have been more pleased.

site_logo

ltcterry2006 . 2019-12-17

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Great food and fantastic service....very accommodating to my girlfriend who is celiac. Offered a wide range for her and all the other dishes were great too! Definitely worth a visit

site_logo

Q4271YYjamesl . 2019-12-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Abbiamo cenato in questo ristorante perché desideravamo provare piatti tipici della cucina scozzese. Il locale è molto carino, non molto grande, ma intimo, con mutata scozzese in sottofondo. Ho assaggiato il filetto scozzese ben cotto e cucinato davvero bene. Mio marito ha preso un'ottima zuppa di pesce. Birra locale e infine un dolce di mele molto buono.

site_logo

MonicaLZ . 2019-12-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

This restaurant was perfect! The food was incredible (especially the haggis filo parcels), the service was superb (so friendly and welcoming) and the atmosphere was really nice.

site_logo

Traveller20176476886 . 2019-12-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

3rd time here and another fabulous evening. Took my partner for his birthday. Fabulous food and atmosphere and staff. I will be back!

site_logo

julierQ7432MK . 2019-12-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We were looking for traditional scotish cuisine and this was definetly a great find! Super friendly staff they were very helpful. Very centric location and the food was delicious.

site_logo

polazz . 2019-12-05

MORE AT TripAdvisor

What a lovely find! Wonderful little place serving top quality food in abundance by warm, welcoming staff. I made a last minute online booking here searching for somewhere quiet(er) to eat on my own whilst travelling with work. This place was the perfect solution.

site_logo

From-Where-I-Stand . 2019-12-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Prenotato direttamente tramite Tripadvisor dall'Italia, locale un po' decentrato, in una zona di uffici e musei. Locale moderno, con pochi coperti, atmosfera molto tranquilla e distanze corrette tra i tavoli (non consueto per Edimburgo...), servizio rapido e molto professionale .

site_logo

F6230ROriccardom . 2019-12-03

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Had a delicious meal with great friendly service from the team. Meals were bought in a timely manner, not rushed but no waiting. Fantastic and will be back next time were in Edinburgh!

site_logo

Gingergall . 2019-12-03

MORE AT TripAdvisor

In visita a Edinburgo per il weekend, ho voluto concedermi una cena scozzese e al Pibroch si é rivelata del tutto adatta ai miei desideri. Personale gentilissimo, servizio veloce, e menu per tutti i gusti. Apprezzata la musica tipica non troppo alta e il locale elegante con stile scozzese. Il prezzo é nella media se si pensa al rapporto qualità prezzo.

site_logo

Stefania C . 2019-12-02

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Io e il mio ragazzo decidiamo di concludere la nostra vacanza a edimburgo in questo ristorante consigliatoci da una famiglia italiana la sera prima.

site_logo

umbertobelle . 2019-12-02

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I really enjoyed my visit to Pibroch. The food was delicious, the service was excellent, the restaurant was nicely decorated and very the staff were very welcoming. Would recommend!

site_logo

connoje . 2019-11-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

This restaurant was recommended to us and lived up to all expectations. Haggis, soups and steak pies are on the top of the menu. Don’t miss it. Great customer service

site_logo

ColAIDenison . 2019-11-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Superbe restaurant où l’on peut manger des plats typiques écossais. Très chaleureux et des plats succulents ! Nous nous sommes vraiment régalés. Belle ambiance et personnel très sympa.

site_logo

Explorer764173 . 2019-11-27

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We enjoyed a delicious meal, in a tastefully decorated restaurant. Modern yet maintaining traditional Scottish themes. We had between us the salmon fish cakes, haggis parcels and chicken liver parfait - all very very good. To follow we had roast lamb in rosemary jus (delicious) and duck with black cherry sauce (also delicious). All well presented, served by friendly staff. Would definitely recommend.

site_logo

Lisabette82 . 2019-11-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

C'était un midi en semaine et malheureusement nous n'étions que 2, mon fils et moi.

site_logo

LOUNAGASPAR74 . 2019-11-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Called in without reservation (mid week) offered choice of table. Very good meal nicely cooked and well presented, service was great, nice relaxed atmosphere, lovely choices on a small menu. Cullen skink was excellent.

site_logo

debraA22 . 2019-11-21

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Per chiudere la nostra vacanza decidiamo di cenare l'ultima sera in questo ristorante.

site_logo

lucalauri2019 . 2019-11-20

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Siamo stati qui una domenica sera, raccomando la prenotazione, specie al venerdì o sabato. La carne squisita, sia l'agnello che il manzo. I prezzi dei piatti principali vanno dalle 15 alle 20 £. Un po' alti, anche perché le porzioni sono nella media, però la qualità merita. Anche i

site_logo

332enricad . 2019-11-19

MORE AT TripAdvisor

What a sublime place this is The rump of lamb was perfect. As well as the Scottish beef fillet. Haggis parcels to start. YUMM!!

site_logo

angelchain . 2019-11-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

5 star friendly service as always and one of my favourite restaurants! Haggis starter is exceptional and the staff are always welcoming! Favourite spot for tourists and locals and I enjoy bringing my family from the states here every time they visit especially my auntie who becomes very nostalgic of her youth before she moved abroad.

site_logo

CharlieBr2189 . 2019-11-11

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Credo che non ci sia molto di meglio per provare la cucina tradizionale Scozzese, altissima qualità, cortesia, semplicità e prezzi corretti.

site_logo

MMarzo . 2019-11-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

After our initial restaurant choice was closed we decided on here. So incredibly happy we did as everyone was so welcoming and the place looked amazing. Very family friendly as we had 2 young children too. Food was delicious, perfect size portions. We had a full 3 course and what can I say except it was marvellous. If we get asked where to eat in Edinburgh we will definitely recommend!

site_logo

Elginlassie . 2019-11-10

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Food here was true scottish fayre

site_logo

kourky . 2019-11-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Came here while visiting family in Edinburgh. Thoroughly enjoyed it - we all did! Haggis starter was amazing - loved the sauce! Then I had the steak pie - made the proper Scottish way with the pastry on top! Just as good as my granny’s.

site_logo

islandhopper2223 . 2019-11-05

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Cena perfetta sotto tutti i punti di vista: locale in old town, personale gentile, cena per due a base di stufato scozzese e torta di melanzane e caprino, innaffiati da ottima birra alla spina. Due dolci e un conto di 57 sterline in due. Da provare.

site_logo

472claudioc . 2019-11-02

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Booked Pilbroch as we wanted some traditional Scottish food on our first night in Edinburgh. Did not disappoint at all and we had a fantastic meal.

site_logo

611leeg . 2019-10-31

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Monday evening we were let down by our hotel so started a wander of the streets to find a restaurant. What an amazing find. The chef gave us a wink through the serving hatch, the staff were so friendly. We were excited just by the menu and the feel of the place without even seeing or eating any food! A good choice of dishes and portion sizes. Sadly it was our last night in the city, I would have gone back for more.

site_logo

LynnGo1 . 2019-10-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Walked in by chance on Monday eve. Fairly busy but ok for 4 more. Great welcome from the front of house staff and just got better. Locally brewed beers on tap for a per dinner drink - lovely. Cullen skink superb, chicken liver parfait was rich and lovely. the duck was beautifully cooked (and I am fussy about this) and the pies were very very good. Puddings were also rich and lovely especially the cranachan . All in all a great night out with cheerful but professional staff which I would highly recommend to anyone

site_logo

Chris G . 2019-10-30

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Enjoyed my meal her with the family including a 5yr old. The waiters and waitresses were very helpful and my wife who is dairy and gluten free had no problems choosing something to eat.

site_logo

James1712 . 2019-10-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We decided to try this Scottish restaurant on our first night in Edinburgh. On entering the restaurant, it was empty, save for a couple of occupied tables. Room galore to spare. "Have ye booked?" growled the waiter. "No", I replied timidly, thinking that maybe I should have booked, as it may well get full with people who had reservations. But this was a dreich late October Monday evening - how many couples were venturing out on a night like this? We were eventually sat down, we enjoyed the food and drinks, but at no time during the evening did any other couples turn up to claim their bookings, so the restaurant was still half empty. Bad practice, which detracted from the overall experience. I could understand asking about bookings at the height of the season, but at quieter times, simple maths would tell the waiters how many free tables were available.

site_logo

Thirdface . 2019-10-25

MORE AT TripAdvisor

My group of 34 travelers had a private dinner here to kick off our tour. Amazing amazing!!! I appreciated the presentation of history and of course the whiskey tasting!

site_logo

travelbybeth . 2019-10-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

A gentle little gem of a restaurant. Traditional Scottish food that is not pretentious, yet well presented and flavoursome.

site_logo

ericmZ3357PV . 2019-10-16

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Personlig restaurang med mat med lite twist. Servicen är uppmärksam och prisnivån i linje med de flesta restauranger. Ljudnivån är aningen hög, men det tycker vi äldre ju ofta :) Kan verkligen rekommendera den. Bra läge också!

site_logo

Benny02 . 2019-10-14

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Fuimos bajo recomendacion del hotel Town Hill Place, lancomoda es sinplemente fantastica, el pate de entrada es una delicia al igual que el cordero o cualquier otra carne, buenos whiskies también

site_logo

FrequentFlier723821 . 2019-10-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We wanted to eat traditional Scottish food at least once whilst in Edinburgh. I’m so glad we picked Pibroch. The food was excellent as was.the service.

site_logo

HelenK1975 . 2019-10-13

MORE AT TripAdvisor

My experience didn't match the rating of trip advisor. Food and service was okay but felt like I was in a pub rather than a restaurant.

site_logo

chrisfowleredin . 2019-10-12

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Every dish we had was as good or better than anything meal in our 5 days in Edinburgh. Great! I was tempted to give a 5 but it was a little short on atmosphere compared to other restaurants. It was fine, but could have been any nice restaurant anywhere. A little out of the way (only a little) but the fod is worth it.

site_logo

Trek769599 . 2019-10-09

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Fuimos por las recomendaciones de TripAdvisor y acertamos, las sopas buenísimas y las carnes exquisitas , no es barato pero merece la pena, el personal muy amable y paciente porque llegamos un poco tarde y nos atendieron muy bien

site_logo

lolastra . 2019-10-04

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Se non volete mangiare nei soliti locali per turisti e volete invece provare la cucina locale. Buona scelta di birre e piatti tipici, cortesia e prezzi nella media.

site_logo

Fabio P . 2019-09-29

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Fuimos a cenar. Los camareros fueron muy amables y nos aconsejaron muy bien. Si vas en fin de semana mejor reservar mesa,no es muy grande. La relación calidad precio, buena.

site_logo

Sightseer740204 . 2019-09-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

A large group of us came here for dinner and we were ordering from a set menu

site_logo

991udayt . 2019-09-28

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We had a lovely meal and found it very difficult to decide what to select from the lovely menu. Great Scottish food, very well presented, nice service and a lovely relaxing evening. Very nice restaurant.

site_logo

Gauldie2015 . 2019-09-27

MORE AT TripAdvisor

I had haggis for the first time here and the dish was absolutely delicious. The waitstaff was friendly and the wine was good as well. Making a reservation would be a good idea, but they do also seat without reservations.

site_logo

caitlinm1991 . 2019-09-26

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Lauren the sever was awesome, ( good luck with your next step ) food was really flavorful and good. I was apprehensive to try haggis, but told server to bring me her favorite, I am so sorry I did not try this sooner.

site_logo

yorock1 . 2019-09-24

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Ci sono tutti gli ingredienti per consigliare questo ristorante. Location deliziosa, appena fuori dal trambusto e con il personale assolutamente cordiale e accogliente.

site_logo

Clao77 . 2019-09-24

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Warm and friendly. A good late Sunday dinner for four after a long drive.The service was very good and the ingredients used; Lamb, Steak, Salmon and Haggis were good quality. The ambiance and location make this a very easy to access restaurant for anyone staying off Canongate or the Mile. Booking is probably a very good idea as it's a popular spot.

site_logo

Airstream56 . 2019-09-24

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Buon ristorante tipicamente scozzese con una calda accoglienza.Ci sono ritornata perché ho potuto gustare la tipica cucina scozzese. Buon rapporto qualità/prezzo

site_logo

magomerlino59 . 2019-09-23

MORE AT TripAdvisor

We returned from our all day tour to our wonderful Airbnb and found this Resturant within a block. We walked in without a reservation on a Saturday evening. The staff was accommodating and found us a table. We both had the Scottish Pie which was excellent. Good selection of beers. Reservations recommended as seating is limited. We would go back.

site_logo

Mike W . 2019-09-21

MORE AT TripAdvisor

Similary restaurants in Edinburgh and Lothian

restaurant_img
4,5

759 Opinions

The Bonningtonlocation-icon284 Bonnington RoadScottish

I was pretty baffled at the experience I had here this week- I understand that this is a pub environment however, frankly, it's quite a nice pub, and I had been looking forward to coming here for food and some drinks. After a general bad attitude from one member of staff in particular, he decided to come over and rudely say 'there are coasters at the table you can use you know' whilst snatching our menus away. For context, at this moment, I scanned the room and not a single other person in there had a coaster under their drink. One of us had a corner of our glass on one of the menus without realising which, while I understand is irritating for the owners of said menu, I do not believe justifies rudeness to customers. I have worked in customer service and hospitality my whole life and have seen a lot worse be done to such items but still, I would never consider being outright rude. After we asked him if 'he would mind throwing a couple over', he again, rudely turned around and said 'what did your last slave die of?' before walking away. We left immediately and decided not to eat anything. Now, I really do have a personal belief that if you're going to take out your disdain towards life on the general public, customer service isn't really the career for you. It's very concerning when staff clearly get enjoyment out of being rude to people and putting a sour taste on their day. I will make sure to tell everyone I know to avoid this long haired, ponytailed, dark-haired, glasses-wearing man at all costs if they so happen to stumble into this establishment.

salmonmustfilletsteakpuddingoldsoupduckpastrycookedfishchocolategingerpielamb